Shifting unwanted, underperforming players will always be somewhat of a problem for big clubs, but it has been a glaring issue for Man United in particular of late.
Phil Jones finally left the club in the off-season after 12 years, having made a total of six Premier League appearances in the last four campaigns.
The defender became a symbol of the perils of rewarding players with long contracts given how inactive he has been for years — not once in his 12 campaigns did he make 30+ appearances and there were only four seasons in which he exceeded the 20-game barrier.
The 31-year-old ex-England international is now a free agent, yet there are still many others at United who badly need a fresh start.
The likes of Eric Bailly, Harry Maguire, Scott McTominay, Donny van de Beek, Brandon Williams and Dean Henderson are clearly surplus to requirements.
Maguire is the most high-profile of this out-of-favour contingent, given that he joined the club for a reported fee of €93 million in the summer of 2019.
The England international is only 30 — the prime age for a defender — and so United potentially could still recoup a considerable portion of the money spent on him.
However, with just a week to go before the transfer window closes (at 11pm on 1 September), it appears increasingly unlikely that the former Leicester star will leave.
Man United recently accepted a €35 million offer for Maguire from West Ham, only for the defender to fail to agree personal terms.
A €40 million deal for Nice defender Jean-Clair Todibo is understood to be close and is expected to be agreed upon even if Maguire stays put.
Yet if United are to invest further before the window closes, they will surely need to find a way to offload some of their stars for a decent sum.
Martial, Van de Beek and McTominay are others that have been regularly linked with the exit door of late.
2. The imbalanced midfield
Casemiro has had a disappointing start to the season. Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
It’s obvious from their first two games that Man United’s midfield is a problem.
Both Tottenham and Wolves cut through it far too easily in the opening Premier League fixtures.
The Red Devils had just 44% possession against Spurs and were lucky to escape with three points in their opening fixture, as Wolves were denied a clear penalty in the dying moments and wasted several good chances.
In both matches, they started with an attack-minded midfield trio of Casemiro, Mason Mount and Bruno Fernandes, looking far too open as a result.
After a largely positive first season at Old Trafford, Casemiro has been poor in the opening two games amid fears age could be catching up with the Brazilian at 31.
Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has been particularly critical, labelling him a “panic buy” in his Telegraph column last week.
At the very least, the ex-Real Madrid man needs help with a more defensively inclined player operating alongside him.
McTominay was introduced in the 88th minute against Wolves and was an unused sub at Spurs, suggesting that for all his defensive prowess, Ten Hag is reluctant to rely on the Scottish international this season ostensibly due to his technical limitations.
However, there is a clear lack of balance in the midfield and if they aren’t going to use McTominay, they will surely need an upgrade rather than solely availing of the options at their disposal.
Sofyan Amrabat, the 27-year-old Fiorentina midfielder and one of the standout players for a Morocco side that finished fourth at last year’s World Cup, would appear to be the ideal candidate.
However, whether the Red Devils can secure a deal looks doubtful.
The player was left out of the first leg of Fiorentina’s Europa Conference League play-off tie on Thursday evening, suggesting a move could be imminent.
But Liverpool have also been strongly linked with Amrabat, and Anfield looks the more attractive option from a footballing perspective currently.
However, Amrabat knows Ten Hag well, having come through under him at Utrecht, while the fact that Jurgen Klopp’s men have already recruited Alexis Mac Allister, Dominik Szoboszlai and Wataru Endo to their midfield indicates he has a better chance of thriving amid the more thin options at Old Trafford.
Advertisement
3. The lack of depth in attack
Anthony Martial has struggled for consistency during his time at Man United. Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
When Man United badly needed a goal in the 85th minute against Spurs, the sight of Anthony Martial emerging from the bench will have been far from reassuring for fans.
The situation prompted a characteristically caustic response from club legend Roy Keane.
“They are bringing on the likes of (Anthony) Martial, you might as well bring on Frank Stapleton and Norman Whiteside,” the Irishman quipped. “Martial is not going to get you out of trouble.”
Others share Keane’s frustration with the inconsistent French forward.
The 27-year-old is in his ninth season at Old Trafford, having joined for €42 million in 2015 — a then-record transfer fee for a teenager.
Yet nearly 10 years on, Martial has rarely looked like establishing himself as a clinical goalscorer.
He has only reached double figures in three of his seasons at the club and registered an underwhelming tally of six goals in 21 Premier League appearances last season.
Yet the Red Devils keep having to rely on him owing to a lack of alternative options.
Marcus Rashford, meanwhile, has struggled to make an impact having been asked to play as the main striker in the club’s opening two Premier League games.
The England international is generally at his best in a wider attacking role and has looked ineffectual in this less familiar position.
The Red Devils have of course splashed out €75 million to prise Danish international Rasmus Højlund from Atalanta, joining the club on a five-year deal.
Unfortunately, an injury has delayed Højlund’s debut, though he is expected to be available for selection against Nottingham Forest this weekend.
Nonetheless, it is a big ask for a 20-year-old to lead the line at one of the world’s most high-profile clubs.
Moreover, while he clearly has the potential to become a top-class striker, Højlund is not there yet.
He registered nine goals from 32 appearances in Serie A last season, which indicates he is hardly prolific enough to be United’s main man at present.
4. Supporter discontentment
Protesters outside Manchester United football ground megastore force closure on day the club unveil their new home shirt. Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
It is now more than 10 years on from Alex Ferguson’s retirement and since then, Man United have patently lacked leadership off the field.
In that period, a series of poor decisions at boardroom level have meant that the club have gone from being the dominant side in England to perennial underachievers who frequently miss out on a top-four finish.
The latest example of this significant problem was the appalling manner in which they handled the Mason Greenwood saga.
While the club eventually came to the right decision in announcing that the striker would not play for them again, it took a considerable backlash, with staff considering either resigning or going on strike, for the call to be made.
Everything else surrounding the decision epitomised the lack of conviction behind the scenes that has hampered the club for a decade.
As highlighted thanks to some excellent reporting by The Athletic’s Adam Crafton, there was the cynical manner in which United were planning to re-integrate Greenwood, down to small details such as how he should be photographed in training, compiling a list of individuals that were expected to be “hostile” to the star’s return and going so far as CEO Richard Arnold filming a now-aborted video explaining the reasons behind the player’s controversial return.
Even the official statement released this week by United was another missed opportunity to emerge from this sorry saga with some credit.
It erroneously stated Greenwood had been “cleared of all charges,” thereby completely undermining every other contentious claim they made in relation to the marginalised forward.
The dithering over Greenwood is just one of a number of ways the club have managed to alienate a considerable portion of their fanbase.
The circus over the ownership is another stark example.
Since the Glazers executed a $1.5 billion leveraged buyout of the club in 2005, they have become increasingly unpopular.
The anger reached its zenith in May 2021 when around 200 fans broke into Old Trafford, injuring two police officers in the process and forcing the postponement of their Premier League match with Liverpool.
The club’s subsequent re-signing of Cristiano Ronaldo appeared to temporarily quell the anger while the progress made on the pitch under Ten Hag last season also seemed to alleviate some of the prevailing acrimony.
Most frustrating of all, though, is the current takeover predicament.
As far back as last November, the Glazers announced they were willing to sell the club, with Sheik Jassim bin Hamad Al Thani of Qatar or British tycoon Sir Jim Ratcliffe emerging as the two most viable buyers.
But no resolution has been reached amid lengthy negotiations.
A report in The Sun this week suggested Sheikh Jassim’s £6 billion offer for the club had been accepted, and that the takeover would be completed by mid-October.
However, until an official announcement is made, Man United fans would be forgiven for remaining sceptical after years of mismanagement and broken promises from those behind the scenes.
5. Managing the European commitments
Marcus Rashford has cut a frustrated figure already this season. Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
What constitutes a good season for United this year is not an easy question to answer.
Based on the early evidence, mounting a serious Premier League title challenge looks beyond them.
At the very least, fans will want to see evidence of progress and signs that the Erik ten Hag project is going in the right direction.
Last season was certainly a substantial step forward given the sorry state the Dutch coach found the club in when he took over.
A League Cup triumph was the highlight, while a third-place finish in the top flight and runners-up medals in the FA Cup were encouraging signs.
Building on this progress, however, will be an even greater challenge.
The prospect of reducing the 14-point gap that separated City and United last season will be what matters most to fans, with Pep Guardiola’s treble winners again looking like the team to beat having convincingly won their opening two games.
And perhaps the biggest inconvenience for United will be navigating Champions League football alongside their domestic commitments.
Of course, they competed in the Europa League last season, but that is a competition where most Premier League teams often tend to rest their best players in the early stages.
By contrast, fans will demand that Ten Hag regularly selects close to his strongest XI in Europe’s premier club competition, which they haven’t won since 2008.
And competing in the Champions League can be a burden to teams who don’t possess as much squad depth as a club of the calibre of Man City.
The Etihad outfit aside, the three English clubs who competed in the Champions League last season finished fifth, eighth and 12th in the top flight.
Granted, the season was further complicated by the World Cup-enforced mid-season break, leading to its unprecedented length as well as some rather freakish results.
However, the Red Devils must avoid becoming overwhelmed by the schedule, like so many teams before them.
And that is why the next few days could be crucial. The number of players Ten Hag brings in and sells will likely determine whether they are genuinely capable of competing on several fronts.
Ten Hag’s record in the transfer market has been mixed so far — Casemiro, Lisandro Martinez and Christian Eriksen all made a positive impression last season, though the likes of Antony, Tyrell Malacia, Marcel Sabitzer and Wout Weghorst failed to fully convince, with the club opting not to retain the latter two players after their loan deals expired.
United will therefore surely need at least one or two game-changing signings in the coming days to avoid another long, hard campaign where they are once more eclipsed by their improving rivals.
Upcoming Premier League fixtures (kick-off 3pm unless stated otherwise)
Friday
Chelsea v Luton (20.00)
Saturday
Bournemouth v Tottenham (12.30)
Arsenal v Fulham
Brentford v Crystal Palace
Everton v Wolves
Man United v Nottingham Forest
Brighton v West Ham (17.30)
Sunday
Burnley v Aston Villa (14.00)
Sheffield United v Man City (14.00)
Newcastle v Liverpool (16.30)
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic.
Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy
here
before taking part.
5 problems Erik ten Hag needs to solve
1. Harry Maguire and other out-of-favour stars
Shifting unwanted, underperforming players will always be somewhat of a problem for big clubs, but it has been a glaring issue for Man United in particular of late.
Phil Jones finally left the club in the off-season after 12 years, having made a total of six Premier League appearances in the last four campaigns.
The defender became a symbol of the perils of rewarding players with long contracts given how inactive he has been for years — not once in his 12 campaigns did he make 30+ appearances and there were only four seasons in which he exceeded the 20-game barrier.
The 31-year-old ex-England international is now a free agent, yet there are still many others at United who badly need a fresh start.
The likes of Eric Bailly, Harry Maguire, Scott McTominay, Donny van de Beek, Brandon Williams and Dean Henderson are clearly surplus to requirements.
Maguire is the most high-profile of this out-of-favour contingent, given that he joined the club for a reported fee of €93 million in the summer of 2019.
The England international is only 30 — the prime age for a defender — and so United potentially could still recoup a considerable portion of the money spent on him.
However, with just a week to go before the transfer window closes (at 11pm on 1 September), it appears increasingly unlikely that the former Leicester star will leave.
Man United recently accepted a €35 million offer for Maguire from West Ham, only for the defender to fail to agree personal terms.
A €40 million deal for Nice defender Jean-Clair Todibo is understood to be close and is expected to be agreed upon even if Maguire stays put.
Yet if United are to invest further before the window closes, they will surely need to find a way to offload some of their stars for a decent sum.
Martial, Van de Beek and McTominay are others that have been regularly linked with the exit door of late.
2. The imbalanced midfield
It’s obvious from their first two games that Man United’s midfield is a problem.
Both Tottenham and Wolves cut through it far too easily in the opening Premier League fixtures.
The Red Devils had just 44% possession against Spurs and were lucky to escape with three points in their opening fixture, as Wolves were denied a clear penalty in the dying moments and wasted several good chances.
In both matches, they started with an attack-minded midfield trio of Casemiro, Mason Mount and Bruno Fernandes, looking far too open as a result.
After a largely positive first season at Old Trafford, Casemiro has been poor in the opening two games amid fears age could be catching up with the Brazilian at 31.
Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has been particularly critical, labelling him a “panic buy” in his Telegraph column last week.
At the very least, the ex-Real Madrid man needs help with a more defensively inclined player operating alongside him.
McTominay was introduced in the 88th minute against Wolves and was an unused sub at Spurs, suggesting that for all his defensive prowess, Ten Hag is reluctant to rely on the Scottish international this season ostensibly due to his technical limitations.
However, there is a clear lack of balance in the midfield and if they aren’t going to use McTominay, they will surely need an upgrade rather than solely availing of the options at their disposal.
Sofyan Amrabat, the 27-year-old Fiorentina midfielder and one of the standout players for a Morocco side that finished fourth at last year’s World Cup, would appear to be the ideal candidate.
However, whether the Red Devils can secure a deal looks doubtful.
The player was left out of the first leg of Fiorentina’s Europa Conference League play-off tie on Thursday evening, suggesting a move could be imminent.
But Liverpool have also been strongly linked with Amrabat, and Anfield looks the more attractive option from a footballing perspective currently.
However, Amrabat knows Ten Hag well, having come through under him at Utrecht, while the fact that Jurgen Klopp’s men have already recruited Alexis Mac Allister, Dominik Szoboszlai and Wataru Endo to their midfield indicates he has a better chance of thriving amid the more thin options at Old Trafford.
3. The lack of depth in attack
When Man United badly needed a goal in the 85th minute against Spurs, the sight of Anthony Martial emerging from the bench will have been far from reassuring for fans.
The situation prompted a characteristically caustic response from club legend Roy Keane.
“They are bringing on the likes of (Anthony) Martial, you might as well bring on Frank Stapleton and Norman Whiteside,” the Irishman quipped. “Martial is not going to get you out of trouble.”
Others share Keane’s frustration with the inconsistent French forward.
The 27-year-old is in his ninth season at Old Trafford, having joined for €42 million in 2015 — a then-record transfer fee for a teenager.
Yet nearly 10 years on, Martial has rarely looked like establishing himself as a clinical goalscorer.
He has only reached double figures in three of his seasons at the club and registered an underwhelming tally of six goals in 21 Premier League appearances last season.
Yet the Red Devils keep having to rely on him owing to a lack of alternative options.
Marcus Rashford, meanwhile, has struggled to make an impact having been asked to play as the main striker in the club’s opening two Premier League games.
The England international is generally at his best in a wider attacking role and has looked ineffectual in this less familiar position.
The Red Devils have of course splashed out €75 million to prise Danish international Rasmus Højlund from Atalanta, joining the club on a five-year deal.
Unfortunately, an injury has delayed Højlund’s debut, though he is expected to be available for selection against Nottingham Forest this weekend.
Nonetheless, it is a big ask for a 20-year-old to lead the line at one of the world’s most high-profile clubs.
Moreover, while he clearly has the potential to become a top-class striker, Højlund is not there yet.
He registered nine goals from 32 appearances in Serie A last season, which indicates he is hardly prolific enough to be United’s main man at present.
4. Supporter discontentment
It is now more than 10 years on from Alex Ferguson’s retirement and since then, Man United have patently lacked leadership off the field.
In that period, a series of poor decisions at boardroom level have meant that the club have gone from being the dominant side in England to perennial underachievers who frequently miss out on a top-four finish.
The latest example of this significant problem was the appalling manner in which they handled the Mason Greenwood saga.
While the club eventually came to the right decision in announcing that the striker would not play for them again, it took a considerable backlash, with staff considering either resigning or going on strike, for the call to be made.
Everything else surrounding the decision epitomised the lack of conviction behind the scenes that has hampered the club for a decade.
As highlighted thanks to some excellent reporting by The Athletic’s Adam Crafton, there was the cynical manner in which United were planning to re-integrate Greenwood, down to small details such as how he should be photographed in training, compiling a list of individuals that were expected to be “hostile” to the star’s return and going so far as CEO Richard Arnold filming a now-aborted video explaining the reasons behind the player’s controversial return.
Even the official statement released this week by United was another missed opportunity to emerge from this sorry saga with some credit.
It erroneously stated Greenwood had been “cleared of all charges,” thereby completely undermining every other contentious claim they made in relation to the marginalised forward.
The dithering over Greenwood is just one of a number of ways the club have managed to alienate a considerable portion of their fanbase.
The circus over the ownership is another stark example.
Since the Glazers executed a $1.5 billion leveraged buyout of the club in 2005, they have become increasingly unpopular.
The anger reached its zenith in May 2021 when around 200 fans broke into Old Trafford, injuring two police officers in the process and forcing the postponement of their Premier League match with Liverpool.
The club’s subsequent re-signing of Cristiano Ronaldo appeared to temporarily quell the anger while the progress made on the pitch under Ten Hag last season also seemed to alleviate some of the prevailing acrimony.
However, the Greenwood saga and the disappointing start to the season, have helped bring the issue back to the fore and there have been fresh protests this month.
Most frustrating of all, though, is the current takeover predicament.
As far back as last November, the Glazers announced they were willing to sell the club, with Sheik Jassim bin Hamad Al Thani of Qatar or British tycoon Sir Jim Ratcliffe emerging as the two most viable buyers.
But no resolution has been reached amid lengthy negotiations.
A report in The Sun this week suggested Sheikh Jassim’s £6 billion offer for the club had been accepted, and that the takeover would be completed by mid-October.
However, until an official announcement is made, Man United fans would be forgiven for remaining sceptical after years of mismanagement and broken promises from those behind the scenes.
5. Managing the European commitments
What constitutes a good season for United this year is not an easy question to answer.
Based on the early evidence, mounting a serious Premier League title challenge looks beyond them.
At the very least, fans will want to see evidence of progress and signs that the Erik ten Hag project is going in the right direction.
Last season was certainly a substantial step forward given the sorry state the Dutch coach found the club in when he took over.
A League Cup triumph was the highlight, while a third-place finish in the top flight and runners-up medals in the FA Cup were encouraging signs.
Building on this progress, however, will be an even greater challenge.
The prospect of reducing the 14-point gap that separated City and United last season will be what matters most to fans, with Pep Guardiola’s treble winners again looking like the team to beat having convincingly won their opening two games.
And perhaps the biggest inconvenience for United will be navigating Champions League football alongside their domestic commitments.
Of course, they competed in the Europa League last season, but that is a competition where most Premier League teams often tend to rest their best players in the early stages.
By contrast, fans will demand that Ten Hag regularly selects close to his strongest XI in Europe’s premier club competition, which they haven’t won since 2008.
And competing in the Champions League can be a burden to teams who don’t possess as much squad depth as a club of the calibre of Man City.
The Etihad outfit aside, the three English clubs who competed in the Champions League last season finished fifth, eighth and 12th in the top flight.
Granted, the season was further complicated by the World Cup-enforced mid-season break, leading to its unprecedented length as well as some rather freakish results.
However, the Red Devils must avoid becoming overwhelmed by the schedule, like so many teams before them.
And that is why the next few days could be crucial. The number of players Ten Hag brings in and sells will likely determine whether they are genuinely capable of competing on several fronts.
Ten Hag’s record in the transfer market has been mixed so far — Casemiro, Lisandro Martinez and Christian Eriksen all made a positive impression last season, though the likes of Antony, Tyrell Malacia, Marcel Sabitzer and Wout Weghorst failed to fully convince, with the club opting not to retain the latter two players after their loan deals expired.
United will therefore surely need at least one or two game-changing signings in the coming days to avoid another long, hard campaign where they are once more eclipsed by their improving rivals.
Upcoming Premier League fixtures (kick-off 3pm unless stated otherwise)
Friday
Chelsea v Luton (20.00)
Saturday
Bournemouth v Tottenham (12.30)
Arsenal v Fulham
Brentford v Crystal Palace
Everton v Wolves
Man United v Nottingham Forest
Brighton v West Ham (17.30)
Sunday
Burnley v Aston Villa (14.00)
Sheffield United v Man City (14.00)
Newcastle v Liverpool (16.30)
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
EPL Erik ten Hag Premier League talking point Manchester United Tottenham Hotspur