“HE TOLD US his idea and everybody screamed with laughter.”
It is the response everybody dreads when they pitch a risky idea to a room full of people.
But the idea, put forward by the then-Lord Mayor of Dublin Gay Mitchell, was a radical one.
An ambitious plan that would change the cultural, social, economic and sporting landscape of the country forever. His detractors though, simply said it was a politically-motivated publicity stunt.
Surely Dublin could never host the biggest show on earth – the Olympic Games.
“A lot of people thought it was joke,” Jonathan Irwin explains to The42.
Dublin’s Challenge
Irwin, a prominent businessman, and who along with his wife Mary Ann has since gone on to establish the Jack and Jill Children’s Foundation, was an integral part of the ambitious project, but admits that even he initially believed that the idea of Dublin hosting an event of the magnitude of the Olympics was farcical.
It was back in 1992 that Mitchell first commissioned a report to discover if Dublin could make a credible bit to host the Games.
“Back in the early 1990s we had nothing: not the venues, not the motorways that we have today,” Irwin recalls.
“It was a very interesting time. We had really high calibre of people working on the report, and it became a blueprint for Dublin going forward.
“There were 14 different committees set up looking at everything ranging from accommodation, environment, transport, security, culture, marketing, finance, media and telecommunications. Every area had to produce a report within 18 months; we started with very little hope, but we were always looking at 2016.
“Pat Hickey [President of the Olympic Council of Ireland] initially rubbished the idea, but once the report was published he was very much on board.
We didn’t necessarily think we would win, but we had enough to put together a credible bid together. When the finance committee said it was possible, it became more of a realistic opportunity.
The project was deemed cost-effective in the Price Waterhouse report titled: Making an Olympic Bid: Dublin’s Challenge.
The vision would have seen Dublin’s docklands revamped into the Olympic village; Croke Park transformed into the main Olympic stadium for the track and field events; and Lansdowne Road, the RDS, and UCD’s Belfield campus all redeveloped to host other competitions. On top of that, the telecommunication and transport hubs would have been completely overhauled.
The regeneration of Dublin, a chance to encourage higher participation in sport, and the opportunity to advertise the country like never before on the world stage were all compelling arguments made in favour of the bid.
‘Positive experience’
Irwin took up the role of CEO of the Dublin International Sports Council (DISC) while former newspaper tycoon Tony O’Reilly became the chairman.
The remit of the body was straightforward: to demonstrate that the country’s capital was capable of staging some of the world’s biggest sporting events, with one eye on an Olympic bid.
Among the events staged in Dublin in the following years were the 1994 Women’s Hockey World Cup, the college football game in 1996 between Notre Dame and US Naval Academy — the first of its kind in Europe — as well as the opening stage of the 1998 Tour de France.
“The Tour de France was very complex to organise. It was like D-Day. It was a mighty undertaking; organising the machinery, arranging road closures and getting the riders back to France the next day.
“But it showed we had the capacity and the facilities. It was a very positive experience and showed we could not only host big events, but do them well.”
Another project that Irwin was involved in at the time was the possible transfer of Premier League football club Wimbledon from London to Dublin. At the time, Wimbledon had no stadium of their own, and controversial owner Sam Hammam was looking to sell.
“We thought we had it done. The only real stumbling block was that the FAI wouldn’t meet with us and we needed a licence from them. The Dublin Chamber of Commerce said it would be worth £22 million annually to Dublin.
“We would have a 40,000 seater-stadium in Clondalkin, and we struck a deal with Ryanair to transport the fans from the UK for the first year or two.
“The deal would have been better to attract players too. It is much more attractive to live in Dublin, than say Sunderland.”
But ultimately the ‘Dublin Dons’, as they would have been called, never happened and Wimbledon eventually became Milton Keynes Dons with the club’s proud history virtually erased from today’s incarnation. (In its place, a small group of hardcore fans did set up a new club, AFC Wimbledon, at the bottom of England’s footballing pyramid in 2002; after six promotions in 14 years, they will compete in the same division as MK Dons this season.)
Counting the cost
It is one thing to put an Olympic bid together, but quite another to convince the general public that spending billions of euro of taxpayers’ money is a worthwhile investment.
The view among many governments now is that the tangible and intangible benefits that come with staging events such as the Olympic Games rarely justify the significant investment required by the exchequer.
However, a poll conducted by the BBC a year after London 2012, showed more than two-thirds of the British public felt that the £9 billion spent to host the 2012 Games was well spent while 74% said they would like to see the Games return to Britain.
However, part of the London’s bid of the Olympics was to leave a lasting legacy and to “inspire a generation” to play more sport, goals which have failed to materialise as Rio approaches. Newly-released data from Sport England show that people now play less sport than they did in 2012, with the figure down 0.4% over that four-year period.
More startling is the fact that the biggest decline was among the among people from ethnic minorities and economically-disadvantaged groups.
In the past, hosting the Olympics may have been a dream, but it appears now that it could be an economic nightmare — not to mention the extra security required due to heightened terror threats that are now part of the process of staging major events.
Legacy
Although the Dublin Olympic report had its detractors, it also highlighted that if the money was invested in the right areas, there was scope for plenty of improvement in the capital.
“We did have capacity to host it,” Irwin continues. “We have things in our favour like a good time zone and no enemies. The conclusion was that we could do it. The next step was to get the government in favour of a bid, but we never got it.”
“People gave up time on voluntary basis. Meeting every week. People who shared my attitude were convinced it could happen.
“It was so long ago in a way. Ideas were revolutionary at the time. We missed our chance.
“2016 was to be the year. The staging of the Special Olympics of which I was a board member kind of morphed out of it.”
Perhaps staging the Games can be compared to giving the International Olympic Committee the keys to your house to host their party, in the hope that your reputation and popularity would exponentially be enhanced in the process.
But experience has shown that you’re the one left footing the bill and cleaning up the mess when they move on.
If you factor in all the recent controversies surrounding the Games, the shine of an Olympic gold medal for some, doesn’t seem as lustrous as it did 24 years ago.
With special thanks to Cllr Ruairi McGinley who assisted in the research of this article.
The42 is on Snapchat! Tap the button below on your phone to add!
Dublin would have been perfect. No problem for the athletes sourcing drugs.
The Olympics in Dublin……. Hahahahaha…..
Can’t get 6 Garth Brooks concerts sorted but can do the Olympics?? Yeah…..nah.
Haha brilliant. No other city had drugs problems. That’s why it’s so funny
Would have got it if we had included a decent bribes committee
Here we go again the auld Irish attitude laughng at such a bid. We have some marvelous rivers that would be brilliant for the canoeing. Brilliant golf courses. We have an 85,000 capacity stadium for track and field. We have the Aviva for the soccer, I am sure one of our many 30,000 + GAA Stadia could be used for sevens rugby. The 3 Arena for boxing. The list goes on. We could and we should be hosting an Olympics, World Cup and Euros.
Where is this 85,000 seat track and field stadium?!! Because croagh park doesn’t have a track last time I looked.
I do think holding the Olympics would be a stretch too far for a country of 4.6 million, however at the same time we do seriously need to shake off the small town attitude we have. Any badly needed major infrastructure project is often met with laughs of “ah shur what do we need that for you’d swear we’re all living in New York” or something along those lines.
Perhaps holding the Rugby World Cup would be a very achievable aim that would help people become a little bit more ambitious about the development of this country.
Yes and where were we going to get the money for revamping crokepark and the other stadiums? The Olympic village would be a bit of a problem don’t you think and families homeless? Not too mention the money that would have to be spent on public transport and infastruture in order to be even considered.
And plenty of turnstiles for the hurdle races
Don’t we have every nationality living in Dublin
Just organize them
Just alone regarding Croke Park:
Despite now being Europe’s 3rd largest stadium and sandwiched between two railway lines, it does not have even one railway station.
Moreover, a railway station was supposed to be provided when the stadium was redeveloped.
Yet strangely, when the GAA redeveloped above the railway tracks a few years ago, the station was never built – but CIE got two corporate boxes for heart own private use.
Now the GAA are baffled as to why the natives object when events such as concerts are proposed, yet all the while, the main and most obvious problem is movement of people – i.e. a transport issue.
If those in authority are too arrogant or oblivious so as to provide such obvious facilities – where infrastructure is already present regarding one stadium – it can only be considered a great blessing that Dublin was not burdened with further incompetence that would have happened with Olympics.
Engage brain before posting Phil. The article says back in the early 90′s we had no infrastructure. Most of the golf courses you refer to along with croke park the aviva the national aquatic centre were not built. Gay Mitchell was a gob sh**e back then and still is. Thankfully the people saw that when he went for president. Again I point out we had nothing as CJ had spent everything and hived it off for himself and his cronies.
It would’ve been our best chance at getting GAA into the Olympics…
Yes. We could’ve competed against ourselves. Guaranteed gold.
The Aussies would probably beat us in the football though
Poor old DOB would have made an absolute fortune in renting out his barriers – I bet you he is still wringing his hands and crying into his brandy over missing out.
That feasibility study must have cost a bit.
We couldn’t hold a Web summit
With the politicians in Ireland they would be off and running with all Comercial profits before the competition even started. A joke, the whole concept in the banans republic that the Irish politicians have shafted to their own gain going back to De Valera’s time. Tony Gregory was the last true Irish politician with integrity but then he didn’t have much competition
Gay mitchell is a populist. He wanted the headlines but never intended to host anything
I’m not sure how the beach volleyball would have fared on Dollymount Strand with the cold cold, wind and showers.
People thought it was a joke because it was a joke
Gay Mitchell is one of the biggest toolbags this country ever had, the first mainstream party candidate in the history of the state to lose his deposit when he ran for the Presidency !! His idea was completely mad & wasted a load of money at a time when the country hadn’t an ass in it’s pants. Deserves to be punched everytime he shows his weasel face in public !
Gay Mitchell is dead, have a pinch of respect ffs.
Gay Mitchel is not dead. His brother Jim is.
The poor of Brazil will suffer for decades because of the money they had to out into hosting it. No thanks leave it to bigger nations that have the money.
Olympics are a giant money pit. Way this county is we’re very lucky someone came to their senses and said no
It was a ridiculous idea, then same as now.
Irwin accused Mick Wallace of looking like a tramp. I can never listen to his west Brit voice after that. He also used his charity to run for the seanad.
The Dublin Dons would have been great
Cheaper to host than the recent bailout
well glad that didn’t go ahead would haven been yet more money spent on Dublin and the rest of the country shafted again! Dublin produces a log of gdp for Ireland…which is not a surprise given all development takes place there and so many people from outside sublime have had to move there dubliners can’t afford a house anymore. How ironic.
Dreaming in that is like Leitrim winning the all Ireland!
Amazing how public money can be spent on the ridiculous and it seem to be a relentless trait by the buffoons in power.