Backs:
Hugo Keenan — 7: Safe. Smart. Industrious. Made his yards without lighting the world on fire. Made a hames of one kick as Ireland were compounding their errors. You’d take that from your fullback most days, and you’d still take Hugo Keenan as your fullback seven days a week.
Mack Hansen — 8: Officially the man of the match — and no qualms on this end. Fielded well and was, as is his wont, omnipresent in Ireland’s attack. Took his try extremely well and is such an underrated. Some footballer.
Garry Ringrose — 7: Quiet-ish by his own standards but, like Hansen, finished well when his opportunity came early in the first half. Put his shoulder to the wheel on the other side of the ball.
Bundee Aki — 7: Didn’t get too many opportunities to carry but the few he did get, he took them well. Score was a gimme on a good support run but there was nothing ordinary about his assist for Earls’ crowning moment.
James Lowe — 8: This writer’s man of the match. An exhibition of his full range of skills. Lowe was absolutely on it, popping up everywhere and typically making enough of a dent in an English defender that he could release a perfectly timed offload to further Ireland’s attack. His right-handed pass out to Peter O’Mahony in the lead-up to Ringrose’s try travelled roughly six kilometres at first glance.
Ross Byrne — 7: Nice and aggressive with his penalties to touch, a quality not often spoken about but one which gave Ireland several idyllic attacking platforms. Two beautiful skip-pass assists and plenty of nice touches. Poor day off the tee and a little bit loose in the first half, even excluding the couple of botched set plays which weren’t his fault.
Jamison Gibson-Park — 6: Not a huge deal to write about today: still integral to everything good that Ireland do in attack.
Forwards:
Andrew Porter — 7: Too hot to handle for the English scrum. Quieter than usual in the carry but put in some barbaric hits.
Dan Sheehan — 6: Was probably on his way to a 7 or 8 until he was withdrawn in the 36th minute. That he caught Elliot Daly on an infield dash 13 minutes earlier is kind of insane: the man is a hooker. Darts were decent, albeit with one overthrow on the half-hour mark. Won a huge scrum penalty with his last involvement.
Tadhg Furlong — 7: See Porter above — but add to the equation that Furlong seemed to personally piss off the English front row to a delightful degree, at one stage commenting, ‘There’s some chat coming out of ya’ at one stage in the first half. He’ll be annoyed to have gotten bursht by Ellis Genge on a first-half carry, but he made a big one of his own before going off halfway through the second.
Tadhg Beirne — 6: Led the team in tackles on a day in which he was needed for pure grunt work. One huge counter-ruck. Quiet on the other side of the ball — don’t think he made a meaningful carry.
James Ryan (captain) — 8: Like Beirne, the stats don’t give a fair reflection of his overall contribution, which included a deftly executed kick into the English backfield midway through the second half. Led from the front and took things right to the edge with referee Paul Williams, which was required once or twice.
Peter O’Mahony — 6: Provided the necessary bread and butter for Aki’s try and occasionally rolled back the years on the left edge. Not his hardest day out and he was put in cotton wool before the hour mark.
Josh van der Flier — 7: Just a generally solid outing on both sides of the ball, and a lovely tee-up for O’Mahony prior to Aki’s try bumps him from a 6 to a 7.
Cian Prendergast — 7: A couple of nervy moments early but settled himself with a big turnover in the 11th minute when Ireland found themselves under the cosh, and that set the tone for a game in which he became a pain in the arse for England throughout. Carried with spite for more metres than any other Irish forward, and was a go-to in the lineout.
Replacements:
Rob Herring (Sheehan 36′) — 6: Uncharacteristically poor throw on the English 5′ early in the second half but otherwise showed why he’s such a valuable player, particularly across the set piece.
Jeremy Loughman (Porter 72′) — n/a
Finlay Bealham (Furlong 56′) — 7: Huge jackal penalty win as Ireland withstood the first bit of serious English pressure in the second half.
Joe McCarthy (O’Mahony 53′) — 7: Made four carries, six tackles and one big turnover upon his introduction.
Caelan Doris (Ryan 69′) — n/a
Conor Murray (Gibson-Park 66′) — n/a
Jack Crowley (Aki 58′) — 6: Would have thrived in this game had he started. Nice touchline conversion from Earls’ score, and threw himself about the place.
Keith Earls — 100: Centurion. Try-scorer. The Man.
Good to see Sammy putting in good performances. He could turn out to be an excellent Internation too. Great to see strength and depth at centre in Munster too, Scannel, Farrel, Taute, Arnold and even Goggins.
It would be nice to see some Munster developed players break into the national team, and stay there. It has been a long time since Conor Murray and Simon Zebo did so. There are a number of players in the background but they really need to start producing more for Ireland.
@grandslamkbo: O’Mahony? I agree that we could do with more lads breaking in for regular games but there’s such a log jam of Leinster players…
@EnKy: POM, of course. My error, I meant backs. No reason to drag thinly veiled hostility towards Leinster in this. What Munster-developed players do you think are being unfairly kept out of the first team or regular squad positions for Leinster players? As an Irish supporter, I want to see the best for the national team. Every team has to do their part.
@grandslamkbo: last weekend there were 3 Leinster starters, 2 – munster, 1 Connacht and 1 Ulster. For the next match it’ll be 3 munster, 2 Leinster, 1 Connacht and 1 Ulster. Not sure how you figure munster should be doing more.
@Jim Demps: It was a pretty poor attempt at trolling
This guy has got some serious acceleration.
The abuse joe get and yet the work he puts into these younger players and bringing them through slowly but making sure each part of the foundation is rock solid. Those who buy into this learning set up and do the required work will become far better players for us in the medium and long term.
@Chris Mc: where you seeing all this abuse for Joe?
@Jim Demps: Ahhhh c’mon now… Even Ive hurled the odd bit of abuse at him. And i think he’s flippin great.
The criticism from fans is constant. No matter what he does there will be those who think he shouldve done differently. That’s just the territory of being a head coach. Everyone has an opinion, so no matter what choice Schmidt makes, someone will disagree
@Jim Demps: I just made it up
@Rudiger McMonihan: ya ur probably right. I’m always dumbfounded that he goes with toner.
Fine player with a big future ahead for Munster and Ireland.