JOE SCHMIDTโS DREAM of bowing out as Ireland coach after guiding them to their first Rugby World Cup semi-final is set to be dashed, Irish rugby great Tony Ward predicts.
In Japan, Schmidt will bring down the curtain on six years of remarkable success that have included two historic wins over world champions New Zealand and three Six Nations titles, including only their third Grand Slam in 2018.
The New Zealander is keen to erase the memory of the hugely disappointing quarter-final exit to Argentina in the 2015 World Cup.
However, Ward โ regarded as one of Irelandโs finest ever fly-halves โ believes Schmidt will fall short of a last-four spot.
โThat is a massive step and for me a step too far,โ Ward, 64, told AFP.
โWe have a relatively easy pool, no disrespect to Scotland, but it is a given to qualify from that pool.
โBut then we could not have got a worse draw for the quarter-finals. (We will face) either the Springboks who are definitely on the up, or New Zealand.โ
Ward, the inaugural European player of the year in 1979, says he fears Ireland will suffer most in the line-out, a facet of their game that was starkly exposed in the humiliating 57-15 thrashing by England last month.
โA potential weakness is the absence of Devin Toner and his importance to the line-out,โ said Ward.
โHe has been sacrificed for this strategy of tight lock, first with Quinn Roux then now Jean Kleyn. The line-outs have been a problem.โ
Toner was the most controversial omission from the squad having started 50 of the 68 Tests Ireland have played under Schmidt. South Africa-born Kleyn only became eligible under the three-year residency rule in August.
With Toner standing at almost seven feet he is very hard to miss and I fear if Ireland do not get their line-out in order their game could fall apart.
โBut Rory Best is worth his place (as hooker) for what he brings to the side in terms of his captaincy โ he is an excellent leader โ and all-round work rate, including tackling.โ
- โDampened expectationsโ -
Ward, whose 19 Ireland caps spread over nine years (1978-87) would have been considerably more but for competing with Olly Campbell, says it was encouraging to see World Player of the Year Jonathan Sexton play for an hour in the 19-10 victory over Wales last Saturday.
Sextonโs fitness is of prime importance to the Irish, especially with number two fly-half Joey Carbery recovering from an ankle injury, leaving the inexperienced Jack Carty as the back-up potentially for the opening game against Scotland on 22 September.
โSexton will have been delighted to have got some minutes of game time into his legs as he looked ring rusty having not played since May,โ said Ward.
โNo matter how much training you have done it is game time that matters.
โHe will have gained immeasurable self-confidence from his run-out against the Welsh and likewise (scrum-half) Conor Murray, as neither have been playing well this year.
It is crucial those two hit the ground running (against Scotland) as after the line-out they are the next building block.โ
Ward said the back-to-back wins over Wales were encouraging and decried Welsh head coach Warren Gatlandโs assessment of last Saturdayโs defeat that the Irish โchoked us (Wales) to death.โ
โIreland were very effective, and they need to repeat that performance in Japan,โ said Ward.
โThat was really poor of Warren Gatland saying they had choked the game.โ
Ward, though, says Ireland are capable of beating anyone on their day but several below-par performances this year have lowered the heady expectations following the Six Nations Grand Slam and the defeat of the All Blacks in 2018.
โThese results have dampened expectations in general and rightly so,โ he said.
โGoing as the number one-ranked team in the world is total nonsense and reflects the stupidity of World Rugbyโs rankings system.
โWe are definitely not the number one country in the world. The lesser expectations from the public is exactly what Joe (Schmidt) will want.โ
Former Ireland performance analyst and current coaching wizard of OZ Eoin Toolan joins Murray Kinsella and Gavan Casey to predict Irelandโs World Cup, break down every pool, and call the overall winners.
The42 Rugby Weekly / SoundCloud
Yeah, cheers Tony. Iโm sure the lads are delighted with your faith in them.
Heโs right though, would we beat the All Blacks or South Africa now? Unlikely. England and Australia ahead of us as well and we caught Wales on a bad day.Also most think we will take Scotland handy enough, not so sure. All sounds negative i know, but its where weโre at right now.
Thatโs the spirit Tony !!!
Tony Ward is some waffler.
Grrat to have faith in the lads ,I DO!!!!!
Itโs amazing how many ex players honestly donโt want Ireland to make a semi final. The begrudgery in this country is scary.
@Chris Mc: I donโt see where he said he didnโt want them to make the semiโs. Just that he didnโt believe they would. Surely nothing wrong with that??
@Chris Mc: Vert true Chris, Ward is right as often as he won with Irelandโฆ.
Heโs right though. Heโs allowed express an honest opinion.
@Bill Clay: right about what?, that Ireland will lose to NZ/SA at quarter final stage, yes heโs allowed to express an opinion, but that doesnโt mean heโs right or wrong seen as this game hasnโt even happened yet.
@DERRY1973: they will lose to sa.. I know the irfu fanboys wonโt appreciate that
@Bill Clay: What!? call yourself a fan!?! Call yourself an Irishman?! Call yourself a bill!?โฆ
@Bill Clay: Ward is rarely right. You must be new to the sportโฆ.example , here he is picking the 2011 Irish WC teamโฆ..https://www.therugbyforum.com/threads/tony-wards-30-man-ireland-squad-for-the-world-cup.22995/ If you read him often enough, you will see most lads on here the 42 are more informative.
Give the lads a chance!
You canโt slate the guy for being honest. And as much as want Ireland to go on to the semi final and further, if im honest, I donโt think they will.
@gillespieonthew: I honestly didnโt think we would beat NZ twice in 3 years.
Christ, thatโs the spirt Ward. Can just imagine , you and Neil Francis , hanging around with each other, talking absolute b*******
It might suit us to be underdogs in qf, Last 2 world cups we had so-called favourable draws against Wales and Argentina and were well-beaten in both. South Africa being talked up an awful lot but if we play well we have every chance against them. I would be less hopeful against NZ but even that is not impossible. Letโs not write
ourselves off too soon
I have to say, itโs really frustrating to see commentators write off Scotland. Glasgow regularly put Irish clubs to the sword and we rarely have a walkover with scotland. Their back three have plenty speed and could skin us.
@B Collins: They could but they wont
@B Collins: Scotland have beaten us once in the last 7 games weโve played against them. A game where they played well, we played badly, which was played in Murrayfield and it was still a 1 score game. Their record against tier 1 countries outside Murrayfield is incredibly poor. They could beat us, but it would be unlikely and would be counter to almost everything weโve seen on the recent past.
@b collins: not regularly Irish clubs beat them when it counts
@B Collins: Good point, i said it earlier, everyone thinks weโll take the Scots easy enough, not so sureโฆ. although we will prob get to quarter final, but thats as far as we go i reckon. This is based on current form.
When is the last time we lost to either of those teams? 2 years ago?? After we beat SA to a series at home and beat NZ in Chicago? My memory is not what it used to be but the $h1tโฌ coming out of these pundits leaves me steaming hastag awkwardfacts
An Ireland vs England final would be my dream scenario too!!!! Fingers crossed!! รire abรบ!!!!!!!!
Putting the moan already typical in English football but not expected here lets get behind the team go on Ireland