Overview
TIPPERARY WERE CERTAINLY a bit off the pace for chunks of yesterday’s semi-final against Galway.
Perhaps the five-week lay-off contributed to some of Tipp’s rustiness but Galway were excellent in many respects.
These were two very evenly-matched teams, as the scoreline would suggest, and there was virtually nothing in the game but Tipp had the bit of luck as Galway’s David Collins spilled the ball out over the line late on, and the Tribesmen lost Joe Canning and Adrian Tuohy to injury.
If that ball had gone down the field, there was every chance that the match was going to finish in a draw but Tipp displayed resilience and a stubborn streak to hold out in a game that, in recent times, they might well have lost.
I think Tipp will be absolutely delighted with the way they were able to win it but Galway will feel unlucky and they lost nothing in defeat.
The ‘Bonner’ Maher effect
I’ve spoken about this guy before but Patrick ‘Bonner’ Maher played a key role again for Tipperary yesterday, particularly when his side was chasing the game.
This was ‘Bonner’ time as he rolled his sleeves up, chased back and got in some phenomenal tackles and dispossessions.
Here’s just one example as first, Galway’s Pádraic Mannion gets possession of the ball:
Note the time on the clock, 46:26, before I talk you through what happens next.
In the second picture, Mannion gives ‘Bonner’ the slip as he prepares to move forward with the ball:
Crucially, ‘Bonner’ doesn’t give up as he chases back with the Galway player:
Mannion enters the Galway half but ‘Bonner’ in hot pursuit, executes a perfect hook to turn over the ball:
And finally, with 46 minutes and 37 seconds on the watch, ‘Bonner’ now has ball in hand:
If you’re talking about a proverbial game of inches, this kind of work-rate is priceless.
11 seconds after Mannion first gained possession, ‘Bonner’ has dispossessed him and put Tipperary back on the front foot.
The point is that it’s easy enough to have good work-rate when you’re team is going well but when your team is struggling and down a couple of points, you can really measure a player’s honesty.
You can be a leader and take responsibility without ever opening your mouth and ‘Bonner’ is a guy who does it by action.
Here’s another classic ‘Bonner’ catch as the game prepares to enter its final ten minutes of normal time, Tipp still behind:
Eight seconds later, ‘Bonner’ is grounded by a Gearóid McInerney:
And yet, he still manages to get up and get a handpass away to ‘Bubbles’ O’Dwyer:
I can’t emphasise enough how important this guy is the Tipp team and his importance was never more needed than in that second half yesterday.
The John McGrath influence
Just like ‘Bonner’, I’ve written about John McGrath in the past, particularly after the Munster final and the provincial first round victory over Cork.
His set-up for John O’Dwyer’s goal was terrific yesterday and was yet another example of decision-making and calmness in moments of extreme pressure.
He’s very assured for a young player and held the ball up beautifully to let ‘Bubbles’ get into position off his right shoulder.
The crucial thing to note here is that John’s handpass went straight into O’Dwyer’s hand, which meant that ‘Bubbles’ never lost a stride before he finished with devastating accuracy.
Admittedly, it was an error from John Hanbury that let the ball through to McGrath, as we can see from this first picture:
McGrath picks up possession and the handpass is executed at just the right time and at an ideal height:
What McGrath’s pass has done is allowed ‘Bubbles’ to grab the ball in his left hand:
The pass has cut out the Galway covering defender and also allowed Bubbles that split second that he needs before he get himself into a shooting position.
If it’s lower, Bubbles may have to control it on his stick and perhaps be forced outside but the timing and execution of McGrath’s pass allows the goalscorer the chance to finish with economy of movement.
For John McGrath’s own goal, Seamus Callanan plays a brilliant role.
Where most guys would have taken the ball to hand, he scoops it first time, low to the ground, in McGrath’s direction:
McGrath’s one-on-one with the goalkeeper but he still shows great composure to finish it, first of all taking the contact from Galway goalkeeper Colm Callanan:
John turns and it’s now a simple task as he shoots into an empty net:
It should also be noted in this passage of play that the man who won the ‘dirty’ ball and provided the pass for Seamus Callanan was that man, ‘Bonner’ Maher.
Hurling at this level, one of the most important factors in whether you’re successful or not is how you execute chances. Tipp are very good in this regard.
Two were missed earlier in the game – Noel McGrath unlucky to see a shot come back off the crossbar before John McGrath was denied by an excellent Colm Callanan save – but of four goal chances created, two were taken and that’s a good return. Ultimately, it was good enough to win the match.
Tipp’s forward worries
For all of the good stuff that happened in attack, there are some areas of concern for Tipperary heading into the final with Kilkenny on 4 September.
I felt that when ‘Bubbles’ didn’t start, it was going to place extra pressure on our forward line to get scores.
Daithí Burke marked Seamus Callanan and did an excellent man-marking job on him and Seamus had no score from play.
Seamus still had a good game overall, providing assists while also winning and converting frees, and he set up that aforementioned goal.
But the bigger point is that four of Tipp’s six starting forwards didn’t score from play – Callanan, Dan McCormack, ‘Bonner’ Maher and Niall O’Meara.
Still, ‘Bonner’ had an immense game, as I’ve already discussed, while Dan McCormack provided an assist for John McGrath’s first half point and won at least three frees that were converted by Callanan.
Niall didn’t have his best game in a Tipp jersey this year but he was very workmanlike at the same time, before making way for ‘Bubbles.’
Noel McGrath had three points from play and John McGrath 1-1 but we were under pressure for scores from elsewhere in the forward line.
Michael Breen hit three from midfield while the Mahers – Ronan, Pádraic and Brendan – added one each.
But four players drawing blanks from play in attack is a worrying enough trend for me and it puts pressure on the outfield players to contribute.
Still, the likelihood is that ‘Bubbles’ will start the final and that will add a different dynamic.
Overall, Galway did as well as they could defensively but ultimately, it was Tipp’s goal-scoring ability that got them over the line.
Unforced errors
Tipperary’s two goals were conceded from unforced errors. Niall O’Meara, twice, failed to rise the ball on the Cusack Stand touchline and he comes under pressure here from Cathal Mannion:
Johnny Coen (purple circle in the next picture) picks up possession and his handpass to goal-scorer Conor Cooney (blue circle) is excellent. But Tipp’s error on the touchline has them badly on the back-foot as Cooney has loads of space to run into and he will eventually get his shot away from the spot where the arrow points to:
Tipp conceded two goals from turnovers yesterday and seven points from frees.
Those are statistics that will concern Michael Ryan and it won’t go unnoticed.
Michael pointed to a lack of intensity in some parts of the match and this sloppiness feeds into that.
For Galway’s second goal, Seamus Kennedy and Brendan Maher try to play an elaborate one-two of handpasses but goal-scorer Joseph Cooney is alive to it:
Cooney gets a hurl in and he’s on the move towards the Tipperary goal:
Cooney moves on and crashes a shot into the far corner and Brendan Maher, with hands on head, knows that he’s made a mistake:
Brendan made a pass that he didn’t execute well and really didn’t need to be made. This is what I mean by a lack of intensity and it’s so easy to get caught if you drop in concentration for a split second.
Small changes make the difference
When John O’Dwyer came on, it was at a time when Galway were playing very deep defensively, as they tried to protect their lead.
Tipp were operating with a two-man inside line of Seamus Callanan and John McGrath, with ‘Bubbles’ roaming.
This was a worrying period for Tipp as several balls went into the Galway defence and were mopped up comfortably.
Below is one good example, with just one Tipp forward, Seamus Callanan, anywhere near the 20m line. The Galway defenders, Gearóid McInerney and Daithí Burke, are well positioned to come from two different angles to cover as the ball drops in behind. Eventually, it will be Burke who completes the clearance:
But Tipp mixed it up as Bubbles went into the full-forward line and played as a third inside forward. It really did make the world of difference and ‘Bubbles’ was in the right corner forward position to score his goal, a lot closer to the Galway goal that if he had stayed roaming outside.
Savage battle in Thurles
Savage. There’s probably not a better word to describe Saturday’s replay between Kilkenny and Waterford.
I couldn’t get over the physicality and intensity that was in it from the very word go.
These two teams were really sharp and at match pace from the very first second.
It was just excellent stuff, every exchange at championship intensity and it was brilliant to watch.
The quality of the game was remarkable, particularly in the first 20 minutes and Austin Gleeson’s goal from that Michael ‘Brick’ Walsh pass was pure quality.
When ‘Brick’ wins the ball, he delays the pass for just a fraction of a second, waiting for the gap to open up and for Gleeson to come through:
Gleeson takes the ball at full tilt and doesn’t lose a step, meaning that he’s in full flow to go past the Kilkenny defender, before finishing emphatically:
What I really liked about Colin Fennelly’s first goal for Kilkenny was his absolute intent to score a goal.
It’s a straightforward ball from Walter Walsh from a deep position, straight into the Kilkenny inside line.
Fennelly takes the ball with conviction and crucially, he has that half a yard on Barry Coughlan:
Fennelly was totally committed to taking on his man and in full flow, he was almost unstoppable before crashing a shot to the net:
I spend a lot of time coaching this kind of stuff, particularly with inside forwards.
If they’re lucky enough to win ball cleanly when it goes in, you’ll see some forwards going outside their man in an arcing fashion, trying to get into a position where they can swing it over the bar. But Fennelly was so aggressive in his decision-making, turned and went straight for goal.
That conviction to go for the jugular is what you want from your inside men.
The Fennelly factor
While Colin Fennelly had a crucial impact for Kilkenny with those two goals, his brother Michael was back to his very best on Saturday and his potential absence for the final is a major blow to Kilkenny’s chances.
This was the Michael Fennelly of old, a marauding figure crashing into tackles and driving forward.
But he also does the simple things so well, with this handpass to a better placed teammate eventually leading to a Kilkenny score for Liam Blanchfield at the other end of the field:
The introduction of Blanchfield paid off big time, as he scored three points with probably as many possessions. It just demonstrates the quality of execution required when you’re hurling at the highest level because chances can be few and far between. Your strike ratio has to be very high and it was remarkable display from a guy to go into a game of that magnitude with little or no game time under his belt.
Waterford didn’t do a whole lot wrong and showed remarkable resilience, falling five behind but coming to within a whisker of taking the game into extra-time.
It’s very hard to find any sort of fault in their play but Kilkenny upped their game considerably, as we expected.
Waterford dictated the first game to a large degree, played it at their pace, their tempo.
But on Saturday evening, Kilkenny controlled it, particularly in the second half, but Waterford showed remarkable resilience to hang in there.
I have to finish with that incredible Eoin Murphy catch to deny Pauric Mahony an equalising score.
When you talk about leadership, this is it in a nutshell. Mahony didn’t hit that free badly and it was spot on for accuracy but look how high Murphy gets off the ground to prevent the ball from going over the bar:
That’s just a phenomenal catch, a match-winning moment.
Plenty of goalkeepers wouldn’t have taken that chance if the ball is that far over his crossbar but Murphy deserves huge credit for executing it under that kind of pressure.
The42 is on Snapchat! Tap the button below on your phone to add!
It would be some session.
Interesting they left Thurles off given the large capacity
I’ve never been but heard it’s an awful bootleneck of a place to get to
Wouldn’t say there are a massive number of hotel rooms either.
Having said though i’ve been to Pearse Stadium and Thurles can’t be much worse positioned
@Ciarán: They wouldn’t want to have half empty stadia for the group stages which is what the GAA grounds will be used for with the exception of Croke Park.
100%
Thurles would not have the hotel capacity to accommodate an international game.
Not enough hotel rooms in Thurles for an international game
Casement is as much of a bottleneck to get in and out of.
Pearse stadium is in a city with lots of hotels though, most visitors would be using public transport
Ah u could say the same for Clones. Both are in fairly rural areas with no hotels etc to accommodate larger crowds who will need somewhere to stay
Surprised Cavan not picked.
Seating is terrible. Hard to see the field
@Ciarán: the weak link is MAYO and that will take a lot of selling to the committee
Seemingly not enough hotels around thurles !!!
I agree, it’s hard to believe the stadium with the second biggest capacity, even third if modified to an all seater, is left out of this. It also handles more big crowds on a regular basis than all but Croke Park, is easier to get to than several others with train and motorway links.
That’s a red herring. There’s not much for hotel space in Castlebar, Derry or Kilkenny either. Easy to get to Thurles via train and road (bus) so the hotel issue is nonsense I’d say, no offence.
Can’t understand that one.would be some trip to Tipp
There’s enough in a 20 mile radius plus everyone in Kennedy Park could put up a bunch of them let them make a few Bob lol
Easy get to Castlebar aswel. But it’s a devil to get around the place when a gaa game is on never mind getting busses in for this.
Chreck out balls.ie and it might not be nonsense about hotels ….
Croke park to host a rugby world cup final. Wouldn’t that be a scene.
Noo to forhen games! Make the gaa great again!
It would be the best Rugby World Cup ever !
Think i’ll stick the house up on Airbnb for it and whip out the tent for a few weeks
Better start saving now the tickets ain’t cheap!
amazing – never in a million years did i think a RWC match would be brought to derry. this has to happen
Great for that north west region to see international rugby player there.
Casement could be wiped off that list soon. Quickly becoming a red herring unfortunately.
Could that have an impact on the bid? I’d imagine having a large stadium in the second largest city on the island with a large hotel capacity would be quite crucial to the bid, Ravenhill only holds 18,000.
Casement if finished won’t be 34.5k capacity.
They better improve wheelchair access in a lot of these stadiums
Can’t wait for pairc ui caoimh to open..it’s looking well
Disagree, Pairc Ui Chaoimh is outdated before it’s even built , terribly old fashioned design, one stand is tiny , corners not rounded, terrace not covered, bit of a shambles really
and just when a story is published about irish rail thinking of closing routes that are losing money. the stadia or eagerness of the public to host the tournament won’t be a problem. infrastructure is where we could fall down.
Dont worry we’ll only be three years away from Metro North by 2023
Donncha Ó Ríordáin, the 2011 RWC in NZ was a huge success with almost no rail system and an infrastructure that often consisted of one road in and one road out. Let’s not forget most of the games will be 15,000 to 30,000 hardly any reason to panic and start building motorways. None of the supporters are in a rush to get anywhere.
i’ve never been to nz so wouldn’t know a whole lot about their rail and motor networks. i just know that ours are pathetic. and just because a country like nz hosted a tournament with substandard infrastructure, i don’t think that should be used as an excuse to not put money into transporting people and at least leaving a legacy behind after the tournament.
@Donncha Ó Ríordáin: Insurance, Oil and higher purchase are the daddy. Watch as they invest billions in keeping us on the road.
I was hoping they would tie this announcement in with a redevelopment / new build for Connacht rugby (obviously not a thomond sized building)
Castlebar is significantly bigger than 31,000
Might be restrictions that won’t allow it to be at capacity. Soccer has to be all seated, perhaps the rugby world cup has ruled too about stadia , capacity and other infrastructure
It is all seating, i’d say 38-40,000
It’s all seating but this “seating” on three sides of the pitch comprises of uncovered concrete benches, it’s not exactly on par with a uefa 5 star facility. Other than the new covered stand, it would want a serious upgrade if it is to hold a rugby world cup game.
Without the concrete benches if it held 12,000 I’d be surprised
We’ll tell them to bring cushions with them!
The plan is to keep assign the seating to the entire ground. It’s bee n happening slowly. Injection of cash from this would see it easily finished. That would make the capacity circa. 33,000
Disappointed that the Gaelic Grounds and Semple have been excluded considering their large capacities would mean more tickets for fans etc. Nonetheless, I really hope we get this opportunity. Any news on the France or SA bids?
I believe SA’s own government pulled them out of the running.
It’s something to do with meeting racial quota targets – if they weren’t met the bid wouldn’t be endorsed by the government. I believe it was in doubt, but is back on track now. Don’t quote me on that though.
Yeah the SA govt are back tracking and are now saying the Boks, while not on target, are making serious efforts to meet quotas.
I almost hope not. The rugby bandwagon is getting out of control. It reminds me of the obsession with F1 back in the nineties when Eddie Irvine was threatening for the top spot. Here, (and with the notable exception of Limerick – a true rugby place), everyone seems to think they are part of “the rubby”, when in reality, only those who are privately educated stand much of a chance. They’ll be booing the kicker next. Rugby is in real danger of becoming the new soccer. Going forward.
@Dr Richard DeWitt: What on earth is a “rubby”??
What real fans call it apparently
What a tw@t
@DeWitt, Rugby is one of the most popular sports in the country, due in no small part to the tremendous success of the provinces and the national side. It is here to stay whether you like it or not. As a sport it is loved by many in this country. Landing the world cup would be a huge boost to the economy and no doubt even further grow the game. “Limerick is a true rugby place…”? Ironically enough, a rugby world cup would be a huge boost to the local enomomy in Limerick ( much needed ) and if its true that Limerick is “a true rugby place” then its only fitting the world cup comes to Limerick.
@Dr Richard DeWitt:
‘Is in real danger’ generaly prefixes something bad. Like getting fired or developing diabetes.
@Robert James Behan: How many people loved rugby 20 years ago? You win a bit, everyone is a fan. There are guys I grew up with who thought rugby was for “posh tossers” growing up who now act like they themselves showed promise at under-9. How many people watch F1 now? RTE don’t even show it anymore. It’s a bandwagon, plain and simple.
@Dr Richard DeWitt: Aww someones a bit bitter their sport isnt getting as much attention as they would like. Might want to remove that chip from your shoulder and get over it. What other international sport that we just beat the wrold champions in would you prefer we all obsessed over?
@Dr Richard DeWitt: I think the lack of an F1 team in every parish may have been a factor too
@DeWitt, Must be terrible to be as miserable as you are? Don’t hurt yourself jumping off the band wagon. There is nothing controversial about the rise of rugby. So what if rugby has grown hugely in popularity over the past 20 years? Sport in general is fickle by its very nature. It rises and falls on its own sword. Do you think the football fan base in Ireland didnt massively grow in the late 80s and early 1980s when Ireland were making it to European Championships and World Cups and grinding out results? And what about the huge drop in attendances at football games when the national side wasnt doing so well? Your F1 comment is a red herring. I remember Snooker being a very popular game growing up as a kid. The snooker halls would be packed put when the world championships and other major tournaments were on. It would be well reported and on the TV. Now you would be lucky if there is even a whisper of a snooker tournament in Ireland…… In short your post is pretty redundant.
Ask the Maori coach.. he had only positive things to say about Limerick and their passion for rugby
@Dr Richard DetWit – fixed that for you – one of the t’s was in the wrong place.
Have the GAA officially pledged to upgrade the stadiums mentioned aside of Pairc ui Chaoimh and Casement Park?
@Peter Nagle: might have a job persuading them to put in seating and a roof.
Will we lose the stadiums in the north if brexit goes through??
Not really of it’s a joint bid by the IRFU and GAA, both an all island organisation. Plus the loyalists are not going to turn the money regard of their allegiance.
*turn down the money regardless*.
Wow this is really a small minded statement . Clearly Keelan has no understanding of the passion that the rugby fans in NI have for Irish rugby .
I was referring to hardline Unionist politicians who think there’s some sort of takeover whenever the Republic and the North cooperate together. So don’t be getting your knickers in a twist.
Ok , but I think that you will be waiting a long time to see any objections from any politicians North or South .
I may sound dumb mentioning this, and I apologise if I do, but why not transform Windsor Park to host a rugby match?
@Zacarias.: well it would mean having to get Linfield FC to agree for one while the GAA is already on board. Its capacity is only 18,000 and I suspect the pitch is too short?
Nervous year ahead.
@Trevor Dunne: Bless
Now now Doc don’t be a w@nker
Are we really in a position to host this tournament? Sure, NZ hosted it with perhaps even more inferior infrastructure, but they probably got nowhere near as many fans as we would get due to us being in Europe, where 5 of the 8 or so countries that actually follow the game come from.
We’d probably scrape by hosting it, but there are far more important things to be sorted out in this country.
Eoin Fitzpatrick, when you mention infrastructure, are you talking about high speed trains and motorways? There’s 4 or 5 rest days between your teams games. Fans will zig zag around the country to kill time, visit new places, listen to traditional Irish music and drink Guinness until it comes out their ears.
They might add a bit to the gene pool while they’re at it.
Kerry would want to give Fitzgerald Stadium a good scrub, i was there for first time this year for Munster final, dirtiest stadium iv ever seen, the jacks were the worst iv ever seen , absolutely disgusting which is a pity as Killarney is a great town
Invest in the infrastructure now so it doesn’t become the thing that wrecks the experience!
Well done to the GAA for letting their stadia be used. Very often the national sport in Ireland seems to me to be not GAA or Soccer but – GAA bashing. 8 of the 12 proposed stadium are GAA ones. Anyway good luck to the bid for 2023.
Yeah they’re happy enough f*ckin their foreign sports rule out the window when there’s a chance of making a few bob.
I think that a good many of the proposed venues will never be used. To secure the RWC we will have to trade some of the games to Cardiff, Edinburgh etc to lock down the votes of their unions.
Don’t think so. The Welsh RFU probably dislike the French a bit more than us so we’ll be seen as the lesser of 2 evils. And shur aren’t the Scots our Gaelic cousins.
Dare to dream.
I’d say we are certs .. liam neeson will find the organisers and sort them if not !!!
It’s no surprise that the IRFU has left one of Ireland’s biggest towns in Tallaght out of the picture!
Snobs
I see the Britain wants to host it with Ireland than.