FRANCE EDGED SOUTH Africa 30-26 in the Autumn Nations Series in Marseille on Saturday after both sides had leading players shown red cards for dangerous play.
The Springboks’ 2019 World Rugby Player of the year Pieter-Steph du Toit was sent off inside the first quarter-of-an-hour before last year’s award winner and captain Antoine Dupont suffered the same fate after the break for the home side.
Les Bleus, next year’s Rugby World Cup hosts, laid down a marker with a win over the Webb Ellis trophy holders less than 10 months out from the tournament.
France head coach Fabien Galthie kept the same starting line-up from last weekend’s win over Australia, the country’s record 11th straight victory.
After the smoke from the pre-match show lifted, Springboks captain Siya Kolisi came out of the tunnel sprinting in front of the 65,000 full house, reminiscent of when he became the first black player to lead his country in June 2018.
Thomas Ramos kicked a penalty to make it 3-0 to the hosts before du Toit’s moment of madness after just 12 minutes as he headbutted Jonathan Danty at a ruck.
Galthie was forced to re-shuffle his back-line with Danty off for a head injury assessment as flanker Sekou Macalou came onto the wing and Yoram Moefana moved to centre.
Galthie’s outfit took the ascendancy and Ramos added a second penalty to make it 6-0 after 17 minutes before Cyril Baille crashed over just after the quarter mark.
Ramos slotted the extras to make it 13-0 with the Webb Ellis trophy holders stunned.
Winger Cheslin Kolbe scored a penalty to make it 13-3 after 25 minutes to calm the away side’s nerves.
Kolisi’s pre-game passion lifted to another level on the half-hour mark as he spun away from a rolling maul to slide over, then celebrated by pointing to the sky, before Kolbe kicked the additional points to make it 13-10.
With things finely balanced and the Boks calmed after du Toit’s red card, Ramos was successful with a third penalty which made it 16-10 at the break.
- Uncle Falatea -
Kolbe and Ramos traded penalties after the interval as France led 19-13 with 35 minutes remaining.
Dupont then followed Du Toit as he took out Kolbe in the air from a Faf de Klerk kick with the Boks camped inside Les Bleus’ 22m.
After a second lineout Willie le Roux found Kurt-Lee Arendse with a sublime pass before scrum-half de Klerk slotted the touchline conversion to make it 20-19 with less than half an hour to play.
Dupont’s opposite number De Klerk, having taken over the kicking duties from Kolbe, off for a head injury assessment, and Ramos exchanged shots at goal to leave the score at 23-22 to set up a tense final quarter.
De Klerk was subbed off before Damian Willemse made it 26-22 with a penalty.
After three pick and gos on the South Africa line, replacement prop Sipili Falatea buried over, two phases after his nephew Yoram Moefana had broken the defensive line.
Barnes’ checked the try with his video referee before Ramos missed the conversion leaving the score 27-26 with four minutes to go.
France’s 12th straight victory was sealed with less than two minutes on the clock as Ramos kicked a penalty from 45m to stake their claim for next year’s World Cup.
Christ, 3 articles in 24 hours.
We get it.
1)Class player who’s critical to Munster and a great player for Ireland when selected.
2)Offered bigger money overseas which the irfu just can’t match.
3)Good but not good enough to pick for Ireland if he goes abroad. (Only applies to Murray, sexton, and probably furlong)
4) it’s heaslip’s and the Kearney brothers’ fault.
Come back when you some real updates.
@sup: total overkill
I started reading the 42.ie mainly because of the detailed and clever rugby analysis articles that they had. Having never played rugby but yet being an avid fan it was very interested to read the depth and knowledge of some reporters on the skills and tactics of the game.
There seems to be no analysis on the 42.ie just cheap click bait articles on common topics repeated and rehashed.
Please bring back the in depth analysis and not this player agent pushed drivel.
@William O’Gorman: Murray Kinsella was the one doing the brilliant analysis but he’s taken a sabbatical since the lions tour. Hopefully he’ll be back before the 6 nations!
@sup: Murray was probably the best analyst going, hope he is back soon, without him the 42 has just gone for the mundane.
@William O’Gorman: well said William.
I can’t understand why the defence to this situation is the irfu can’t compete with England and France , I don’t see the relevance , the news is the irfu offer is not acceptable for omahony , it’s rumoured to be 350k for both his contracts , Luke fitz was on more when he retired for a context example,
Omahony is the exact person that would happily stay at Munster but also seems a proud fella that wouldn’t stand for disparity within the international set up, if he’s on less than a lot of his Irish teammates past and present and he is shouldering the responsibility of the real embodiment of Munster then he should hold out. He hasn’t once referred to being interested in moving just that there are offers if he needs them. It’s a matter of fix our ship before blaming the bigger ship next to us
Years ago when I coached at under age level the difference between a vocal/aggressive captain in the changing rooms and a not so vocal one was amazing. The entire team used to get so pumped up and it used to make a massive difference to have a captain able to psyche up his team. I was in the crowd once and within ear shot at an SCT game where Shane Jennings was the captain and before kickoff I heard him talk to his players and he was phenomenal at it. POC had it and POM has it. The “don’t fcuk with us” mad man look on his face. You can’t teach that and it’s a very important trait to have in your leader.
@Gary: they certainly do have it ! But Shane Jennings went to Leicester for two years as did Leo … SOB , Murray , Sexton , POC , all leaders , Donnacha Ryan , too . When Ireland lost to Argentina in 2015 it was because of the lack of leaders on the pitch , POM was gone , OBrien was gone , Sexton gone , POC gone … but now there are plenty more and by 2019 Furlong , Hendo, Henshaw will be strong leaders so POM will hopefully stay home , get a good deal and be on board . If he doesn’t well I wish him every success
If he or Stander go all the Munster fans will be up in Dublin with their pitchforks and torches
@Peter Brophy: let them ! Look at Jordi Murphy , he’s moving to Ulster , so there’s even more competition for backrow playing all the big weekends . O’Mahony deserves a nice raise but Ireland still got great results before he got back from injury . So either a compromise is reached or good luck and all the best . There is no way JS will pick a backrow player playing overseas between now and May 2019 . After that he may decide that he needs these players for Japan no matter where they’re playing , but not before .
@Limón Madrugada: we need pom for the world cup in my opinion
@Finbarr O Donovan: we need every quality player available but backrow is stocked . We don’t know who’ll get injured , who’ll be a bolter . I would love to have POM in the squad every time . But if you give him special status overseas he won’t get the rest and ‘protection’ required . And you’re sending a signal ( of the wrong kind) to four or five more ‘key’ players .
With Marty Moore coming back , Jordi Murphy going north there are signs that there are players who are showing their commitment to the IRFU . These guys will have a slight priority in order to show how swapping provinces is the way forward and going outside the provinces is not.
@Limón Madrugada: when did Ulster sign jordi Murphy.?
@Limón Madrugada: never heard that Murphy was off to Ulster. Is this confirmed or just talk?
@David OfBrien: thornley seems pretty certain of it in his IT article thismorning
@Finbarr O Donovan: why? Ireland performed just as well without him. There are 2, maybe 3, indispensable players for Ireland – Murray, Sexton and maybe Furlong (our increasing depth at TH means we could lose him without dire consequences). Every single other player can be replaced with an option just as good. If every single player is fit, does POM make the Joe Schmidt XV? No. Does he make the bench? Maybe.
@grandslamkbo: He definitely starts if he’s fit! Key to the Irish setup. Nonsense to think Ireland could let either him or stander leave and we have an old heaslip sitting on a contract who wouldn’t even make the team in 2019 if all were fit.
@Limón Madrugada: Trying to compare POM leaving to jordi Murphy is madness. He couldn’t start for leinster and needed to move!
I’m delighted he has chosen to go up north but that is only an option for players who need game time or want to move up in standard.
@Peter Brophy: never heard about jordi murphy leaving, is it just a rumour or is there an announcement I missed?
@Andrew Gleeson: I’m not comparing Murphy directly to POM , I’m demonstrating that Murphy and others are showing a commitment to the Irish team and make no mistake this will be taken into account when it comes to split decisions . But while we’re on the subject Murphy was on the team that beat NZ , POM was still injured . Ireland manage to get excellent results with and without POM .
Ireland will be stronger with POM involved but have learned to get great results even without key players . Same goes if SOB left or Cian Healy or Stander even . Murray and Sexton ( especially with PJ still in limbo) are the only untouchables right now for me . With a bit of luck Luke McGrath , Marmion , Carberry , Bleyendal etc can reduce the gap .
@Andrew Gleeson: You think he plays if fit. I asked if he plays in a Schmidt team. You’re not Joe Schmidt. Schmidt doesn’t often play POM when he’s fit. That’s the point.
If IRFU can only afford to keep one of POM or CJ on the contracts they’d command id be interested to know who Munster supporters would prefer
@Paul K Murphy: there’s no way the IRFU can continue to pay the players a wage that will see them all stay.
The gap between what’s on offer in Ireland & abroad is widening. We all accept the IRFU cannot & should not compete.
Players of this profile will be leaving in the next year or two.
@Paul K Murphy: we have Marty Moore coming back and Jordi Murphy heading north. If one or both of POM or CJ goes, Munster have a massive problem. They’re both in an area where Ireland are strong. Not sure this constitutes a wave leaving (except from Munster). On another point, for any player who had dreams of leaving or maybe was disgruntled with life in Ireland, this is the most opportune time to do so. Especially if you’re not playing for Leinster. Just say you haven’t bee offered what you want and them watch the fury unleashed on the Union.
@Gustave H: The Pro 14 needs to generate more money. The SA teams joining has helped. If the move for a US team brings in the big money I’m all for it. Always said I dislike conferences and the travel but if its what is needed to prevent the provinces becoming feeder teams I’m all for it.
@Paul K Murphy: There is limited money. POM should be given a good offer but Ireland have to recognise that despite him being a big player, it’s a position we are strong in (even if, as i’ve already said, he’s our number one 6, with Heaslip out). The gap to the next guy is not that big. The IRFU money has to be prioritised – Furlong for example should be much more of a priority. In any case, POM is a homebird and won’t move unless his offer is insulting, which it won’t be. The IRFU need to realise these two points and budget accordingly. Ringrose for example isn’t even getting a national contract, as far as I know.
@Paul K Murphy: Rationale is players are already thinking about jumping post WC in 2019 for $$$$$. They want the best of both worlds – IRFU dead right to sign up as many to 2020 or beyond as possible.