Advertisement
Did this man score Ireland's greatest ever international goal? Donall Farmer/INPHO

Open Thread: Was Aiden McGeady's strike yesterday Ireland's greatest ever goal?

Was McGeady’s effort better than Whelan’s shinner and Kennedy’s screamer?

IMMEDIATELY AFTER AIDEN McGeady’s stunning late winner for Ireland against Georgia yesterday, a few knees jerked so severely in TheScore.ie office that a couple of desks flipped over.

Immediately after we tidied up the strewn stationery and computers, someone legitimately asked whether McGeady’s magical turn and precise shot was Ireland’s greatest ever international goal?
http://vine.co/v/OzaOiVJXmJe

Of course, you are entitled to say “settle down lads, there have been plenty of better goals than that, baby!”, but what are they? And were any of them better than yesterday’s?

For the purpose of the debate, we are taking context out of it completely. We are judging goals solely on their aesthetic value and not factoring in their importance.

Here are a few that could challenge McGeady’s:

Ronnie Whelan vs USSR in 1988

Chimpanzeethat / YouTube

Mark Kennedy vs Yugoslavia in 1999

Chimpanzeethat / YouTube

Jason McAteer vs Netherlands in 2001

Adam Roylance / YouTube

Liam Miller vs Sweden in 2006 (last goal in video)

Chimpanzeethat / YouTube

But we want to here from you. What do you think is Ireland’s greatest international goal? Has there every been one better than McGeady’s? Leave your choice in the comments below, but don’t bother recommending a free kick; our stock as a footballing nation would plummet ever further if our greatest ever goal didn’t come from open play.

Reus a doubt for Ireland clash after injury blow

Would Ireland get better use out of McGeady as a number 10?

Close
48 Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.