If you watch one VAR discussion tonight, make sure it's this one. The RTÉ panel don't hold back on their opposition of the new system #rtesoccer #worldcup #VAR pic.twitter.com/eCbnM3o2YK
— RTÉ Soccer (@RTEsoccer) June 25, 2018
THE RTÉ PANEL gave a scathing assessment of the Video Assistant Referee system following tonight’s controversial Iran-Portugal game.
Cristiano Ronaldo was fortunate not to be sent off for a stray elbow amid a series of other controversial decisions, and watching on from the studio, Keith Andrews, Didi Hamann and Liam Brady were left deeply unimpressed.
Andrews said the game “became a circus,” while Brady felt Iran were the victims of two bad decisions — the penalty that wasn’t and the failure to send Ronaldo off.
The Arsenal legend added that Iran were fortunate to receive the late penalty, explaining: “Because Iran had suffered a couple of injustices, they said to give the [last-minute] penalty.”
VAR farce? The RTÉ panel still aren't convinced by VAR and whether or not the right decisions are being made #rtesoccer #worldcup #VAR #IRN #POR pic.twitter.com/qSm5yKTa8G
— RTÉ Soccer (@RTEsoccer) June 25, 2018
Hamann, a long-time VAR critic, said there were too many “gray areas” with certain contentious calls for the system to be applied satisfactorily.
“The reason it was brought in in football was to get the right result and the fair result — that is the biggest myth in football because it only takes one decision to get wrong and you don’t get the fair result,” the former Liverpool midfielder said.
“The discrepancy between what we’ve lost in the emotion, heat-of-the-moment decisions, celebrations, sadness, if you compare that to what we got, did it make it any fairer, did it make our product any better? I don’t think it did.”
The42 is on Instagram! Tap the button below on your phone to follow us!
Anyone seen Mel?
@TheHospitalPass: he’s preparing the appeal
@TheHospitalPass: remember he said that Tyrone and Kerry are the top 2 teams in the country a few days ago. What a genius
Derry broke the Tyrone code,did I get that right mel.
@Stephen Doherty: lots on here have made similar statements
@TheHospitalPass: Mel who?
@Joe Healy: Mel who pipes up when Tyrone win but goes missing when they lose in the championship. He’s good craic
@Kevin Mullin: always here
@TheHospitalPass: I’m here unlike you
@Stephen Doherty: we still are
@mel roberts: Hard luck to Tyrone Mel, they were worthy champions last year and at least they have a second chance.
Best team by far. Tyrone just relying on physicality and as usual made a balls of it. 2 red cards is typical of this outfit. If they don’t sort out their tackles, this will be repeated probably against Sligo. Well done Derry
@Noel Lynn: 2 absolutely ridiculous reds to give away, especially the first one. How can you lose your head that easily
@Noel Lynn: it’s a very hard game to tackle fairly in.
@Noel Lynn: mayo v Tyrone in the qualifiers would be a juicy one
@Finnster: ya was just thinking same
Great game from Derry, well on top all over. Will give Ulster some rattle now. Tyrone haven’t been really been at it this year and the back door will be tough this year. Thought the Kennedy red was pretty soft but at the same time it’s not the first time we’ve seen them in trouble with discipline. Works for them some days, caught today.
Tyrone discipline is an absolute disgrace. Week in week out they are involved in brawls and getting red cards for fun. Seems to be every week they are appealing another card. Conor McKenna the usual suspect and once again delivered in getting his red. Pathetic and an awful influence especially for the young players. Would not let me son watch them play, not for the red cards because he’d know better, but for the tragic approach taken. No wonder nobody watches anymore.
@Stanley: In the words of an adopted Derry girl “You might want to think about wising up”.
Might have been better accepting their bans and trying to learn from them
Tyrone might consider the Tailteann cup after that display!
@Desheen: Not Good Enough fir it
Something not right in the Tyrone camp. Fellas quitting the panel, other players publicly criticising fellas for leaving the panel..haven’t been at it this year.
C’mon, Mel. Spill the beans..
Cliques, favoritism, club clashes..?
Derry were always going to be a tough one, the sort of game were ypu need to dig in and get a result. Didnt happen, Derry played well, bossed the midfield and we were petulant. Two red cards that an u11 would be embarressed by. Better team won, fair play Derry but you get these days with us, also get All Ireland finals though.
Please,please can we outlaw the back pass in gaelic football,destroying the game,and the enjoyment thereof
Jesus, first round of qualifiers gonna have Mayo, Tyrone, Armagh, Clare, Monaghan/Derry, possibly Dublin or Kildare depending on the draw.
@Alan Kenny: provincials are so last year. Qualifiers are where the cool teams play their football
@Desheen: Rte gonna be raging
Remember seeing Derry playing in the 50s.and in particular 1958 I think it was,with Jim McKeever and the Cribbin’s ,that team was magic,didn’t win much,no Derry come near since,maybe this team has ‘it’
@Sean Doheny: Didn’t a Derry team not win the All-Ireland in 1993 with a famous team?
@Sean Doheny: you alright there Sean. As far as I remember Derry won an All Ireland in 1993 would you believe. Star studded team they had too.
Where the hell is Mel!??
@Billy Davies: the man is entitled to have a few pints and reflect
@John O Reilly: in Sally’s I’d say
@Tom kenny: was in parkhead yesterday. Watched that shambles from Glasgow thank god
I’ve been in glasgow watching Celtic win the league. I’ll front up. Seen this coming. Fair play Derry. Onto the next. I’m still here unlike hospital pass
Derry bring a dog fight & Tyrone needed that. They are miles from where they need to be and evident from the league. They’ll need to cop on fairly quick or they’ll be dumped out of the qualifiers.
@archie bald henry: no dog fight today. Derry just better today in all areas in fairness.
@Mel Kilcoo would beat Tyrone :)
Derry won in 1993 alright,but weren’t near as magic as the 58 team (my opinion)
I was at parkhead today. Shite Jobby!! I’m here give me pelters it’s deserved!! Seen it coming. We are still gonna win the all Ireland
@mel roberts: Fair play Mel. Take the bad with the good. Derry deserved the win.
Tyrone usually don’t follow up their all Ireland winning years with another the following year. It’s next year I’d be watching out for ye.
@mel roberts:
Fair play on travelling to Celtic Park today.
Hail Hail and up the Dubs.