Wales 23
Ireland 16
Murray Kinsella reports from the Millennium Stadium
IRELAND’S GRAND SLAM dream ended with a 23-16 defeat to Warren Gatland’s impressively combative Wales at the Millennium Stadium.
In an enthralling game in Cardiff, Wales’ sublime defensive effort repelled Ireland at crucial times, while their lineout got the better of Paul O’Connell’s pack on the day of the lock’s 100th cap.
The championship remains alive for Ireland, who travel to Edinburgh next weekend, but there will be disappointment on the journey home from Wales. That said, the hosts were worthy of their win, attacking incisively at crucial points and arguably bettering Ireland in the aerial battle.
Scott Williams’ second-half try was vital, but the kicking game of Leigh Halfpenny, as well as a drop goal from Dan Biggar did most of the damage for Gatland’s men.
Ireland simply struggled to truly cut the Welsh apart with ball in hand, despite a healthy share of the second-half possession in particular. The tryline stands were magnificent from the Welsh, but Schmidt will reflect on a lack of the final thrust when within striking distance.
The Welsh made a lightning start to the game, thundering into Irish tackles, competing successfully in the air and absolutely hammering bodies at ruck time. The combined effect was essentially a 12-0 lead with just 14 minutes gone, Halfpenny firing over four penalties.
Ireland struggled to get to grips with Barnes’ demands around the breakdown, particularly in releasing after the tackle and rolling away, O’Connell looking for clarity on both issues.
Schmidt’s men finally made an impression on the scoreboard in the 18th minute, Sexton kicking a penalty from 46 metres out shortly after missing one from a similar distance wide on the left.
Momentum gradually shifting in their favour, O’Connell and Sexton opted to go to the corner with a quarter gone and Wales penalised for failing to roll away. Big moment you thought, but Sam Warburton leaped to steal in front of Devin Toner as Ireland threw to the tail.
The Welsh captain was soon in the sin bin though, Barnes losing patience when the openside illegally looked to turn Irish possession over at ruck time. Sexton rubbed salt in the wound by making it 12-6.
Wales stemmed Ireland’s growing influence by powerfully building to a 40-metre drop goal for Biggar, though there was frustration that the score stemmed from a harsh scrum penalty against Ireland inside the Wales half.
Ireland’s fluid attack brought them back on top again, O’Connell taking a cleverly delayed Sexton pass to break the impressive Welsh defence and draw another penalty. The out-half had no problem in making it 15-9.
After what had been a stuttering first-half in terms of the flow of the game, the second was one for the ages, both teams adapting to what Barnes wanted at the breakdown. That allowed longer passages of play.
With 50 minutes on the clock, Ireland kicked a penalty to touch on the right side of Wales’ 22 and launched a frankly incredible portion of the game.
Through 32 phases, Wales’ defence held up to the Irish battering of their tryline, hammering ball carriers back in the tackle. Ireland’s error-free attack was similarly astonishing, but they couldn’t find that crucial weak point, Liam Williams eventually being penalised for not releasing post-tackle.
Again, Ireland built through the phases but Robbie Henshaw came in from the side to provide Wales with a relieving penalty.
In a now breathless contest, the inspirational Alun-Wyn Jones counter-rucked for a big turnover in midfield soon after, sending his side tearing back at Ireland through Jonathan Davies.
Tommy Bowe did well to halt the centre just short of the tryline, before Biggar wasted a notable overlap on the left by passing over three of his teammates’ heads and into touch.
Undeterred, Jones pinched the lineout and Wales take their turn to bludgeon at Ireland’s line, eventually firing a pass out to the backs, where replacement Scott Williams, just on for Jamie Roberts, got outside Jamie Heaslip to score.
Biggar converted with comfort to put Wales into an intimidating 20-9 lead, but Ireland responded swiftly. Iain Henderson was particularly impactful as Schmidt sent on a raft of substitutes, the Ulsterman’s restart win and carrying guiding Ireland close once again.
After Cian Healy had knocked-on with the tryline begging and Ireland with a major overlap on the right, Wales prop Aaron Jarvis conceded a penalty at the breakdown, allowing Ireland to kick to the corner. From there, the maul rumbled and Barnes did not hesitate with a penalty try when Wales dragged it down.
Sexton’s conversion brought Ireland back to 20-16 in an absorbing encounter, but a knock-on close to halfway as he looped off Healy brought to an end the next attacking chance.
There was redemption of sorts for man of the match Warburton soon after as he won a sublime turnover penalty to allow Biggar to extend the Welsh lead to 23-16, but Ireland refused to let this game go.
They flooded forward again, Jonathan Davies being yellow carded for slapping down a pass in the Welsh 22 with 78 minutes gone. Into the corner Ireland went, with the nerves around the Millenium Stadium frayed beyond repair.
Charteris stole the first lineout over O’Connell, but Mike Phillips couldn’t get length on this touch finder. Back to the maul Ireland went, but in a huge final act of a defensive masterclass, Wales held it up for the turnover.
Ireland almost looked to have regain possession at the subsequent scrum, but Barnes delivered a final penalty against the men in green. Joy for the Welsh.
Wales scorers:
Try: Scott Williams
Conversion: Leigh Halfpenny
Penalties: Leigh Halfpenny [4 from 4]
Drop goal: Dan Biggar
Ireland scorers:
Try: Penalty try
Conversion: Johnny Sexton
Penalties: Johnny Sexton [3 from 4]
WALES: Leigh Halfpenny; George North, Jonathan Davies (YC ’78), Jamie Roberts (Scott Williams ’59), Liam Williams; Dan Biggar, Rhys Webb (Mike Phillips ’68); Gethin Jenkins (Rob Evans ’40), Scott Baldwin (Richard Hibbard ’57, reversed ’79), Samson Lee (Aaron Jarvis ’13); Luke Charteris, Alun-Wyn Jones (Jake Ball ’72); Dan Lydiate (Justin Tipuric ’68), Sam Warburton (YC ’28), Taulupe Faletau.
Replacements not used: Rhys Priestland.
IRELAND: Rob Kearney; Tommy Bowe, Jared Payne, Robbie Henshaw, Simon Zebo; Johnny Sexton (Ian Madigan ’77), Conor Murray (Eoin Reddan ’63); Jack McGrath (Cian Healy ’57), Rory Best (Sean Cronin ’63), Mike Ross (Marty Moore ’63); Devin Toner (Iain Henderson ’63), Paul O’Connell; Peter O’Mahony, Sean O’Brien, Jamie Heaslip (Jordi Murphy ’72).
Replacements not used: Felix Jones.
Referee: Wayne Barnes.
The rest of the league is improving, if that continues then great. Hibs are a joy to watch for instance with a good manager. Steve Clarke has worked wonders with Kilmarnock also. Aberdeen are very consistent. Another close season and some good buys then hopefully these sides will be even stronger next year.
The most important thing is the negotiation of the new TV deal.
@Ciaran Rice: yeah hopefully Scottish football improves for all our sakes.
@Ciaran Rice: you knew I was going to comment. Jesus Ciaran I think you are a secret Hibs fan. The love in from Celtic fans towards Hibs is laughable due to Lenny being at the helm.
Now there’s you harping on about how competitive this league is and there’s MON stating this is the worst rangers team he has ever seen yet there is only 3 points separating aberdeen, Hibs and the rangers and you are singing the praises of the other two
@Mel Roberts: I appreciate the football that Hibs play. I praised Kilmarnock too. They aren’t as good to watch as they don’t have the players that Hibs do but they are very well organised and drilled by Steve Clarke.
@Ciaran Rice: Gerard is a catholic according to Wikipedia. Wonder how Rangers faithful will react?
@Ciaran Rice: awww Scottish pub football. That’s nice!
@Henry Porter: let’s not tell them for the craic.
@Roibeard O’ Beachain: fk off back to Brighton ya West brit
Just need another team to challenge Celtic, doesn’t have to be rangers. Why not have a strong Hibs team and begin a glasgow – Edinburgh rivalry which could be just as good for Scottish football
Rangers under Gerrard will slip
@Maurice Bourke: I’d say you’re the first person to ever make that joke.
@Maurice Bourke: Yep Glasgow isnt a good place for former Liverpool players to begin managerial careers as John Barnes can testify
Let rangers rot, they bring nothing to the league.
@Ray Farrell: most successful Scottish team by a bit still!
@Gavin Scott: 9 or 10 illegal Scottish titles but never kings of Europe.
@Jamie McCormack: And their fans are hated worldwide .
Martin is beginning to sound a little like the cheerleaders in the Scottish press now.Was he not bothered by the industrial strength cheating when he was up against the old club?Scotland needs a strong Aberdeen,Hibs and the like and not just this particular club which is still living way beyond its means.
I don’t see this as a poisoned chalice for Gerrard at all. All he really needs to do is establish rangers as the undisputed no2 in Scotland and be competitive with Celtic in the head to heads especially at home. Draw a few and the odd win and the majority of fans will be content. The gap in the budgets will keep all bar the headbangers realistic. They should be a clear second and above for the very same reasons they are behind Celtic though and anything less will be inexcusable.
@tim dawson: this couldn’t be further from the truth. The Rangers fans are not going to accept being second to Celtic continuously. I’m going to assume you don’t understand football in Glasgow.
@tim dawson: You obviously dont watch Scottish Football. Neill Lennon and Hibs are miles ahead of Rangers.. Rangers have no money and will start spending stupidly to stop Celtic doing the 10 in a row.. Where as Hibs have decent young players, are playing brilliant football and a potential financial windfall if they sell McGinn to Celtic..
@David Garland: ahhh no they are not. Rangers and Aberdeen are both ahead of Hibs.
@Ciaran Rice: The majority will reluctantly imo. They wouldn’t have prior to sevco but they are a lot more clued in financially now than they used to be and than the average big club fan. Yes they want to finish above Celtic but not by bankrupting the club. They will not accept finishing behind anyone else though and They will not accept second to anyone if the money is there through a new owner etc but in the current circumstances they have no choice and they know it.
@David Garland: I don’t they will. As for hibs etc that’s why Murty was sacked. I agree that hibs are playing good football. It’s great to see them getting full houses.
Puke football…and i support finn harps
@Jono: you’re speaking from experience so
O’Neill would know all about dreadful teams
a joke League at least in the LOi most of the top half are comppeting
If rangers won just 2 of the old firm games Brendan Rogers would probably be about to be replaced by Gerard
Hibs are crap. When was the last time they won the league?
Sevco are a joke and deserve to be laughed at. Relegation could be a reality for them next season.
@Trevi Fountain: what has their last title win got to do with the current Hibs team being good? Nothing?
When was the last time you watched Hibs?
One less team to pillage the rest, gives Aberdeen, hibs hearts etc a chance to build teams and not have the best ripped away from them