Benetton 30
Munster 40
MUNSTER HAVE OVERTAKEN Benetton in the URC table after a 40-30 victory over the Italians which was both testing and thrilling.
Graham Rowntree’s men received two yellow cards — which overlapped for a costly couple of minutes in which they were reduced to 13 men — but scored six tries in Treviso to take maximum matchday points, while Ignacio Mendy’s last-play hat-trick dot-down was enough for Benetton to take a four-try bonus point which could yet prove crucial in the play-off race.
A broad palette of scores by Paddy Patterson, Jack O’Sullivan, John Hodnett, Jean Kleyn, Antoine Frisch and Joey Carbery was ultimately enough for the away side but Munster will be frustrated by the relative ease with which Benetton were able to conjure four of their own against the southern province’s typically more resolute defence.
Carbery, who started at out-half but wound up playing the majority of the game at fullback, had a mostly mixed day but his lung-bursting kick-chase in the 71st minute proved pivotal as Antoine Frisch finally took Munster out of reach of the courageous Italians.
It was a game whose back-and-forth excitement masked over periods of poor quality but, with such disruption to both squads and so much on the line between them this afternoon, all that truly mattered was the result.
Coming into this afternoon’s encounter, Marco Bortolami’s Benetton sat one point, and one place, above Munster in the URC table. The Teviso outfit had won eight of their nine competitive home games this term, six of them with bonus points. They had scored an average of 35 points in their last six games in all competitions.
That they were without a full 17 of their Italian call-ups didn’t prevent them from producing an occasionally electrifying attacking display but Graham Rowntree’s Munster, minus eight of their own internationals, ultimately had the edge in overall caliber as was expected.
A frantic start to the game more closely resembled this morning’s Sydney sevens action than typical 15-a-side fare.
Benetton were making hay through Munster’s 10-12 channel and were able to convert the chaos into a composed opening try. It was outside centre Marco Zanon who applied the finishing touch to a sweeping backline move which involved an excellent linebreak by his fellow midfielder Filippo Drago and a tidy offload assist by Jacob Umaga.
Out-half Umaga’s conversion from the left-hand touchline came back off the post.
Munster spurned a couple of their own early opportunities through inaccuracy both of the hand and at the breakdown, and they were made to pay as Benetton more than doubled their lead.
An innocuous-looking situation on the Italians’ own 10-metre line yielded a wonderful second try: Drago cut in-field and rode the tackle of Roman Salanoa before popping an offload into the sumptuous line of fullback Rhyno Smith. The South African steamed into the Munster half at full tilt before getting a diving pass away to right wing Ignacio Mendy, who took it to the house and sparked wild celebrations at the Stadio Comunale di Monigo.
Umaga, this time, nailed the afters and stretched the hosts out to a 12-0 lead inside 14 minutes.
Munster gained a foothold three minutes later and it was another score from way downtown. Joey Carbery swung a skip pass out to Calvin Nash, who chipped and collected down the right wing before sending Paddy Patterson under the posts. Carbery added the conversion to bring Munster back to within a try.
After Nash went off holding his ribs, Ben Healy made his entrance off the bench. He went in at out-half with Carbery shifting to fullback, Shane Daly moving from 15 onto the left wing, and Liam Coombes swapping sides.
A spell of Benetton pressure before the half-hour mark was relieved with a jackal-penalty turnover by Jack O’Sullivan, and it was Munster’s blindside who helped to nudge them in front.
John Hodnett, already impressive again, lowered the shoulder and found open field inside the Benetton half. Hodnett fed the oncoming O’Sullivan, who waltzed over to leave Carbery with the simplest of conversions to make it 14-12 to the visitors.
Munster built some phases in a bid to assume control towards the break but it was Benetton who still looked the more dangerous off limited ball. Their last attack of the first half yielded another line-break and three points from the boot of Umaga following a Munster infringement on the ground.
It was 15-14 to the hosts at the turnaround.
Munster reclaimed the lead almost immediately upon the resumption. A fluid move across the backline was kept alive by the soft hands of Carbery and Hodnett backed himself down the left flank, swatting off weak Benetton tackles to score. The Roscarberry man was later named Player of the Match, while Carbery made it 21-15 with the boot.
Moments later, however, Ben Healy was binned for deliberately knocking on a Jacob Umaga pass as Benetton once again took advantage of soft Munster defence. Umaga pointed to the sticks and narrowed the deficit to three points.
A seesaw battle was increasingly looking like it was going to come down on the side of Munster as Benetton’s defence — again, they lacked a plethora of internationals — began to wilt in the face of its higher-quality opposition.
Though still down to 14, the visitors sealed their bonus point and took their first two-score advantage of the day through Jean Kleyn. The Ireland international capped off a patient, forward-led raid of the Italians’ 22′, the highlight of which was a huge carry by Roman Salanoa which gave Munster a foothold just metres from the line. Carbery, again, did the rest, and it was 28-18.
Benetton simply refused to lie down, however, and continued to test Munster down the other end. Graham Rowntree’s side were briefly reduced to 13 when Diarmuid Barron was pinged for going off his feet as Munster scrambled to defend their own line on 57 minutes. Benetton opted for a scrum and expertly exposed Munster’s two-man disadvantage as Mendy crossed for his second in the right-hand corner.
Umaga’s conversion went wide, again leaving just a try between the sides at 28-23. Healy returned from the bold-boy step to take the restart.
Carbery remained on place kicks and after Carl Wegner strayed high in a relatively harmless tackle, he had the chance to stretch Munster’s lead back out to two scores. The Ireland international’s effort from just over 40 metres shaved the right-hand post and dropped wide, however, leaving Munster’s lead a perilous one as Barron’s return brought them back to full complement.
It was a poor miss, but Carbery more than made up for it moments later when he was integral to Munster’s clinching score. The stand-in fullback chased a kick 70 metres down the field like a man possessed, his pressure on Rhyno Smith allowing Shane Daly to smother the Benetton fullback who eventually coughed up possession.
Paddy Patterson tried the dart and was stopped inside the hosts’ 22′. Carbery, already standing in at fullback, then deputised at nine and teed up Healy, whose pinpoint crossfield kick from right to left sent Antoine Frisch over for Munster’s brilliant fifth try.
Carbery, his legs surely like jelly, pulled his touchline conversion wide but Munster were up 33-23 with only seven minutes remaining.
With Benetton hearts finally broken, the southern province went over again on 76 minutes — and it was Carbery who dotted down after a tidy, floated pass by Healy bypassed the tired Italian defenders.
His successful conversion made it 40-23.
The fat lady was singing but Benetton were cognisant that a four-try bonus point could yet prove crucial in the URC play-off race.
They got it through Mendy, who completed his hat-trick in some discomfort. Umaga’s successful conversion gave the scoreline a fairer reflection as Munster came away 40-30 victors and moved three points ahead of Benetton in the table heading into the Six Nations break.
Scorers for Benetton:
- Tries: Marco Zanon, Ignacio Mendy (3)
- Pens: Jacob Umaga (2/2)
- Cons: Jacob Umaga (3/4)
Scorers for Munster:
- Tries: Paddy Patterson, Jack O’Sullivan, John Hodnett, Jean Kleyn, Antoine Frisch, Joey Carbery
- Pens: Joey Carbery (0/1)
- Cons: Joey Carbery (5/6)
Benetton: Rhyno Smith; Ignacio Mendy, Marco Zanon, Filippo Drago, Mattia Bellini; Jacob Umaga, Dewaldt Duvenage (Captain); Nahuel Tetaz, Siua Maile, Tiziano Pasquali; Marco Lazzaroni, Riccardo Favretto; Giovanni Pettinelli, Alessandro Izekor, Henry Stowers.
Replacements: Bautista Bernasconi, Thomas Gallo, Filippo Alongi, Nicola Piantella, Carl Wegner, Abraham Steyn, Manfredi Albanese, Marcus Watson.
Munster: Shane Daly; Calvin Nash, Antoine Frisch, Malakai Fekitoa, Liam Coombes; Joey Carbery, Paddy Patterson; Josh Wycherley, Niall Scannell (Captain), Roman Salanoa; Jean Kleyn, Fineen Wycherley; Jack O’Sullivan, John Hodnett, Alex Kendellen.
Replacements: Diarmuid Barron, Mark Donnelly, Stephen Archer, Cian Hurley, Ruadhan Quinn, Neil Cronin, Ben Healy, Rory Scannell.
Match officials: Referee: Ben Blain, AR1: Federico Vedovelli, AR2: Franco Rosella, TMO: Sam Grove-White.
Get instant updates on your province on The42 app. With Laya Healthcare, official health and wellbeing partner to Leinster, Munster and Connacht Rugby.
A broad palette of scores… I knew at this stage it was a casey article. Nice work.
@Jim Demps: yeah four of them (+ seven).
Carbery for Ireland!!!
@C McSporty: haha
@C McSporty: at 15
Didn’t see the game but even given that Benetton are a very tough team at home, missing 17 internationals and this should have been a Munster walk over (even missing 8 themselves) Did Munster play below expectations? Or have Benneton managed to find a lot more depth in their squad? Or is Marco Bortolami turning them into a well drilled side even missing so many players? If Benetton carry on like this it can only be good for the league.
@Kingshu: BT are a totally different animal this year as is Italian rugby in general. Worth a punt to turn over France. Thought munster played themselves into the game and scored some decent tries ….harsh yellow and ball was well fwd for their last try …which could be all important. All played generally well…hodnett was immense …kleyn again….v unlucky not to be in 6N squad but good for munster
@Kingshu: Have a bit more depth just not quite enough yet. They were 12-0 up before Munster got into their stride. Last try they for a bonus point looked dodgy (forward pass).
3 weeks to the next full weekend of URC games. Those who’ve lots of game/minutes will be happy with some downtime.
@TL55: Thats good, I dont think they will ever have enough depth to be competitive durning international windows, even Leinster with their amazing squad depth, would struggle losing 17 players never mind a team with far fewer resources like Benetton. They have been good last few seasons but really look to be focusing on home games this year, and great that they are competitive in the international window. Looks like they have a lot more Italian players than they used to, and have picked up a number of Argentines from Jaguares, so that prob helps in the international windows.
Apparently there’s a new law I’ve only just seen or heard about for the first time.
If the ball misses your hands are you are attempting an intercept and it goes off your shoulder, it’s deemed a deliberate knock on……
@Criiochúr Daniel Daithí O’Chathail: the replays were poor enough I thought but it definitely looked like the ball went clean through his hands and actually hit his chin/shoulder.
@James: He even gesticulated to his shoulder after he went off. He accepted the outcome but only because he knew he wouldn’t change the referee’s mind. It was an abysmal decision and I never like to talk negatively about the referee, but this instance forced that because I was scratching my head after that.
@Criiochúr Daniel Daithí O’Chathail: the last try for benetton was a head scratcher as well, ref just outright refused to get the tmo to look at it, if he was so adamant it was flat ( it was definitely not flat) what harm in asking for a look game was over anyway just as well it wasn’t a tight match even at that it handed them a bonus point
@Michael McGrath: he isn’t a great referee. May have been making up for other decisions that went munsters way.
@James: did it definitely go forward too? I wasn’t at all sure. Anyway calls like that are the cost of spending up the game
I hope we never see that ref again, he seemed determined to have an effect on the game, that and the ability of TV providers to supply whatever footage suits them, was that last pass forward, sure looked it but who knows, Treviso claim a point and remain above us in the table. Great game from Hodentt and after a shaky missed tackle start from KoS he came good, would have him at 8 with Kendellen at 6, also a perfect opportunity for Campbell to come into the fold, dunno where he’s gone after a series of solid performances. Malakey is looking strong, Salanoa is tipping along well too, hop he can stay injury free. Patterson seems to just bag tries and play in winning teams, sorta sad to see Joey grubber kicks wide. that missed penalty was pretty shoddy, again looks better with a few extra seconds in front of him. Decent result on the road tho.
@thesaltyurchin: wrong on the table. Its now been updated.
@thesaltyurchin: missed penalty was unlucky, 40 metres out in front of posts with no angle to play with. All kickers will tell you these are the hardest to make because you’re expected to nail them.
@Mark Sheehan:
Rubbish. No excuse for that from pro
@thesaltyurchin: treviso are below us now have a look at the updated table
…given the new rule on time-bound conversions , why did Patterson throw ball away after his score?
@Michael Murray: Dunno, but someone was saying when he was on the team at UCD they were 90% more likely to win as opposed to 40% when not. A mad stat that got much beer-spilling scrutiny but he’s literally scoring in every game he plays. Gonna be hard to not start him soon enough.
Carbery misses most important kicks. Could have counted today. Don’t give me silly stats that say 80 plus Per cent success. All are important but especially ones from near touchline or as in case today 40 m out. O’Gara , Sexton and any good kicker gets them. That’s the difference
@Maurice Dinan: look at you arguing with stats as if you know better then them. Carbery had a 71% success rate with the boot yesterday. Love to know how kicks from the touch line are more important then then the kicks in front of the sticks? I’ve seen sexton miss many straight forward kick down through the years. As for o’gara between 2002 and 2011 as per a 42 article he had a kick success rate of 72%. You whinging about carbery only getting 71% yesterday. Have a word with yourself lad.
@whoowhat?:
My point was that Carbery regularly misses important kicks . The one straight in front of posts yesterday could have come back to haunt. I watch every single game by the way
@Maurice Dinan: He doesn’t tho, he has a very good kick %. Probably the most high pressure game he’s been in was against France last year with him starting, he nailed all his kicks that day.
I’ve seen sexton who is a very good kicker miss from just out side the 22 more then once and they were far off centre of the posts in games for ireland.
Kickers miss, no kicker has a perfect record.
A good result for Munster…. But they have a lot to do to achieve a top 6 finish…. Munster will have to win all the remaining games which include 2 trips to SA for the URC alone and during that month April they’ll play Sharks twice onces for league and the HC. Sharks are 4 points behind Munster at 8th place with 2 games in hand. These guys are the biggest treat to stop Munster in both comptetions.