WHETHER YOU’RE INCLINED to call it the Principality, the Millennium or an interstellar cruise-liner docked next to the Arm’s Park, the word ‘Cardiff’ is all that’s needed to conjure a wealth of recent Irish rugby nostalgia.
Late drop goals, Heineken Cups, humbling defeats to rampant reds and a cherished Grand Slam of our own. By 2013, with five wins from seven clashes against Wales in their new ground, it felt like a place where Irish teams could handle anything thrown at them.
Eight long years have passed since Ireland last beat Wales on their own patch in anything other than a pre-World Cup warm-up. These were years with no shortage of success: three Six Nations titles, a Grand Slam and global recognition as a force to be reckoned with, but Joe Schmidt’s Cardiff recollections are not as sweet as Ireland’s collective memory.
2015, before being pummeled by the Pumas at the venue in that year’s World Cup, Schmidt had Ireland on pace to deliver an emphatic Six Nations title defence by way of Grand Slam.
He entered Cardiff with three wins from three, but left it bemoaning Wayne Barnes after Leigh Halfpenny kicked open a sizeable lead and a late scrum penalty denied Ireland a chance to cross out the seven-point deficit.
In 2017 the sides met in round four again, but neither were in such rude health. A debacle over an Edinburgh bus made a mockery of Irish attention to detail. Wales had also lost to the Scots by the time Ireland arrived on their doorstep. Robbie Henshaw was left in the Laws of the Game confessional booth after scuppering a late Irish maul on the verge of a try, but serious damage had already been sustained to Irish title hopes and Conor Murray’s shoulder before half-time. The scrum-half laboured on with the issue for five second half minutes before Kieran Marmion was called in to aid a resurgence.
The less said about 2019 the better. All the warning signs for a woeful World Cup were already manifest in the spring; a team trying to talk its way into form and title contention before being thoroughly hosed.
All in all, Cardiff has been a fairly miserable spot in recent Irish rugby history. Today (kick-off 3pm, Virgin Media) is Andy Farrell’s chance to change the tune.
Scotland have made this a fine weekend for droughts to end and there will never be as ripe an opportunity to pick off Wales at this venue with the host’s patchy form, depleted personnel and absence of a crowd to make the Principality a cauldron. Mind you, even without a crowd, this won’t exactly be a sterile arena. The roof will be open in cold conditions and the newly laid pitch will provide the bumps in the road.
Although Farrell urged some caution in drawing attention to the eight-year-gap Ireland need to bridge today, the fingerprints of a man willing to err on the side of adventure are on his opening starting line-up of the Championship with James Lowe and Hugo Keenan trusted in the back-field on Six Nations debut and former Scarlets favourite Tadhg Beirne deployed next to James Ryan.
Four more of the men who made their Test debut last year are alongside the returning Tadhg Furlong on the bench, but otherwise the head coach has been able to choose from tried and tested stalwarts who bring the added benefit of being in form.
Wales coach Wayne Pivac this week noted that ‘there is less discussion and more work being done’ by way of differentiating this setup from the autumn. However that bears out after the first whistle, this Welsh pack won’t want for experience and grizzle with a black-eyed Alun Wyn Jones leading and Justin Tipuric, Ken Owens and Taulupe Faletau setting out to disrupt Ireland’s rhythm.
Josh Adams made himself a high-profile absentee – another victim to the scourge of gender-reveal parties – but with 20-year-old Gloucester flyer Louis Rees-Zammit on the wing, there is potency in the home side’s back three. It’s in the centre where Ireland appear to have a clear edge. Robbie Henshaw and Garry Ringrose are reunited in green for the first time since the World Cup and they will hope their partnership can expose a new combination of George North and Johnny Williams.
Speaking after Ireland’s captain’s run yesterday, Simon Easterby lamented slow starts that had cost Ireland in defeats here in 2015, 2017 and 2019.
Having spent his first year speaking about how his team must get better at being adaptable and be able to cope with changing situations, Farrell will be determined that his team won’t be deterred by early scoreboard pressure.
Victory by almost any route would be a sign of this team’s progress at the beginning of year two under Farrell.
Wales:
15. Leigh Halfpenny
14. Louis Rees-Zammit
13. George North
12. Johnny Williams
11. Hallam Amos
10. Dan Biggar
9. Tomos Williams
1. Wyn Jones
2. Ken Owens
3. Tomas Francis
4. Adam Beard
5. Alun Wyn Jones (captain)
6. Dan Lydiate
7. Justin Tipuric
8. Taulupe Faletau
Replacements:
16. Elliot Dee
17. Rhodri Jones
18. Leon Brown
19. Will Rowlands
20. Josh Navidi
21. Gareth Davies
22. Callum Sheedy
23. Nick Tompkins
Ireland:
15: Hugo Keenan
14: Keith Earls
13: Garry Ringrose
12: Robbie Henshaw
11: James Lowe
10: Johnny Sexton (Captain)
9: Conor Murray
1: Cian Healy
2: Rob Herring
3: Andrew Porter
4: Tadhg Beirne
5: James Ryan
6: Peter O’Mahony
7: Josh Van Der Flier
8: CJ Stander
Replacements
16: Ronan Kelleher
17: Dave Kilcoyne
18: Tadhg Furlong
19: Iain Henderson
20: Will Connors
21: Jamison-Gibson Park
22: Billy Burns
23: Jordan Larmour
The42 is on Instagram! Tap the button below on your phone to follow us!
It looks like something that would be built in the 80s. No imagination.
Pity the GAA didn’t fund this themselves they’re well able to
@Jamie: should have been redesigned once the fcuk up structurally was confirmed and the whole stadium needed to be knocked. It should have been built as an all seater modern multi sport municipal stadium, government funded, co-owned and run that the whole city could have been proud of. Can you imagine cork with international soccer and big rugby matches. Instead we have a glorified greyhound track, rebuilt as per the 1970s design that will be empty bar 3-4 games a year. Such a waste.
@Leo Erah: 100% agree with you
@Leo Erah: Amen to that!
@Leo Erah: while that is the perfect solution can you see the GAA, IRFU and FAI ever sharing stadiums all over the country.
@Fear Uisce: fai and irfu do at the aviva you should rephrase that as the GAA
@Jamie: I said all around the country. the GAA was happy enough to let them use Croker for a few years
@Fear Uisce: Ye because of the cash on offer that’s the only reason
@Jamie: joke in Limerick too. Gaelic Grounds never used and when it is tiny crowds given the size of the venue. Markets Field for soccer, Thomond Park the only decent modern stadium of the three. For a city the size of Limerick is bananas having three venues.
@Jamie @Fear Uisce @Leo Erah: No prizes for guessing you guys aren’t GAA fans :-) You are taking a very simplistic view on the matter by not considering the GAA’s position.
You are ignoring the key fact that there is competition for players here. The FAI and IRFU have an international dimension giving them earning potential that far exceeds the GAA. The GAA has infrastructure in the form of stadia and local grounds, why would they give away their trump card? It is all very well to bury your head in the sand and pretend the associations are not in competition with each other, they clearly are.
Also painting the GAA as money grabbing is factually in correct, it is very well run from a financial point of view at least. Check out their publicly available financial report to see how the money filters down to the clubs. The government grant for Pairc ui Chaoimh is only a fraction of what the IRFU and FAI received for the Aviva.
@Ted Logan: it’s better than a lot of the crap stadiums that we have in Ireland
@Ted Logan: better than a lot of the crap stadiums we have in this country
@Leo Erah: bang on
Do you think the Fai get the Aviva free of charge or something. While they have a ground sharing contract and split the debt, the ground still belongs to the irfu
@Ted Logan: jealous
@Dahayeser: in Australia same level of competition between federations, however grounds are municipal and shared. GAA have stadia today because funding has been provided by government. In a country the size of Ireland 3 stadiums in one small city is nuts. As for this new stadium a revamped version of an outdated and dangerous relic. Shocking!!!
Ger lane was not available for comment. He was to busy on the trowel.
If in theory dublin and Kk win, wex have to play dublin, and they’re going to bring the game to cork? Do they not usually wait to see the draw before the venue is announced?
@MunsterFan: never mind, misread the bit about the meeting once the games are over this w/e
I would be shocked if this is ready lads. No second fixtures inside the building complete yet. The outside areas are still a building site, with mounds of rubble and earth everywhere. Wooden hoarding up and no perimeters in place. Builders compound still full and workers still going at it 24/7. It may open but it will look shite and not ready and if that’s the case what’s the point?
They’ll be lucky to have it open for Ed Sheeran at this rate and that’s assuming an Bord Pleanala grant them planning permission for it!
@Leo Erah: got nothing to do with planning ( which goes to city council not bord pleanala), all they need do is apply to city council for an event licence.
@John Buckley: that’s incorrect. An Bord Pleanalas terms of granting planning specifically called out that planning was granted for the venue as a “sporting venue” and not to be used for recreational use pending additional planning applications. I.e. No planning for venue to be used for concerts. Have a read of the planning submissions on the city council website. They also need a licence from the council on top of the planning which is no slam dunk.
@Leo Erah: Thats incorrect. There is no point in reading submissions as they are observations made by the public. The planning conditions are all that matter. Cork City Council have said the concerts do not require planning and only require an events licence. The use of the word ancillary in the conditions is probably what makes this possible. There is no condition to make them go for planning for concerts.
@John Buckley: the planning conditions from an Bord pleanala are all on the system also John, they specifically call out concerts and non sporting events needing separate planning applications. It’s all there in black and white and the the cork board commented on it at the time saying it hey would be returning for additional planning. Have a read of the full report from an Bord pleanala.
@John Buckley: just dug it out – section 13.20 of the inspectors report says “this application does not include provision for concerts”. It defines ancillary as use of the stand facilities by the GAA and third parties.
@Leo Erah: The only condition relating to this is: 3- all uses hereby permitted shall be ancillary to the principal use of the development site as a sports facility. It says nothing about requiring planning for concerts. Cork City council have stated planning is not needed for concerts, only an events licence.
@John Buckley: go to the section I called out above in the report. It clarifies concerts and explains ancilary. It’s not for concerts. Feel like I’m banging my head off a brick wall here.
@Leo Erah: no condition says they need to get planning to hold a concert. Both the Lord Mayor and a senior council official have stated concerts do not require planning and only need a events licence. The official is qualified to interpret the planning conditions, you are not. In their opinion a license is sufficient.
@John Buckley: have you read the Bord Pleanala report I pointed you towards? I specifically says that concerts are excluded from the planning application and that ancillary use is for events with up to 600 personnel present outside of sporting occasions. I don’t give a fup what the Lord Mayor says it’s there in black and white. Our local residents committee even reviewed it last week and the local councillor confirmed the GAA needed to reapply for planning for the event to go ahead. Jesus man.
@Leo Erah: I don’t care what the local councillor said, it’s the senior council official that is the expert. The description of the sports facility on the inspectors report is taken from the Cork City Development plan. This hasn’t changed in years so they can do what the did for the Bruce Springsteen concert and apply for an events licence and not planning. Your residents committee should get an experts opinion and not an unqualified councillors opinion.
You’re right John, I’ll just ignore the Bord Pleanala report that states it in black and white so and listen to what the “senior council” allegedly said. #youcantakeahorsetothewater
@Leo Erah: Croke park planning permission has a condition limiting it to 3 concerts a year, this was the problem with Garth Brooks. Pairc ui Chaoimh only condition is its use as a sports facility. In 1999 the supreme court ruled that Lansdowne road, a sports facility, did not require planning permission for concerts. These require a public events licence under the planning and development act 2000. Cork County Board probably intentionally kept concerts out of the planning so they would not be conditioned on it and then would comply with planning act by getting a license.
A lot of gaa bashing on here today. What’s new I suppose. #clowncomments
@Conor O’ Sullivan: more Cork County Board bashing than GAA bashing..
I have great respect for the GAA but as a GAA follower in Cork who has witnessed the incompetence of a dictatorial Cork County Board I have zero confidence in them or their ability to run a modern stadium.
@Conor O’ Sullivan: Looks great! 45k capacity – well done lads :)
With the amount of tax funds spent on this stadium 300 houses could have been built in Cork to ease the current crisis, and considering the state of the infrastructure within the city such as roads,money should have been spent to accommodate all tax payers rather than just a few gaa fans. Aviva stadium got zero funding and IRFU and FAI had to pay rent to the gaa for Croke Park, which also received government funding over the years.The GAA should only get funding through the budget like all other sports and not a sent more for inclusive stadiums. Tax payers money could have been more wisely spent and if all tax payers funds are spent on a stadium then all sports should have been included.
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: the aviva got €191m of government funding
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: check your facts. The Aviva Stadium got €192 million in government funding. That’s more than twice what Croke Park got. Does that change your tune in any way about what sports should be played where, or about how money spent on stadia could be ‘better’ spent?
@Jumperoo: no not at all, you’re getting your ‘facts’ from an article which was written in 2010 which refers to the 191m figure as the governments estimated cost of surrounding infrastructure to support the stadium . The gaa gets extortionate funding from the government and lotto which could be better spent. Taking upwards of 50 million out of a economy like cork when hospitals, roads and housing are in bits is shameful. Ireland is a modern country with modern needs and to have the GAA still intertwined in the Irish political landscape is stupid, outdated and only facilitates a very few tax payers. This is not about which sports get what its about what the county needs and where the money is being spent. A terraced stadium which will be sold out once year may not be the wisest investment
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: pretty sure I’m getting it from the aviva stadium website where you can download the factsheet https://www.google.ie/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://www.avivastadium.ie/docs/default-document-library/download-the-aviva-stadium-fact-sheet-here-.pdf%3Fsfvrsn%3D0&ved=0ahUKEwjb07XWvvDUAhVQKVAKHd24BmcQFggtMAE&usg=AFQjCNEc-s-FUw3NCCl6Kg14iNnpdFBZiQ
@Donal Ryan: Lets say Billy in Mitchelstown hurts his neck playing football and needs to be rushed to hospital, they cant take him 20 minutes away to Mallow as the hospital is under funded, under staffed and under treat of closure due to lack of funding. So Billy must travel 50 minutes to Cork City where his neck gets moved and injured further due to bad roads. Then poor Billy is out of work and cant afford the extortionate rent he has to pay brought on by current housing crisis but good old Billy is in great spirits because at least he has a second rate stadium to visit once a year paid for by the Irish tax payer. 30m from the government and 20m from the council for a unneeded stadium is just irresponsible spending especially when there are failing facilities.
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh:
Billy should have taken the motorway instead of trying to avoid the toll going on bad roads
@Donal Giltinan: Motorway doesn’t lead directly to any hospital in cork, so its 50 mins. Do you know how to use google maps donal? your narrow minded, parochial and conservative point of view is typical of the GAA community. Ignorance is bliss I suppose so ignore the valid points made, just stick to your own narrative good man.
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: what’s that got to do with the aviva getting €191m
Hold on….since when was Cork a neutral venue??? Some neck expecting ppl will travel that far for a qualifier…good luck to them!
@patrick keane: Sure Cork is lovely for a weekend out :)
If cork city got a big team in Europe would they offer them to use it considering turners cross holds 6,000??
Who cares, Galway don’t have to go #Galway4Liam
@Trev Gilmore: hon the premier!!! We will prob beat dublin but then thats i’d say. Anyone but kilkenny then
@Trev Gilmore: Gaillamh Abu 2017
I took the virtual reality tour of Pairc Ui Chaoimh last week and it struck me as a fine job when it will be finished
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: why wouldn’t billy take the motorway from mitchelstown to cork?
i was there in1976 Cork v Kerry and nothing worked the turnstiles could not take the crowd so the fans broke down the gates after that the fans spilled unto the sidelines get it right this time CON.
@Pol Mac An Sionnaigh: yes I can use Google maps pol and if you can too you’ll see it’s motorway and dual carriageway the whole way from mitchelstown to CUH. Not a bad road in site. It was a light hearted comment poking fun, not meant to cause you such anguish
Ah lads lads
Do ye think the governing board would have the design foresight or be aloud to :) or indeed think of the wider cork sports :) Did they find the boss’s big seat ☝️he who can’t be named