JOE SCHMIDT’S IRELAND got back to winning ways with a 17-22 victory over an under-strength Welsh side in Cardiff.
You can read our match report from the Principality here, or tell us how you think the players did below.
Will Addison
6Our Rating
Seemed to be a long way down the pecking order before today, but showed good footwork, inventive running angles and good aerial presence from fullback. If this was an audition, he will be frustrated that it was curtailed by a head knock early in the second half and he was replaced twice by Garry Ringrose after that.
Andrew Conway
8Our Rating
Sensational jinking run and cleverly timed pass created the opening try for Stockdale. Unlucky not to get more change from his aerial challenges, but consistenly proving himself to be the best option outside of Schmidt's first-choice back three - if not worthy of breaking in.
Chris Farrell
6Our Rating
Looked terrific as a 12 against Italy, but back in his favoured position Farrell struggled to replicate that form. Seemed to struggle with the low-octane nature of the warm-up and his handling let him down on some occasions when he did try to get Ireland a gainline.
Bundee Aki
8Our Rating
Brought his typical powerful energy to Ireland's midfield. Forced impressive tackle busts. Unlucky not to force a try for Garry Ringrose when he was pinged for a tackle in the air.
Jacob Stockdale
7Our Rating
Under immense pressure after Twickenham, but overcame a shaky start to ground two first-half tries, the second of which showcased him at his best. Agile enough to reach the loose ball, powerful enough to out-pace all-comers and finish the chance.
Jack Carty
8Our Rating
Given man of the match by Channel 4's Shane WIlliams. Appeared understandably tentative early on on his first Test start, but his early kicks at goal and a deliciious line-break quickly steadied his nerve. Good defensive positioning and showed a glimpse of the variety he can bring in attack to keep the red jerseys guessing.
Kieran Marmion
7Our Rating
Helped ensure Carty had a steady combination to work in. And once Ireland were settled he set a nice tempo in attack, even bringing some Connacht-eque, loose expansive attacks to Schmidt's side.
Dave Kilcoyne
8Our Rating
Rubber-stamped his place as the best alternative to Cian Healy with solid scrummaging, hard effective tackles and, of course, that explosive carrying. Day ended earlier than planned with a HIA, but if fit he will be in the 23 to face Scotland.
Niall Scannell
7Our Rating
Joe Schmidt wanted set-piece solidity and Scannell is as close to a guarantee of that as you can get. Played his part in a dominant scrum and was assured at line-out time while also contibuting solid hits in defence.
John Ryan
7Our Rating
Didn't put a foot wrong and kept Ireland's scrum moving forward. A solid alternative to Tadhg Furlong, who replaced him after 50 minutes.
Iain Henderson
7Our Rating
Got through a serious amoung of defensive work and played his part in getting the line-out back on track.
James Ryan
8Our Rating
We all knew things would be better with the young Leinster monster in harness and so it proved. The lock's physicality in contact and excellent line-speed set the tone for a dominant Irish display.
Tadhg Beirne
6Our Rating
Would have hoped to stake a moer impactful claim on his return to Wales, but didn't make any major attention-grabbing carries or hits. Plugged away manfully at unsung duties none-the-less.
Peter O'Mahony
7Our Rating
Steady if not spectacular for the captain. Playing out of position, but maintained his consistent work-rate throughout to give Ireland the edge.
Jack Conan
7Our Rating
First game out in green this season and looked like a man fully up to speed. A muscular presence in assisting tackles for Ireland with nine to his own name.
Replacements
Rory Best
6Our Rating
HIs role in this team was under the microscope all week and Best responded by digging in and adding grit to Ireland's pack to ensure they retained control of this Test. Camera zoomed in on him after the penalty try was scored, but he will be more pleased with his efforts in the maul defence and turnover that followed minutes later.
Andrew Porter
5Our Rating
In for Kilcoyne and picked up immediately where the Munster man left off, forcing a scrum penalty and bringing a carrying presence that is very hard to stop.
Devin Toner
4Our Rating
Mainly left with defensive duties as Wales mounted a late rally.
Tadhg Furlong
6Our Rating
A hell of a boost to give any side from the replacements. Kept the scrum firmly in Ireland's favour and that sucked the life out of Welsh momentum.
Luke McGrath
5Our Rating
Came on with 21 to go and didn't get as much attacking opportunities as he would have liked, but his coach will be thrilled at the last ditch try-saving tackle he made on Elliot Dee.
Garry Ringrose
4Our Rating
So versatile he was an option to play at out-half today, but instead wound up on the wing. Unlucky to have his fine finish called back, but at fault for Patchell try after a weak tackle on the jinking out-half.
Dave Kearney
4Our Rating
Replaced Jacob Stockdale at half-time and had to shift in and out of the fullback slot, so far from ideal conditions to make an impact. Should have trusted his inside man rather than bite for the Owen Lane try.
Jordi Murphy
5Our Rating
Added eight tackles during his short time on the field and helped Ireland hold the late Welsh attacks at bay.
The42 is on Instagram! Tap the button below on your phone to follow us!
1. Gary Breen
2. Gary Breen
3. Gary Breen
4. Gary Breen
5. Gary Breen
6. Gary Breen
7. Gary Breen
8. Gary Breen
9. Gary Breen
10. Gary Breen
11 Gary Breen
There’s only 1 Gary Breen (sing it)
Now that team would have no bother Knocking a few past the Estonians!!
Please let all this Euro 2012 bullsh*t go away quickly.
Come on Estonia.
What about Keith Andrews and Caleb Folan?
That’s some team alright!
What! No Ronnie Whelan, Mark Lawrenson, Packie Bonner or John Aldridge
Should argue that the team was based on consensus, but not outright agreement, between the four co-managers. I had Bonner and Aldo in my eleven!
No Kevin Kilbane? I’m out.
Packie as GK I would argue.
Fact.
Great team – maybe Moran at the back instead of Dunne, but a close call.
Great bench too – Aldridge, Duff, O’Leary, Bonner, Quinn, Whelan, Townsend.
Agreed on Moran, not arguing with Dunne’s contribution but Moran has three major tournaments behind him. Possibly Aldo/Givens instead of Stapo??
Well what about Liam Whelan? Tony Dunne? Noel Cantwell? Johnny Carey? All should be considered except they played before armchair afficianados knew best.
Also it would be easier if you adopted the classic ‘W’ formation when allocating positions viz 1 Goalkeeper, 2 Right Back, 3 Left Back, 4 Right-Half, 5 Centre-Half, 6 Left-Half, 7 Outside Right, 8 Inside Right, 9 Centre Foward 10 Inside Left, 11 Outside Left
Sorry to be so old fashioned!
dead on but very little footage of these lads in action.
As brilliant as Liam Whelan was for United, he only had four caps for Ireland. That’s too little to be considered. Dunne rarely repeated his United form for Ireland.
Well Miguel only four caps yes but that was because he was killed at Munich. He’s was Ireland’s Duncan Edwards
wouldnt have staunton in there, irwin should be at LB. no because i dislike him as a manager, i just dont feel he was that good despite his 100+ caps. kilbane has that many and nobody rates him that highly
better irish RB would be carr, gary kelly or finnan.
john o shea won a stack of medals at united so possibly him at lb if irwin is at rb
Great except for the notable exception of one Gary Doherty
What! No Tony Grealish? The Chuck Norris of Irish football. Remember that 40 yard screamer vs Cyprus.
davie langan 12foot tall when he pulled on the green jersey one of irelands best ever
Forgotten Heroes
GK: Dean Kiely
RB: Gary Kelly
CB: Gary Breen
CB: Phil Babb
LB: Ian Harte
RM: Jason McAteer
CM: Mark Kinsella
LM: Kevin Kilbane
RF: David Connolly
CF: Gary Doherty
LF: Clinton Morrison
Where is steve highway, heart of Mick McCarthy more than the skills,
That’s a great team, no complaints there. Subs bench of Kevin Moran, Ronnie Whelan, John Aldridge, Quinner and Mick McCarthy.
What !
No Gary Waddock ?
No Ashley Grimes ?!!
What about Bernie Slaven ?!!!
Terry Phlean…any games?
Quinny instead of stapleton maybe, Lawrenson for Dunne maybe/maybe not? Duff/Houghton?, Very tight calls, Also it is quite a recent team, giles apart, Did any of the greats of the past get a look in? It is a great team however and would take a bit of beating!
I wouldn’t let Roy Keane near an Irish shirt.
0-0 tonight and 1-1 on Tuesday.
To offer my two (or maybe 11) cents… based exclusively on their performances for Ireland and effect on biggest games
1. Packie Bonner
2. Chris Hughton
3. Denis Irwin
4. Paul McGrath
5. Kevin Moran
6. Roy Keane
7. Ray Houghton
8. John Giles
9. Robbie Keane
10. Niall Quinn
11. Liam Brady
Don’t think much of Keane as a footballer. Great heart yes and Irish through & through!
Can’t argue too much about that selection. Pity no room for Ronnie Whelan. For 32 counties add Jennings,Dougan & Best…..NOW you’re talking World beaters!
. Packie Bonner
. .Steve Finnan Richard Dunne paul McGrath Denis irwin
Damian Duff Roy Keane
Johnny Giles
Liam Brady
Robbie Keane
Niall Quinn
cant forget about this amazing centre back also
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoUNrjrRXw8
0-0 tonight, 1-1 Tuesday.
shu-upyatick
No place for Clinton McMorris??!!!!!
Seriously though, great team, I might just make one change…Duff for Houghton!