THE 1995 RUGBY World Cup was memorable for so many reasons. While there was the euphoria and symbolic power of South Africa’s defeat of New Zealand in the final in what was the first major post-apartheid sporting event that the former country had hosted, this celebration of all that was good about the game was also tinged with sadness.
While the tournament was filled with stars such as Jonah Lomu, Michael Lynagh and Will Carling, there were also countless obscure players with the so-called lesser countries that even hardcore fans of the game were unlikely to have heard of.
Max Brito was one of the less well-known participants to feature in the competition, appearing for Ivory Coast, the only other African team competing that year aside from the eventual winners.
The 1995 Rugby World Cup is regarded by many as the symbolic beginning of the professional era in rugby, but regardless, no player involved at the time was earning the kind of lucrative wages that many modern stars enjoy.
Brito was no exception — in addition to playing for Biscarrosse Olympique in the Fédérale 3 division of French rugby, he worked as an electrician.
Not many people expected Ivory Coast to have much of an impact on the competition given their lack of a rugby-playing tradition compared with other sides, and so it proved. They lost their opening two games — 89-0 to Scotland and 54-18 to France respectively — exiting the tournament at the earliest possible stage as a result.
Going into the third match, on 3 June 1995, Tonga had also been beaten twice, rendering the game a dead rubber, with both teams no longer having a chance of progression to the knockout stages. Brito was making just his third appearance for Ivory Coast at test level, and his second start in the competition, having featured in the first XV against France and as a substitute in the opening loss to Scotland.
After just three minutes of this encounter, however, an incident occurred that would overshadow everything that followed. Brito, playing on the wing, caught hold of a high ball. He ventured forward before being tackled by Tongan flanker Inoke Afeaki. As the play continued, a ruck formed over Brito and subsequently collapsed as he lay prone on the ground, with several players falling on top of the Ivorian as a result.
The seriousness of the injury that resulted was soon apparent. Brito was motionless on the ground for a sustained period as he awaited medical attention before being carried off on a stretcher.
The 24-year-old had suffered a broken vertebrae and was swiftly brought to the intensive care unit of the Unitas Hospital in Pretoria. Yet despite operations undertaken in an attempt to stabilise the fourth and fifth vertebrae, the incident ultimately left Brito paralysed below the neck.
Brito was given compensation following the accident, with every team who participated in the tournament contributing to the cause. Nonetheless, the scale of what has been described as ‘the greatest tragedy in World Cup history’ only grew thereafter. Ever since the incident, Brito has largely been bedridden and confined to a wheelchair.
A 2007 interview with Le Monde portrayed an individual deep in despair 12 years on from the accident, or “my curse” as he referred to it
“I have come to the end of my tether,” he is quoted as saying. “If one day I fall seriously ill, and if I have the strength and courage to take my own life, then I will do it.”
The ex-player, even after 12 years, could only move his head, upper body and one arm. His wife had left him, while his teenage sons, he claimed, only visited him “to take money off me so they can go out and buy things”.
Warning: The following video contains images that some viewers may find upsetting.
A year after the accident, Harvey Thorneycroft, a Northampton winger, led a tour to raise funds for Brito, with other notable names including Martin Johnson and Graham Rowntree taking part. The Professional Rugby Players’ Association also tried to help the Ivorian, but ex-England sevens player Damien Hopley, who also had to retire early because of injury, highlighted the lack of support for Brito in the long term.
In additon, with rugby stars increasingly becoming bigger, faster and more aggressive than ever in the modern age, concerns have been expressed that a repeat of the Brito incident could occur in the near future. Although the injury that the Ivorian suffered was extremely rare, there is perceived to be a greater risk of such issues occurring at competitions like the World Cup, with minnows featuring amateurs coming up against much stronger professional teams.
Furthermore, in 2003, the Independent on Sunday quoted English Rugby Football Union chief medical officer Dr Simon Kemp saying that injuries such as Brito’s statistically “shouldn’t occur more than once in every four World Cups”.
Ivory Coast, meanwhile, have not featured in a Rugby World Cup since 1995, while Brito’s grim fate prompted plenty of debate on whether it was appropriate to allow inexperienced nations to compete with the heavyweights of the game in such pressurised circumstances.
And now, after more than two decades have passed since one of rugby’s most infamous incidents, Brito reportedly continues to live as a quadriplegic in Bordeaux. He retains some income from the Rugby World Cup insurance, while officials still offer invitations to subsequent tournaments, but the former player lives primarily off social welfare these days.
Yet, although not exactly a redemption, there has been at least a hint of positivity in recent times. Notwithstanding the immense trauma he has suffered at its hands, the latest reports indicate that Brito continues to reserve an unlikely, unflagging passion for the sport of rugby.
The Times reports that back in May, an ex-Ivory Coast teammate Djakaria Sanoko — who still visits Brito sporadically at his home — organised his first visit to the Ivory Coast in almost two decades.
A benefit game was arranged with over 60 players — many of whom were ex-teammates of Brito — taking part. More encouragingly still, at 44, Brito has a new partner who cares for him on a daily basis, while in stark contrast with 2007, he holds an increasingly hopeful outlook on life, telling reporters last May:
“I have managed to vanquish my handicap. When you accept what has happened, you can move on. When you refuse to accept it, you can never find a way through. My aim today is to relaunch rugby [in Ivory Coast] by training young players.”
Despite this positive note, however, Brito’s story remains essentially tragic. With the 2015 competition set to begin, the 1995 accident continues to serve as a timely reminder of the considerable risk involved and courage that rugby players at a high level require to continually put their bodies on the line, particularly during high-profile events such as the World Cup, where media hype and intensity levels on the pitch go into overdrive.
Brito’s sad tale ultimately gives a glimpse into the dark side of the sport, with most people preferring to associate 1995 with the image of a smiling Nelson Mandela in the Springboks jersey, rather than the haunting footage of a young Ivorian man laying prone on the ground for far too long. Just like the former event however, the latter one should not and cannot afford to be forgotten by anyone who loves and cares about the game.
No excuses tonight, just beaten by a much better and quicker side. Fingers crossed they can win the tie in Dublin and do well in the Conference group stages.
@Brian Murphy: was a freeroll anyway group stages already secured.
@John Kelly: I’m sure they’d rather be in the Europa Leage group stages though. Plus, a hiding like that is not good for confidence.
@John Kelly: that kind of attitude is why Irish teams do so poor in Europe
@Paul Doyle: it’s a step up in fairness to play the likes of ferencavros Paul obviously Europa would of been better but guaranteed conference won by Roma last year and some really good teams is not too shabby as a consolation don’t you think
@Brian Murphy: of course they would I’m not disputing that but they can have a good craic off them in tallaght and again in the conference group. Another great achievement for the club.
@John Kelly: That’s literally what I said in the comment you replied to. We’re agreed so!!
@Brian Murphy: I actually didn’t meant to reply to your comment just meant to post mine :) but yea totally agree either way it Was a win win imo
@John Kelly: Ha, that explains that. Anyway, agreed.
@Paul Doyle: Irish teams have historically done poor in Europe because Irish barstool fans would rather go to Liverpool or Manchester than support their local team
@Declan Clancy: It’s slightly more complex than that!
Christ it was a tough watch, rovers at the back were shambolic its a miracle it was only 4 nil realistically shud of been 8 or 9.cant knock rovers for gety9ng this far but a hiding like that just shows how far the league of Ireland is behind pretty much all other European leagues.
@Sean Mccabe: apart from maybe the other leagues that Irish clubs have knocked out the teams from those leagues. Surely that makes us better than them?
@Sean Mccabe: Jesus Christ… are they not in the conference league group stage no? I’m bohs fan defending rovers here, yea they were poor tonight but the objective was already achieved. Look at the teams just in the conference playoff rd and rovers already there. Credit where it’s due sean
@Kevin: I wasn’t gonna mention North Macedonia come on now,im thinking along the lines of Hungary,Turkey,Greece,Bulgaria to see if we could match up against them those leagues are hardly world beaters now r they.irish league is light years behind any half decent league in Europe and that’s just the hard truth we were never gonna be them tonight.
@John Kelly: I was giving them credit I said they did really well to get this far.ya can’t deny thst was painful to watch tonight,irelands best team getting mauled by some minnows themselves it just highlights how far irish football is behind others.theres no shame in that just a tough watch
@Sean Mccabe: what are you on about? West Ham, Fiorintina AZ Alkmaar Villarreal FC Tewnte are all still trying to qualify for a tournament rovers are already in the group stage for….. thunk about it
@John Kelly: come on now look at who rovers have played 99% of people wud never of heard of them. I say again I give them credit for getting this far but they were like U 12′s out there tonight out muscled and outclassed. Tallaght cud be even worse
@Sean Mccabe: I kind of agree with you, but in our defence we were missing a good few key players. When Jacko came on he made a big difference. I think Burkie was sorely missed too.
@Sean Mccabe: minnows? They were in the champions league group stages two years ago. Had a crowd of nearly 20,000 there tonight. Bought a player for nearly 2m recently. Why on earth do you think Irish teams should be able to compete against that? Seriously.
@Sean Mccabe: but your not listening it doesnt really matter much. Yes no Europa league but they have 6 more games in Europe 3 home and 3 away against possibly some big European heavyweights that I’ve already mentioned. That’s 6 more chances to showcase the league of Ireland on the big stage and how much it’s progessing. Again think about it for a minute…. But unfortunately we have people like you always willing to pull it down
@Sean Mccabe: Conference League is what Irish clubs can reasonably hope for. If we has 2/3 teams getting to the league stages it would bring much needed money into our league.
Probably once in decade a team could make the Europa given a favourable.
@John Kelly: take off the blinkers pal call a spade a spade that was shocking out there tonight judge tonight’s game not that they have 6 more to come be real that wasn’t a good advertisement for us tonight now was it
@TL55: I agree pal that is our level rite now and that’s a harsh truth but that’s the best we can hope for, that rovers team is shit hot but my god they were woeful tonight
@Kevin: so ur telling me you knew full well rovers were gonna get spanked bad before a ball was eve kicked tonight
@Philip Fox: Jack Byrne tried his best just struggling big time with injuries but he’s a deadly player when 100 %. Shocking at the back tonight they shud of had 8 if they took there chances
@Sean Mccabe: They played poorly and took a hiding but it doesn’t detract from all the excellent results Irish teams have enjoyed in recent years, including Rovers this year. Even good teams play really poorly some times, no point in writing off the whole LOI because of one result.
@Brian Murphy: not writing them off pal just a harsh reality check on were our league lies in European standards hard to watch but it’s been a good adventure for rovers so far.lets hope they can avoid a drubbing though next week
@John Kelly: I think you are overplaying the objective already achieved card by getting to Conference League group. That’s giving them a free pass for poor performance. Their objective was to get to Europa League group stages and they will be gutted to have failed.
@Sean Mccabe: I think they made woeful errors and learned that you can’t hope to compete with a much better side in Europe with no pace in side. They have a chance to rectify in Conference League group stages and will no doubt get a result or two that will make us rethink that place in European standards. Fingers crossed.
@Brian Murphy: I’m just defending the league more than anything else Brian.
@John Kelly: I’m with you on that one!
@Brian Murphy: yes mate nail on the head
@Brian Murphy: only joining this conversation late I honestly thought Rovers did well and missing 5 serious players it could have been a tighter game
@Sean Mccabe: wouldn’t call them minnows look at the facilities they have beautiful stadium and a squad valued at €40million
@ed: never heard of them. Wikipedia nails it though. – Ferencváros has been the most successful Hungarian club in European football competitions having won the 1964–65 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup.
I think that says it all really.
@Bernard Connolly: They were torn apart. Had more ball in second half but never threatened and Ferencvaros looked like scoring every time they broke. They were happy to give them ball at times as Rovers were so slow and doing nothing in possession. A hiding.
R.T.E . Euro jinx strikes again.
In fairness Tetteh looked very good when he came on, and only 17
I’m afraid Rhasida Adeleke(not sure of spelling),is the only one in tallaght who can cope with best in Europe,but the rest try their best
Genuine question what is the last big game for rovers against half decent European opposition that they haven’t bottled?
@Sean Newberry: genuine question, who do you support? Didn’t see you comment on any of the articles over the past few weeks when rovers were winning games.
@Kevin: Against the mighty shkupi and hibernians unreal. Time to close the gap tomorrow.
@Sean Newberry: Ditto most LOI teams down the decades. Exceptions I can think of : Athlone v Inter, Limerick v Real Madrid and Dundalk v Liverpool. No victories there but good shows and entirety amateur players not semi-pro like Rovers today. Says a lot !!
Playing high calibre opposition makes loi sides look poor at times….valuation of each ferencvaros player is double what the opposite rovers player is…pity with the result but is it a big surprise?