Clontarf 13
Cork Constitution 28
CORK CONSTITUTION WON their second All-Ireland League Division 1A title in three years following an impressive 28-13 final victory over Clontarf at the Aviva Stadium.
Man-of-the-match Rob Jermyn had a day to remember, scoring a superb solo try, saving one at the other end and supplying the assist for replacement Duncan Williams’ crucial 58th-minute score. Out-half Aidan Moynihan tagged on three closing penalties to steer Cork Con to their sixth league crown, making up for last year’s defeat to Lansdowne.
Clontarf were only 14-13 behind approaching the hour mark, Matt D’Arcy’s 36th-minute try from a quick tap – in response to converted efforts from Shane Daly and Jermyn – and eight points from the boot of David Joyce making it a one-point game. However, half-backs Williams and Moynihan combined to steer the table toppers home.
Cork Con coaches Brian Hickey and Paul Barr were forced into a significant late switch as captain Niall Kenneally’s injury-enforced withdrawal brought Alex McHenry into midfield, while Clontarf fielded the same team from their semi-final apart from the absence of injured winger Mick McGrath. It was one win apiece from the clubs’ 2016 and 2017 final meetings.
Despite dominating the early possession, Clontarf fell behind to centre Daly’s 12th-minute try. Scrum possession near halfway was moved wide to Sean French who shrugged off Jack Power and held off Cian O’Donoghue’s challenge, linking with Liam O’Connell whose instinctive one-handed flick sent the onrushing Daly darting over beside the posts.
Impressive out-half Moynihan converted for a 7-0 lead, ‘Tarf hammering back with a snappy break from Connacht signing Angus Lloyd and McHenry was promptly sin-binned for slowing up the ball close to his own try-line. Joyce fired over the penalty kick to get his side on the board, but Con swiftly showed their clinical edge again with Jermyn’s brilliantly-taken try.
Number 8 Luke Cahill’s inviting inside pass saw Jermyn expose Clontarf’s defence at the side of a ruck, the wily winger hurtling through and sidestepping around full-back Power to go over to the right of the posts. Moynihan’s conversion made it 14-3 midway through a fast-paced first half and Con’s noted defence kept ‘Tarf try-less during McHenry’s time off the field.
French and Cahill put in two crucial tackles, the Ireland Under-20 starlet foiling an excellent break involving Power, Michael Courtney and Lloyd, and Cahill thwarted his opposite number, Clontarf skipper Michael Noone, near the right corner. It looked like Con would survive some Vakh Abdaladze-inspired scrum pressure, especially when Jermyn got his hand under the ball to prevent Power from scoring off a five-metre scrum.
Power really should have passed to the waiting Courtney on his outside, but his blushes were eventually spared by talismanic centre D’Arcy. After Lloyd had knocked on at the base of a scrum, Clontarf bounced back with a strong bout of carrying, winning a close-in penalty from which D’Arcy stretched over past Cahill and Moynihan for a timely seven-pointer.
D’Arcy was becoming increasing influential, holding up Joe McSwiney for a turnover and then breaking downfield off the resulting late scrum. That gave Andy Wood’s men some momentum at only 14-10 down, but Constitution exploded out of the blocks on the resumption with Daly, McHenry and Moynihan all finding gaps. ‘Tarf scrum half Lloyd was caught offside twice and yellow-carded by referee Jonny Erskine.
Con turned down a kickable penalty and 14-man ‘Tarf displayed their own survival skills, Joyce tackling Jason Higgins short of the line before stand-in Con skipper Brian Hayes’ low-slung pass was knocked on by McSwiney. Lock Cormac Daly’s important tackle on French prevented a potentially dangerous break back on halfway, and Joyce was able punish an offside call against Vincent O’Brien with a 54th-minute penalty goal.
With Leinster’s Conor O’Brien on at centre, Clontarf remained on the front foot as Power and Lloyd spearheaded a break through midfield. However, on the day, Con only needed a sniff of a chance to score, and just a couple of days on from confirmation of his departure from Munster after 11 years, experienced scrum half Williams started and finished a classy breakaway try.
The freshly-introduced 33-year-old used a sudden turnover to kick downfield, Jermyn was first to it and passed out of a tackle for Williams to dash towards the left corner and squeeze over past Sean O’Brien’s last-ditch challenge. Moynihan suffered his only missed kick of the afternoon, before Clontarf prop Royce Burke-Flynn’s injury led to uncontested scrums and Sean O’Brien had to make way.
Frustratingly for watching coaches Wood and James Downey, 14-man ‘Tarf let their discipline slip with industrious lock Cormac Daly’s final act being a sloppy offside. Moynihan landed the 62nd-minute place-kick to extend the lead to 22-13, and he added another with 11 minutes remaining after replacements Conor O’Brien and Brian Deeny had leaked successive penalties.
Con were then down to 14 men as French saw yellow for a deliberate knock-on, albeit that there would have been enough Con cover to keep Power from scoring from Adamson’s attempted pass. ‘Tarf then lost hard-won territory, Munster Academy back McHenry showing his power and pace to surge back into the opposition 22. Replacement Max Abbott followed up with a penalty at the breakdown, ensuring that Moynihan claim the final three points of a very entertaining league decider.
Clontarf scorers: Try: Matt D’Arcy; Con: David Joyce; Pens: David Joyce 2
Cork Constitution scorers: Tries: Shane Daly, Rob Jermyn, Duncan Williams; Cons: Aidan Moynihan 2; Pens: Aidan Moynihan 3
CLONTARF: Jack Power; Michael Courtney, Sean O’Brien, Matt D’Arcy, Cian O’Donoghue; David Joyce, Angus Lloyd; Ian Soroka, Paddy Finlay, Royce Burke-Flynn, Cormac Daly, Ben Reilly, Tony Ryan, Adrian D’Arcy, Michael Noone (capt).
Replacements used: Vakh Abdaladze for Soroka (12 mins), Andrew Feeney for O’Donoghue (45′-53′, temp sub), Declan Adamson for Burke-Flynn (51′), Conor O’Brien for O’Donoghue (54′), Brian Deeny for Daly (62′), Tom Ryan for A D’Arcy (69′), Conor Kelly for Joyce (72′).
CORK CONSTITUTION: Liam O’Connell; Sean French, Shane Daly, Alex McHenry, Rob Jermyn; Aidan Moynihan, Jason Higgins; Gavin Duffy, Vincent O’Brien, Dylan Murphy, Brian Hayes (capt), Evan Mintern, Joe McSwiney, Kevin Sheahan, Luke Cahill.
Replacements used: James Murphy for McSwiney (50 mins), Duncan Williams for Higgins (54′), Jonathan Wren for Jermyn (65′), Patrick Casey for Duffy, Ross O’Neill for Sheahan (both 69′), Max Abbott for O’Brien (76′), Brendan Quinlan for Murphy, Jermyn for Daly (both 79′).
Referee: Jonny Erskine (IRFU)
Great game. Mighty advertisement for the AIL. Would love if the IRFU would do more to promote the amateur game. It can be a really good foundation for academy and potential professional players. Even if the provinces could release those players not making the provincial 23 a bit earlier in the week so clubs can work with them. And supporters clubs offering incentives (like free tickets to lesser pro 14 games/ a percentage off of season tickets) for supporting the local clubs would generate more interest.
There was a time not so long ago that 10/12000 fans would pack Temple Hill, Thomond Park, Castle Avenue, Dooradoyle etc. We need to get some of that back.
@PJ Dinan: Was talking about it recently that it would be great to see a game on terrestrial TV every weekend. Now that RTE don’t have much rugby on it wouldn’t it be great if they picked their game of the weekend and covered it. IMO it would boost interest in the league and help get the numbers up. Another thing I’d love to see again is pro players playing in it when they are coming back from injury. They used to do it so why not again? I think it was great that Duncan Williams played games for Con this year when he knew he wasnt going to be getting game time at Munster. Surely it would have been great Jaco Taute to play for a club too. I remember Christian Cullen lining out for Muskerry way back in the day when he was coming back from injury.
@PJ Dinan: Clubs already are offered tickets for free quite a lot. Provinces run deals for clubs every game. How much more do you want.
Its 20 years now since the 10000/12000 would go to Temple Hill etc for club games and most of them have gravitated to the provinces.
@Tony Walsh: TV coverage would be of benefit but clubs should be far cleverer in what they offer beyond the rugby to get people going to games. Shannon have been excellent in linking with Russells bar to improve what they offer people who turn up on match days. More clubs could do similar.
@Tony Walsh: OTB’s total disregard for the League is also interesting. They don’t have to cover it of course but when you think of all the different platforms they have and the podcast service, it would be great to see some content.
@grandslamkbo: and now that a Cork team has won it they will ignore it more
AIL games should be on a Sunday. Pro14 games don’t normally play on a Sunday and won’t clash. It’s a great standard and I think more people would go watch if it wasn’t clashing with professional games on TV.
@blindside: also every league below the top two should be split into North and South to reduce the travel and time costs. Players having to travel the length of the country for amateur games is crazy.
@blindside: The players and clubs dont want to have games on Sundays. Junior rugby in Connacht/Munster is played Sundays but Leinster and Ulster play Saturdays and do far better from it.
@blindside: Clubs regularly have voted to not have a split. They dont want regionalised leagues and with some divisions there will still be extensive travel regardless
Why are the attendances for these games never reported? Is it that the IRFU don’t bother to issue them or that they don’t want us knowing how low they are?
How does a city the size of Cork only have 5 AIL teams???
@Joe: Other clubs simply not good enough. players gravitating to rest of clubs there. douglas-carrigaline have had to combine at underage in recent years as well.not sure how many more you could expect the city to have?
@Ormond: Dolphin have also combined this year with Douglas and Carrigaline at u14 level. Schools rugby kills the youth game down here.
@Tony Walsh: That and lack of interest. A lot of “rugby country” people are actually just couch Munster and Leinster fans. No interest in playing or contributing. Just eating up the corporate product laid on for them
@Charles McDuck: Not to mention spewing their opinions about rugby tactics online having never picked up a ball in their life. Nothing worse than listening to the new fans moan constantly about reffing decisions they don’t even understant