1. Which Irish player did enough last night to feature against Denmark?
IT WOULD BE fair to assume that, barring injury, nine Ireland players are effectively guaranteed to start against the Danes on Monday.
The individuals in question are: Darren Randolph, Matt Doherty, John Egan, Shane Duffy, Enda Stevens, Glenn Whelan, Jeff Hendrick, James McClean and David McGoldrick.
It was no major surprise, therefore, that none of these stars played a single minute of action against New Zealand at the Aviva Stadium last night.
Every other player in the squad got game time with the exception of one individual โ Scott Hogan โ who has endured a tough time this season at Stoke and appears to have fallen down the Ireland pecking order as a result.
It seems, though, that there are two positions still up for grabs in the starting XI to play Denmark โ one of the central midfield spots and the right wing.
The wide position would appear to be between Robbie Brady and Callum Robinson, while Alan Browne and Conor Hourihane are presumably vying for a place in the centre.
The fact that Brady played the full 90 minutes against the All Whites can be read in one of two ways โ McCarthy was giving him game time now with the knowledge that he has no intention of using him next week, or perhaps he is simply improving his match sharpness with a view to starting him. Last night was just Bradyโs second start of the season in all competitions, while it is the first time he has completed 90 minutes in nearly a year โ Burnleyโs 1-0 win over Brighton on 8 December 2018 was the last time he did so before Thursday evening.
The 27-year-old Dubliner was not quite back to his best against New Zealand โ there were a few stray passes and moments where he could have been more alert defensively. But his set pieces caused problems, and Bradyโs deadly left foot proved to be the source of the first Ireland goal, as Derrick Williams headed home powerfully. He also nearly set up Sean Maguire for another โ his inch-perfect delivery was headed just wide by the 25-year-old.
You would suspect though that Callum Robinson is in the driving seat for a starting spot against the Danes. The Sheffield United player has not been at his best for club or country of late โ he had to settle for an 87th-minute appearance in the Bladesโ recent 1-1 draw with Spurs. Meanwhile, he was substituted in Irelandโs 0-0 stalemate with Georgia last month and did not appear in the subsequent match against Switzerland.
Yet Robinsonโs old Preston team-mate Maguire might just have thrown a spanner in the works with a man-of-the-match performance last night. The Irish boss identified him as a standout player after the match.
The former Cork City man played in McCarthyโs first match in charge, the underwhelming 1-0 win away to Gibraltar, but delivered a subdued display that day and has not started a competitive Ireland game since.
Maguire produced a brilliant finish for the Boys in Greenโs second goal and was generally lively. He has been playing in a wide attacking role with Preston recently. Last night, he played on the left, and itโs hard to imagine him displacing James McClean from the team. Putting him on the right-hand side of the attack, on the other hand, seems a more viable option.
Nonetheless, Robinson also got on the scoresheet, and was the most influential of Irelandโs substitutes. Consequently, he is probably still the slight favourite for a starting spot.
As for the midfield dilemma? Both Browne and Hourihane were solid without being spectacular. Previously, the latter was given the nod against Georgia, while the former took his place for the Swiss encounter.
Last night, Browne played the first 65 minutes before Hourihane stepped in. That fact would suggest McCarthy is edging towards favouring the Aston Villa man.
Particularly if Brady is left out, there are not many in the squad with Hourihaneโs dead-ball prowess and that factor may swing this tough call in his favour.
McCarthy wonโt have forgotten the brilliant free kick that the Cork native scored in the crucial home win over Georgia last March.
2. A low-key atmosphere but an above-average friendly
When you think of friendlies, and Ireland friendlies in particular, they can often be quite bad to watch.
That dour spell where the team consistently struggled to score towards the end of the Martin OโNeill era is still relatively fresh in many fansโ memories.
Last nightโs match initially appeared to have the makings of a similarly dreary occasion.
A crowd of 18,000 had been expected at the game, but that appeared to be a generous estimate when glancing around the stadium last night.
The atmosphere was consequently subdued, despite two of Irish footballโs most promising youngsters (Troy Parrott and Lee OโConnor) being given their international debuts and the match representing the beginning of an international week that could conceivably end with Ireland sealing their spot at Euro 2020 and qualifying for a major tournament for just the seventh time in the countryโs history.
Yet the fact that it was a meaningless game, coupled with the recent negativity generated by a combination of the teamโs inept performances and the various FAI-related controversies, and of course the issue of it being a freezing cold November night on a Thursday, renders it perhaps understandable that so many stayed away.
Those that came, however, were treated to one of the more entertaining Ireland friendlies in recent memory. Before September, Ireland had gone over two years without scoring more than twice in a single game. Now, they have managed that feat in consecutive friendlies.
And it is perhaps reward for a bold team selection. Jack Byrne, Josh Cullen, Troy Parrott and Lee OโConnor among others may be highly inexperienced at this level, but they are proficient at keeping the ball and demonstrating good technical skills.
If these youngsters can continue to build on such progress, then perhaps future friendlies will prove more alluring to the Irish public irrespective of the context.
3. Troy Parrott makes long-awaited debut
It already feels like people have been talking about Troy Parrott since forever, such is the hype that has surrounded him.
So itโs amazing to think the Dublin-born striker is still only 17.
Last night was perhaps his biggest test yet, as the wider Irish footballing public finally got a chance to see the player that the more hardcore fans have been raving about already on account of some eye-catching U21 displays and YouTube highlight reels.
Mick McCarthy summed up his performance nicely afterwards. โTroy did okay. He didnโt set the world on fire, but what he did I was really pleased with. He ran the channels, had a couple of chances โ I know everyone is desperate for him to score โ but the โkeeper thwarted him. Iโm pleased, overall.โ
The one chance Parrott missed was hardly an easy one. Otherwise, he showed good intelligence, both in his positioning and his ability to hold the ball up and win free kicks.
He wonโt start against Denmark of course, but what bodes well is his nonchalance. Both in terms of the way he carried himself in the game and the manner in which he speaks during interviews, you donโt get the sense that he is fazed by the ever-increasing noise around him.
There is clearly fire in his belly too โ he squared up to Winston Reid last night after a coming together between the pair, while he was sent off in his last U21 match following an altercation with Evertonโs Moise Kean.
Overall though, for someone so young, he has taken to international football with admirable calmness and maturity.
The42 is on Instagram! Tap the button below on your phone to follow us!
Kevin Long is such a weird one.
29 years old. At Burnley for nearly ten years. Presumably on a half decent wage. Comes to the side in when Ben Mee or James Tarkowski are injured and rarely puts a foot wrong at EPL level.
Never complains in the press or agitates for a transfer.
Played well again for Ireland tonight but can really only be seen as a bit part player for his country because thatโs what he is for Burnley?
Couldnโt have him in ahead of Clark whoโs just after battling to win his place back in Steve Bruceโs improving Newcastle side.
@Donal McGrath: every time he plays he looks like our most assured defender, and is probably the best of them on the ball. Itโs a weird one alright, but if we actually want to play ball we need central defenders like him who can hold and pass the ball rather than lumping it forward after 2 or 3 sideways passes and getting themselves in trouble
@Donal McGrath: agreed regarding Kevin Long, looked solid again tonight. Clark done very well too and thought he would have been in with a chance of starting Monday potentially depending on the formation Mick goes with.
@Donal McGrath: i thought he was excellent and if i was any team coming up to the premiership that like to pass the ball out from the back hes a good option
I thought Cullen and Byrne were very good. Sadly they have no chance of starting on Monday.
Hendrick and mcclean need to prove themselves,which I doubt they will.
@Fr Romeo sensini.: agree 100%..in neither have performed well for Ireland in the last year or soโฆno doubting their commitment, but for me I wouldnโt start either against Denmark
Byrne should start, with more senior players around him he could really flourish. And we need to attack. Brady please no, awful display again. Missed an easy take down in the box and then gestured to someone like they had done something wrong. Maguire, good goal but overall very poor.
@Toon Army: agreed. Byrne is creative and his passing is top class. Always looking for a break. In my eyes should defo start.
@Toon Army: Itโs funny how everybody sees things differently, I like Byrne but thought he was average last night, maybe even poor, whereas I thought Maguire actually looked dangerous throughout the game and got the great goal to top off a very good performance. I also liked the look of Cullen in the first half but I feel he disappeared a bit in the second. Itโll be some craic if we somehow manage to beat Denmark or get through via the qualifiers and end up at the euros with a couple of games in Dublin!!
@Shane Flanagan: agree with your analysis . Shame Cullen didnโt keep it up for full 90 , you could see his value from first half performance if he played in Danes game. Mcguire isnโt good enough for the next step up unfortunately , very poor oppo last night.I agree would be good craic but not gonna happen . A draw is as good as we can get . No real goal threat. I was really looking forward to mcGold Connolly partnership ..such a a shame
@Michael Flannery: Maguire isnโt good enough?then where does that leave Collins?
@Thomas Devlin: exactly maguire had a really good match byrne browne parrot helped him with that . brady was pish .for a player of his โcaliberโ
It doesnโt matter how well any of them played because Mick McCarthy has his team picked and it includes McClean, Hendrick and Whealen. Afraid to take a gamble on Byrne, Cullen etc..
Love Parrotts play quick touches such clever movement.would love to see him and mc goldrick play as interchangeable 9 and 10
Heโs on the fringes, but any time Iโve seen Alan Judge I think heโs always lively, positive, accurate and creative bringing others around him into the game.
Josh Cullen was my MOTM. He could be used perfectly in this Irish team as he links the play between defenders and attackers so well and just what we need. He was the standout player in our last friendly too so definitely should be in with a shout on Monday to start but I doubt Mick even has him in his thoughts for Monday unfortunately.
I never knew the nz soccer team were the all whites.and the nz basketball team are the TALL blacks. GENIUS.
@Seriously stunned:
Our basketball team are the LITTLE Leprechauns better than GENIUS.
Robinson,Maguire,OโDowda and a half fit out of form Brady still all better options than James McClean on the left.Cullen was awesome as was Jack Byrne.
Thought Lee OโConnor was solid throughout and the most impressive of the newbies. Great cross for the goal.
Parrott was OK. Iโd actually completly agree with Mick Mcโs opinion. โTroy did okay. He didnโt set the world on fire, but what he did I was really pleased with. He ran the channels, had a couple of chances โ I know everyone is desperate for him to score โ but the โkeeper thwarted him. Iโm pleased, overall.โ I would ask the question though, is Adam Idah more deserving of playing last night? He has looked more impressive in the u21 campaign to date than TP imo.
Byrne I thought was very poor. The game was made for a player of his ilk and he didnโt produce anything of note. Ireland had loads of possession and if Byrne canโt show well in that game then he has no place playing against stronger opposition. Heโs busy and looks the part, but what did he actually do with the ball? He offers nothing defensively either.
Having watched the U21 game, I like the look of Coventry and we all know about Molumby. Both are much more rounded players than Byrne for example. Both can attack and defend, box to box type players. Byrne is a luxury number 10 type player and I canโt see too many Irish teams over the next 10 years requiring such a player.
@John Lewis Hamilton: Canโt agree with that. He was involved in everything we did that was good in the first half. We had lotโs of possession because he didnโt lose the ball. Faded a bit in the second but we went a bit more direct and he has played a full season now. Youโre complaining that he didnโt defend while also talking about how poor the opposition wasโฆ.where did he let them team down defensively?
Cullen definitely played well enough to force his way into the starting 11, in place of Whelan, and since its a game we need to win Iโd rather have Byrne in place of Hendrick who has contributed very little in years. Itโs between Robinson and Maguire to play alongside McGoldrick and I think Robinson will hold on to his place. But I think Mick will start with his tried and tested and none of the starting 11 from last night will start Monday, bar perhaps the keeper if Randolph doesnโt recover from injury.
@Ger: The jack Byrne talk is over the top. Every manager in England and Scotland must be wrong. He has some nice touches and plays a few nice passes. You are on about replacing a premier league regular with a 10m price tag . Utter nonsense
@Michael Flannery: Every manager in England and Scotland? How about Holland and Ireland? Did you ask all of them? His troubles in England have been well documented and need to be taken in context. This site alone has done the story to death. At Oldham he was playing brilliantly but they froze him out because they needed to cut the wage bill. The fans petitioned to have him brought back in. Judge him on merit. Heโs a 23 year old who can play positive, exciting football. Hendrick may have been valued at 10m at one stage but who would pay that based on his performances for Ireland? Not saying Jack should take his place but your arguments arenโt all that useful.
Hadnโt really seen Cullen play until last night but was really impressed with his ability to link the play with passes from deep. If Glenn Whelan was to get injured or suspended, I think Cullen could do a good job as his replacement.
@EK: if Glen Whelan wasnโt available I think Christy Brown would do a good job as his replacement
@Thomas Devlin: Not in the squad
I cant for the life of me understand the whole Jeff Hendrick thing he was a decent player once but he has literally done nothing this whole qualifying campaign to deserve automatic selection. He spent the last 2 or 3 matches handing the ball back to the opposition through bad passing and im talking 5 or ten yard basic 8 year old could do it stuff. We played some nice ball last night but i presume we will be back to the old hoof it and hope monday night
@Michael McGrath: He just doesnโt look arsed. Itโs time to call a spade a spade. He looks bored out there for both Ireland and Burnley
@Michael McGrath: if they tried something different and lostโฆso be it
@Michael McGrath: if they tried something different and lostโฆso be it
@Michael McGrath: if they tried something different and lostโฆso be it
Someone tell Whelan to pack it in please.
It didnโt matter if the Lads had scored ten goals last night the same inept players that Mick has inexplicable faith in will start on Monday and Randolph will probably be man of the match,enough said.
Honestly, compared to just how bad our midfield and upfront has been lately, Iโd be playing this and hoping for the best. Randolph, Stevens, Clark, Duffy, Doherty โ Cullen, Browne, Hourihane โ Robinson, McGoldrick, Maguire.
put them all in the Danes wont have prepared for that !
For me Byrne has to start, looking like our best player now, also Maguire has to play as well, either starting or off the bench
Letโs be honest, we havenโt a hope against Denmark. Mick played ultra conservative against a bog standard Georgian team and now we are screwed. We were rubbish against the Swiss who were equally bog standard. Like MON and Trap, our managers are afraid of invention and afraid to play football. England obliterated Montenegro by playing attacking football. If our mindset is defend defend defend them what is the point? Iโll eat my virtual hat if anyone from that team stats against denmark
@Joe: Joe Joe your the man Iโve been saying this for years and everybody put there ole ole hats. This man is no better than o neill or trap only thing In His favour is 2 qualify from the group. Heโs a donโt concede at all costs manager and nobody that played last night will start on Monday. Iโm glad I stopped going after Paris 2009 if Iโm correcz
Dustin
โSQUAD UPDATE | Derrick Williams ruled out of #IRLDEN due to injury
Lee OโConnor will link back up with #IRLU21 โ
Parrott is 18. Duffy is unlikely to start on Tuesday
@Gerry Keogh: parrot is 17
@Gerry Keogh: why wont duffy start?
my Ideal 11
Randolph
Egan, Duffy, Clark
Doherty, Hendricks, Browne, Hourihane, Stevens
Connally Mcgoldrick
Not one of the players from last night will feature is Jack Byrne better than Glen Whelan yes will he start no is Troy Parrot as good as Scott Hogan or James Collins yes will he start no. Mick Mccarthy rarely changes his team he has his favourites just like when he managed before. By the way weโve only score 6 goals in 7 games and won just 3 Gibralta twice and Georgia. We donโt deserve to qualify but if we score first this man will shut up shop and try to hold on thatโs the way he manages.
team i would like to see 4-2-3-1randolph doherty duffy clarke stevens ,cullen hourihane ,maguire, mcoldrick, robinson,parrot
or
3-5-2 long duffy clarke, doherty stevens,cullen hourihane byrne mcgoldrick robinson/maguire. would suit wโbs at club level long and cullen pas it out from the back
at least we would hold onto the ball .byrne and hourihane dead balls .byrne is our best attackinng midfielder not scared to pass the ball tricks take lads on himself give orders he should be brought on if not started. and cullen has to start instead of an over the hill whelan
No way should Maguire be starting any kind of competitive game for Ireland