As always, we’d love to hear your thoughts on this evening’s game. E-mail paul@thescore.ie,tweet @thescore_ie, post a message to our Facebook wall, or leave a comment below.
You may need to refresh the page for YouTube videos and other elements to display correctly.
England 8-14 Ireland
Hello, and welcome to our liveblog of today’s game.
We’ll have the team news for you momentarily.
Here are today’s teams:
England Saxons: E Daly, A Watson, M Hopper, S Hill, C Sharples, F Burns, J Simpson, A Waller, J George, T Mercey, C Matthews, G Kruis, C Clark (c), L Wallace, D Ewers
Replacements: D Ward, N Catt, S Wilson, E Stooke, S Dickinson, D Lewis, H Slade, R Miller
Ireland Wolfhounds: F Jones; F McFadden, R Henshaw, D Cave, C Gilroy; I Madigan, I Boss; D Kilcoyne, R Herring, M Moore; I Henderson, D Tuohy; R Ruddock (c), T O’Donnell, R Copeland.
Replacements: R Strauss, J McGrath, S Archer, R Diack, J Murphy, K Marmion, I Keatley, S Zebo.
Speaking to Sky, Anthony Foley says the Wolfhounds are using the “same template as the senior side have” today, but adds that they’ll have to “adapt” to the occasion.
Meanwhile, the Sky pundits have singled out Ian Madigan as a player to watch this evening.
While the Irish side has plenty of full international experience, the same cannot be said for England.
There are just three full internationals between them, who have a total of eight caps — Joe Simpson (one cap), Freddie Burns (three) and Charlie Sharples (four).
We can’t say we disagree with this:
Ireland 7-0 England: It’s the first time Ireland have found themselves deep in opposition territory and Isaac Boss capitalises (4 mins).
He collects the ball from the scrum following a lineout inside the 22, and dummies before darting through a gap in the English defence to score the game’s first try.
Madigan then makes no mistake with the conversion.
Following that opening try, Ireland have had to deal with pressure of their own.
Daly sprints for the corner, but he doesn’t quite have the pace to escape his marker, and Ireland subsequently retrieve possession and clear.
Ireland are playing with the wind, so they have a slight advantage this half.
They’re currently having to deal with English pressure though, as the hosts are in possession just outside the Wolfhounds’ 22.
With just 15 minutes played, the pitch is already a mess and the players are covered in mud.
England have enjoyed superior possession and territory, but look a little stale in attack at the moment.
Sky’s Stuart Barnes, meanwhile, believes Ireland are “edging it” at the moment.
Again, England have possession in the Irish 22, but again, they struggle to outwit the visitors’ disciplined defence.
They eventually knock-on under pressure from the Irish defence, enabling Anthony Foley’s team to earn a scrum.
Joe Schmidt has just been pictured watching on in the crowd. He’ll be relatively impressed with aspects of the Irish side’s game thus far.
England 5-7 Ireland: Gilroy fails to hold Felix Jones’ pass and Anthony Watson capitalises, catching the stray ball and running under for a try (24 mins).
Burns then hits the post with his conversion.
Ireland 14-5 England: Quick thinking from Ian Madigan. After an attack breaks down, the ref brings it back for a penalty, and the Leinster man has the strength to drive over the line after his well-judged decision to go for a quick tap and go (29 mins).
He then dusts himself off and confidently kicks the conversion.
Ireland are deservedly ahead with five minutes remaining until half-time.
They’ll perhaps want to extend their advantage while they still have the wind on their side though.
So Ireland deservedly lead at the break.
They have frequently been incisive in attack, and have also been solid in defence — save that one lapse when Gilroy failed to hold onto Jones’ pass.
Ian Madigan was arguably the standout player. There was one moment when he inexplicably dropped a pass and put the Irish under pressure, but in general, he has kicked and passed very efficiently, while he also took his try extremely well.
In contrast, the English’s inexperience has shown. They’ve been consistently inferior at the breakdown, and despite enjoying a significant amount of possession and territory at times, the hosts have invariably looked short of ideas in attack.
(Ireland’s Robbie Henshaw tackled by Charlie Sharples of England – INPHO/Dan Sheridan)
It’s a low-key start to this second half.
It’s been a little scrappy, partially due to the increasingly poor conditions, with the majority of the half so far being played around the halfway line.
England have had 78% of the possession in the second half so far.
Nevertheless, similar to the first half, they are committing a number of sloppy errors and lack Ireland’s ruthlessness in attack.
England win a penalty, but Burns hits the penalty for the second time this evening with his attempt.
Meanwhile, Jack McGrath has just replaced David Kilcoyne, and Simon Zebo is on in place of Craig Gilroy.
England launch another promising attack in Ireland’s 22, but somewhat predictably, the move breaks down.
Clark knocks on a simple enough pass to take, and Ireland can relax again.
A great sustained attack from Ireland as Zebo is pushed into touch inches from the try line.
The gulf in class is really evident in the comparisons between the way the teams attack in the opposition 22, with Ireland far more impressive in that area.
The latest substitutions see Jordi Murphy and Ian Keatley on for Tommy O’Donnell and Robbie Henshaw.
England 8-14: Ireland Freddy Burns finally gives his side hope, kicking over a first successful penalty to bring the hosts within six points of their opponents (63 mins).
Game on!
England have just won a penalty at the breakdown.
The Irish side haven’t been quite so impressive compared with their first-half showing
Meanwhile, Diack is on for Henderson and Marmion has replaced try-scorer Boss.
(Ireland’s Ian Madigan tackled – INPHO/Dan Sheridan)
England are looking very strong all of a sudden.
McFadden has to make a good tackle to stop Daly sprinting to the corner for a try.
England continue to probe around their opponents’ 22, but it’s been a huge effort throughout this match from the Irish defence.
Just under four minutes remain now.
Unbelievable drama as Burns drops the ball out of play as he attempts to dive for the try line with the last play of the game.
It’s all over then, as the referee blows the final whistle.
Man of the Match Isaac Boss praises the side for showing “a lot of heart” and acknowledges that the conditions prevented both teams from playing fluent rugby.
The Irish side made over 120 tackles.
So Ireland hold on for a gritty victory.
The conditions ensured that it wasn’t really a game for individuals to impress too much.
That said, there were a number of players who did their cause no harm — Madigan, Boss, Henshaw, Copeland, Cave and Ruddock in particular all had solid outings.
With the wind against them, Ireland played with extreme pragmatism and were perhaps overly eager to kick the ball out of hand at times.
They were nearly made to pay, as the hosts were inches away from scoring a try and potentially winning the match in the final seconds.
However, ultimately, Ireland’s determined defence ensured they held out for a hard-fought and just-about-deserved victory.
what ever about South Africa. Georgia should be given a chance over Italy.
@David Duignan: and what would Georgia contribute seeing as Italy consistently beat them?
How many people do you think will be lining up for 7 hour flight to Tbilisi in February and March instead of Rome?
Italy’s under age teams have been winning games. Dropping them now sees any progress made wasted and resetting the clock 20 years to put Georgia in the same position.
@David Duignan: Italy need to be retained and supported cutting them lose would be a turn for the worst. Georgia……. Are you serious. Italy are suffering from a leveling of playing the rest of the playing field with a resurgent France and Scotland. Georgians would crumble under the relentlessness of 6N. You need massive squad
Italy were never going anywhere, and any form or relegation is not going to happen, far to much at stake for every union. The only question is will the 6 nations become the 7 nations.
Knew I shouldn’t have believed something from the daily mail
I’d say it will happen in c 3 years timeframe but likely they add a 7th team and not drop Italy to the wilderness
And here is an amazing stat for you …
Just noticed 56 comments from the earlier post on this and I didn’t see one mention of this more obvious option – keep Italy and let SA join ( same league as their provinces play and also almost the same time zone
Everyone was either totally against them joining or pro Italy staying
Things that make you go hmmm …
@John Lowry: I thought it covered that in the orginal article. Dont think anyone with a reasonable knowledge of how the 6 nations is set up though that Italy leaving, or there being promtion/relegation was ever going to happen. The only real story was will the 6 nations become the 7 nations (fits in the same international window, with each team getting two rest weeks as well). SA fans aren’t that keen, 6 nations fans aren’t that keen, but CVC and the money men are. TBH its not in the best intrests of world wide rugby, and I wouldn’t really like it myself.
@Kingshu: I reckon SA will join if you add up all the dots it kind of makes most sense
Will take a couple of years to happen
If they are denying it now that means it will almost certainly happen as its hard to believe anything one hears in the media,in a lot of cases believe the opposite of what you hear and you won’t be too far wrong
@O’Brien Michael: So you don’t believe this but you do believe the reports about it “definitely happening”?. Strange to say the least…