PETER O’MAHONY’S LAST-gasp turnover penalty against Glasgow Warriors back in October was always likely to be important and it might yet prove to be the difference between the teams in their race to top Conference A of the Guinness Pro14.
Of course, it was Rory Scannell’s remarkable long-range kick at goal that earned Munster a dramatic 25-24 victory at Thomond Park, but the nature of how Johann van Graan’s side won the penalty was memorable.
Glasgow fed the ball into a scrum in the 79th minute and O’Mahony immediately settled into something of a sweeper role behind Munster’s defensive line, as highlighted below.
Aware that Glasgow would attempt to run the clock down with narrow carries off their rucks, O’Mahony dropped just behind the defence in search of a turnover to save the game for Munster.
With the defenders in front of him bringing linespeed and attempting to chop Glasgow’s ball-carriers to the ground, O’Mahony surged up for his first sniff at a turnover with 78:46 on the clock.
With Glasgow’s support in strong positions, O’Mahony didn’t get into a jackal position but he continued to hover behind the frontline defence searching for an opening.
Below, we see O’Mahony in movement from left to right, beginning to set up behind the next Glasgow carry.
O’Mahony’s positioning means he obviously won’t be involved in the tackle itself – which he wants to stay detached from – but is in range to rush in and jackal as the tackle is completed.
Again, he attempts to do so here and reaches over at the ball this time.
As we can see above, O’Mahony is not on his feet competing for the ball and referee Dan Jones warns him off.
Throughout this passage, Munster are appealing to the referee that Glasgow are ‘sealing off’ the breakdowns, going off their feet in a bid to prevent the Irish province from competing for a turnover, but their complaints fall on deaf ears.
O’Mahony is patient and on his third attempt to attack the ball, he comes up trumps.
Below, we can see him sweeping across into position behind the frontline defence and this time he speaks to CJ Stander before the Glasgow carry.
We don’t know exactly what O’Mahony is saying to Stander here but what follows allows us to make a good guess.
O’Mahony encourages Stander to tackle the first supporting Glasgow player in this instance, rather than the ball-carrier himself.
Glasgow’s Callum Gibbins [7 above] is in position to ‘latch’ onto ball-carrier Kevin Bryce here, potentially giving him additional power into contact but, more crucially on this occasion, leaving him in a position to ensure Munster cannot compete for a turnover.
Click here if you cannot view the clip above
As we see above and below, however, Stander slips beyond Bryce and instead tackles Gibbins.
Nobody actually tackles Bryce but he falls to ground anyway, Glasgow having been content simply to run down the clock without attempting to make progress upfield with their carries.
With Stander now taking up the space beyond the ball [white below] and impeding the arriving Glasgow players, O’Mahony sweeps up from behind Stander to jackal [yellow].
With Bryce suddenly isolated, O’Mahony has just enough time to get over the ball before the Glasgow support arrives.
JJ Hanrahan and Billy Holland immediately move to anchor O’Mahony into place, attempting to give him stability as he jackals [white below].
Glasgow make an impact on O’Mahony and it’s arguable whether he is on his feet as he competes here.
As we can see below, his left hand goes onto the ground before he’s on the ball, ensuring he doesn’t flop straight to deck.
However, referee Jones’ view is impeded by the Glasgow players arriving to the breakdown and he awards a penalty to Munster.
“You [Glasgow] are straight down and he [O'Mahony] is on his feet,” says Jones.
After O’Mahony receives treatment from Munster’s medical team, Scannell steps up to hammer over the winning three points and spark raucous celebrations at Thomond Park.
Munster weren’t the first team to have deployed this tactic and they certainly weren’t the last.
We saw a similar example in a sensational game of Super Rugby last weekend, with the Highlanders manufacturing a last-gasp chance to grab victory from the Hurricanes.
Leading 31-28, the Hurricanes were attempting to run down the clock in the 80th minute, with Highlanders openside James Lentjes [white below] taking up the same role as O’Mahony.
Lantjes is denied an opening at this first ruck, as the Hurricanes get support players into position to recycle.
Undeterred, Lantjes sweeps across to his right as the Hurricanes line up a carry to that side.
Click here if you cannot view the clip above
As we can see above, his team-mate Elliot Dixon [in the 20 shirt] is thinking along similar lines.
Dixon [white below] prompts Shannon Frizzell [6] to step into his position in the frontline defence and joins Lentjes [yellow] in lining up just behind it.
Frizzell takes on the Stander role for the Highlanders here.
As we can see below, Frizzell [blue] targets Xavier Numia, who is providing the closest support to ball-carrier Vaea Fifita.
There is a genuine tackle on Fifita here and it’s crucial as Thomas Franklin [red] chops in low and takes out Fifita’s legs.
Franklin also swings into Numia’s legs, further muddying his access into the breakdown and buying time for Dixon and Lentjes.
Dixon and Lentjes sweep in from behind to jackal at almost exactly the same moment.
As we can see below, Ardie Savea is the Hurricanes player arriving from Fifita’s outside shoulder and he drives in to remove Dixon [white].
But with Numia unable to get a shot onto Lentjes, that simply leaves the Highlanders openside locked onto the ball.
As indicated below, Dan Lienert-Brown [green] reacts by moving to anchor Lentjes into position over the ball.
Referee Glen Jackson already has his whistle raised to his mouth and, with 79:22 on the clock, awards the penalty in the Highlanders’ favour
Unfortunately for the Dunedin-based outfit, they couldn’t squeeze out a win from the ensuing three minutes of pressure from five-metre lineouts.
Ulster, who had to defend through 40 phases of Leinster possession at the end of their recent Champions Cup quarter-final, had Jordi Murphy occupying this role on three occasions during that passage.
However, Leinster guarded their possession greedily and Murphy didn’t get a genuine glimpse at the ball.
We saw Leinster utilise the tactic just last month away to Edinburgh in the Pro14 but, interestingly, it didn’t come with the Scots attempting to run down the clock.
Instead, Leinster pounced as Edinburgh built towards an intended exiting kick.
Click here if you cannot view the clip above
Max Deegan [white below] sweeps in behind the frontline defenders from outside.
With Deegan hovering in behind, Joe Tomane [yellow below] is the chop tackler for Leinster, going in low on ball-carrier Bill Mata’s legs.
Meanwhile, Mick Kearney [red] engages nearest support player Ross Ford, leaning into him above the tackle.
In attempting to roll away from his tackle, Tomane also proves an important obstacle for the next arriving Edinburgh player.
As we can see below, Tomane [yellow] takes out Ben Toolis’ legs as he’s attempting to engage into the breakdown.
Deegan, having swept up from behind the tackle, has already jackaled over the ball and with his team-mates causing havoc in front of him, he’s soon awarded the turnover penalty by referee Ben Whitehouse.
This Leinster situation is similar to the previous two turnovers in that they can confidently predict the opposition will make a short carry close into the ruck.
It’s also similar in that the Edinburgh call-carrier is not centrally focused on making a positive carry.
That Leinster used this simple tactic relatively early in the game – rather than with the final seconds ticking away – was somewhat unique.
While overuse would, of course, lead to teams simply passing out the back to expose a frontline defence shorn of at least one body, it will be intriguing to note if and how teams work similar situations in the future.
Subscribe to our new podcast, The42 Rugby Weekly, here:
Superb piece Murray. For me there isn’t a smarter back rower in world rugby at the moment. His ability to read a game and to make game changing involvements is second to none. O mahony May not be the most gifted with ball in hand but he’s up there with pocock and hooper in terms of what he can do defensively and he’s the best defensive lineout operator in world rugby.
In terms of that passage of play and the sweeper role id be surprised if it wasn’t JP Ferreiras input that set that up. I’m sure I’ve seen that previously with the lions and kriel/ kwagga Smith/ warren whitely.
This is the point I have made about 50 times on here, when self-proclaimed experts have used O’ Mahony’s low tackling stats to argue that he has had a poor game. It seemed obvious to me that he is instructed to sweep, in order to produce turnovers.
Interesting read, especially in the wake of the grief he was getting online about his tackling stats, or lack thereof, against Wales. I posited at the time that it may have been a deliberate tactic to have him loiter in behind the defensive line to attack opposition rucks. I’d love to know if Ireland were employing a similar tactic that day and that’s why his tackle numbers were so low.
@Eddie Hekenui: ..yeah, good case for asking question in light of this piece.
@Eddie Hekenui: his tackle numbers are low because he is often used outside the winger in attack and as a poacher without the ball so the primary defensive work is done by the players who take up positions infield
@Eddie Hekenui: in fairness you did say that.
The Munster turnover example has two clear penalties, first when POM is off his feet deliberately slowing down the ball and at the turn over CJ tackles a man without the ball and blocks the support runners.
@Chris Mc: I’d say just the one penalty for POM putting his arm on the ground. There’s nothing in what Stander did. He made a valid attempt to tackle the ball carrier.
@Chris Mc: neither is a penalty. First contact is with the ball carrier who he slipped off as is clear in the still below the gif, and he didn’t block anyone. As the tackler he’s perfectly entitled to be there once he moves away quickly, which he does. It’s clever play.
@Eddie Hekenui: you’re right but it’s nearly impossible to call because hanrahan and Holland anchor in so quickly.
@Jim Demps: Yeah that is very unlikely to be called in a match unless referees get the benefit of multiple angles and screenshots
@Eddie Hekenui: he clearly takes out the support player and lands in the area the other support players are coming from. A hint of no arms clear out too.
@Chris Mc: But he does so after attempting to tackle the ball carrier and the support player is latched onto the carrier so he can’t really attempt a tackle and avoid him. Absolutely nothing in it. And if you were to penalise lads who land in the area the support players are coming from you’d be penalising every player who missed a tackle unless players suddenly gain the ability to teleport.
@Chris Mc: I would argue Beirne’s head straight into the other players head in the ruck could be one also, although I am not sure if it is even illegal…..
It looks dangerous to me.
@Chris Mc:
Chris you must get tired whenever you say something that is anyway negative to them that you get triple barrelled by the rest of them. I admire you tenacious in those situation.
@Martin Quinn: Do you ever get tired of replying to all my posts and never talking about rugby?
@Eddie Hekenui:
Look at the posts, where have I responded to you, it was to Chris:: You see what you want and again I have not posted to you .I have no idea what you are getting at . I have responded on this article regarding to POM turnover :can you read it first before you attack me.
Think he was lucky with the ref not being able to see his feet (one was off the ground) But that shows how good he is and his experience on dealing with refs:
Great man to have playing for Ireland . The best thing about that was the timing of it (to win the game with getting the kick) Great Head !!!!
Leinster have been doing this all season
@Danger:
Are you sure ?? Do Ulster do it ?? Do Connacht do it ?? You seem sure that Leinster do it .. is that right (your not bias are you ??)