Kilkenny 2-20
Dublin 1-16
Kevin O’Brien reports from Parnell Park
DUBLIN WILL BE left wondering what might have been as a red card for Gary Maguire after 31 minutes ultimately cost them in a titanic clash with Kilkenny.
The Cats ran out seven point winners in the end, but these young Dubs can hold their heads up high after severely testing Kilkenny, both in the physical and hurling stakes.
The result means Kilkenny will face Wexford in the National Hurling League quarter-final next weekend, while Dublin will battle Clare in a bid to avoid the drop to the second tier.
The sight of Richie Hogan being called ashore by Brian Cody after 53 minutes gives an indication to the pressure Kilkenny were under throughout, but eventually the made their experience and spare man count.
Cody revealed after the game that Hogan had suffered from back spasms earlier in the week, but he was denied any opportunity to pick off his usual array of scores in the pocket by a hard-working home outfit.
TJ Reid contributed handsomely for the winners with 0-10, including six frees, but it was the performances of youngsters Conor Martin and Liam Blanchfield that left Kilkenny fans purring on their trip home from the capital.
Martin, in his debut season, finished with 1-5 from play, while Blanchfield’s tally of 1-2 isn’t to be sniffed at. If that duo can carry some of the scoring burden that has been weighing Reid and Hogan down, then Cody will consider the league campaign a major success.
Remember, his attack also has Kevin Kelly and Ger Alwayrd to slot back in. The well hasn’t run dry yet.
Dublin played an intelligent tactical game, with Domhnall Fox acting as a spare defender on the half-back line. It was a game-plan that served them well right up until Maguire’s dismissal, which left Ger Cunningham with no option but to abandon the extra back for the second-half.
The menacing presence of Donal Burke, a year out of minor, in the inside corner meant Dublin had a steady supply of scores (1-7), while Chris Crummey chipped over three points in on of the most effective man marking jobs of the Ballyhale man you’re ever likely to see.
Martin bagged a 4th minute goal for the Cats, but it quickly became apparent they weren’t going to have things all their own way. Donal Burke and Niall McMorrow were among the scores as the home side edged in front by 0-7 to 1-3 after 23 minutes.
They key moment of the game arrived eight minutes later. A good Kilkenny move culminated in Blanchfield rattling the onion bag from close-range. Dublin keeper Gary Maguire was dismissed for his desperate swing across Blanchfield as he attempted to prevent the goal.
Dublin went in at the break a point behind and, crucially, a man behind, despite producing most of the good play in the opening period.
Conor Martin bagged a 4th minute goal for the Cats, but it quickly became apparent they weren’t going to have things all their own way. Donal Burke and Niall McMorrow were among the scores as the home side edged in front by 0-7 to 1-3 after 23 minutes.
They key moment of the game arrived eight minutes later. A good Kilkenny move culminated in Blanchfield rattling the onion bag from close-range. Dublin keeper Gary Maguire was sent off for his wild swing across Blanchfield, breaking his hurley off the corner-forward as he attempted to prevent the goal.
Dublin went in at the break a point behind and, crucially, a man behind, despite producing most of the good play in the opening period.
Donal Burke rolled in a goal for the home side minutes after the turnaround, but Reid, Hogan and Martin all responded with points leave the Cats in front by 2-11 to 1-12 at the end of the 3rd quarter.
The numerical disadvantage had taken its toll on Cunningham’s troops by the finish and Reid put the gloss on the win with his precise dead ball shooting in the closing stages.
Scorers for Kilkenny: TJ Reid 0-10 (0-6 frees), Conor Martin 1-5, Liam Blanchfield 1-2, Conor Fogarty, Walter Walsh and Richie Hogan 0-1 each.
Scorers for Dublin: Donal Burke 1-9 (0-7 frees), Chris Crummey 0-3, Ben Quinn, Ryan O’Dwyer, Cian Boland and Niall McMorrow 0-1 each.
Kilkenny
1. Eoin Murphy (Glenmore)
2. Paul Murphy (Danesfort)
3. Padraig Walsh (Tullaroan)
4. Conor O’Shea (Clara)
5. Conor Fogarty (Erin’s Own)
6. Jason Cleere (Bennettsbridge)
7. Shane Prendergast (Clara)
8. Paddy Deegan (O’Loughlin Gaels)
9. Cillian Buckley (Dicksboro)
10. Colin Fennelly (Ballyhale Shamrocks)
11. Walter Walsh (Tullogher Rosbercon)
12. TJ Reid (Ballyhale Shamrocks)
12. Liam Blanchfield (Bennettsbridge)
14. Richie Hogan (Danesfort)
15. Conor Martin (Emeralds)
Subs
22. Pat Lyng for Fennelly (blood sub, 16 to 25)
17. Joey Holden for P Walsh (ht)
Kieran Joyce for O’Shea (61)
Yellow: Conor Martin
Dublin
1. Gary Maguire (Ballyboden St Enda’s)
19. Fionn Ó Riain Broin (St Judes)
3. Eoghan O’Donnell (Whitehall Colmcille)
4. Shane Barrett (Na Fianna)
5. Chris Crummey (Lucan Sarsfields)
6. Liam Rushe (St Patrick’s Palmerstown)
2. Cian MacGabhann (Kilmacud Crokes)
7. Ben Quinn (Crumlin)
8. Domhnall Fox (St Jude’s)
10. Eoghan Conroy (St Maur)
11. Niall McMorrow (Ballyboden St Enda’s)
14. Ryan O’Dwyer (Kilmacud Crokes)
15. Eamon Dillon (Naomh Fionnbarra)
24. Donal Burke (Na Fianna)
13. Cian Boland (St Oliver Plunketts)
Subs
16. Conor Dooley for Conroy (31)
12. Fiontan McGibb for Fox (ht)
Rian McBride for MacGabhann (52)
Cian O’Sullivan for Boland (58)
Fergal Whiteley for Fox (65)
Yellow: Ryan O’Dwyer
Red: Gary Maguire
Referee: Paud O’Dwyer (Carlow)
Hopefully TV3 will show us the start of this one!
@Murph: Yeh that was shocking by tv3. They’re living up to their reputation. Enjoying watching Scotland get their arses handed to them. Really hope this scenario doesn’t happen to Ireland tho.
@Murph: watch on BBC FFS
@M.G Lochlain: was going to get a 2nd aerial to get tv3 ( im in the north) for £120. Sound like i its a waste of money? Still not looking forward to itv coverage….
@Murph: how many times did they have to mention Ireland Got Talent being on! And hat the hell was that awful mashup at the end of today’s highlights mixed with the Ireland got talent clips!
#notmycaptain
@Ísla Carabine: of course he isn’t you aren’t on the pitch playing
@Ísla Carabine: #innocentuntilprovenguilty. #youmoron.
@Ísla Carabine: I’d like to have a friend like him of i was ever on trial regardless of guilt (which is yet to be determined)
@Dave O Keeffe: that’s fair, it’s extremely difficult for the family and friends of an alleged perpetrator to get their heads around something like this. But, if he is standing by him, do it quietly, he is Ireland’s captain and should under no circumstances be making this worse for the alleged victim. Talking to Matt Cooper yesterday he said this whole thing has driven them on with anger. What kind of message does that give to people who have been raped or abused?!
@Ísla Carabine: but if he tells you hes innocent, and as the leader of ulster rugby, by not being there for support it, then it would come across as he did not believe/support him. If it was any (most) other crimes it would not be an issue. But still i understand the other point of view too, very difficult situation all round.
@Ísla Carabine: look they were stupid for going and should have known it would blow up like this. But it’s done now so let’s move on and actually enjoy the competition and not let this shite over shadow It!
@Sam Harms: some things are more important than a game of rugby and this is one of them. Saying let’s move on is diminishing what’s going on. Those texts alone showed a terrible attitude towards women not something that should be tolerated or endorsed. IRFU and UR are handling this very badly the no comment does them no favours makes it look like there is more to the 3 players going because them going personally is not a legal issue and could just state that if it were the case but now it looks like intimidation and trying to sway opinion. The girl said she was resistant to come forward because she was scared it would be her going up against UR and then they turn up the next day the day she testifies. Yes innocent until proven guilty but that doesn’t mean you can’t have an opinion on what RB, IH and CG did. Terrible decision was made here.
@Gaz o’keeffe: it’s a legal matter, they aren’t allowed to make a comment!
@Gaz o’keeffe: also i agree with you those texts were disgusting and even if they are innocent I hope they never play for Ireland or Ulster again. I don’t think Best and Henderson should have been there at all but it’s done now and it can’t be taken back. Personally I don’t think Best should be captain for other reason but this whole social media hashtagging stuff is ridiculous
@Sam Harms: them turning up to sit in the public gallery in a personal capacity is not a legal issue at all. They could have simply stated they were there in a personal capacity and leave it at that. They’re actions spoke loud and clear to a lot so it doesn’t look good to then try and hide behind no comment and saying its a legal issue when it’s not. It’s only a legal issue if there is more to then them simply going in a personal capacity.
@Sam Harms: you’re entitled to your opinion but the hashtag resonates hugely with people. The poor girl has huge backing.
@Ísla Carabine: but best and Henderson aren’t the ones accused of anything so there shouldn’t be a hashtag saying he shouldn’t be captain. If they were the ones accused of raping someone then it would be different but the fact is they didn’t actually do anything. And how do we know they didn’t just go to hear the girls side of things?
@Dave O Keeffe: spoken like a typical rugby male
@Patrick Corrigan: thats a dumb comment. He could give more support privately than in court. That was out of order.
@Ísla Carabine: Just so you know Best has actually clarified why he was there. He has said that he is down as a character witness and wanted to hear both sides of the story himself
Everyone watch on BBC just try and get RTÉ back
@Ollie Watson: that… not how it works. RTE are at fault.
@Pete Slattery ✊: I don’t think they are, apparent TV3 aren’t making money and are even making a loss. Do you think it would be acceptable for RTE to make a loss?
Can someone tell me the point of going for a drop goal when there’s a penalty advantage in front of the posts. The penalty is going to be scored so there’s no advantage in a drop goal. Why not just throw a wild pass instead?
@Thomas O’ Donnell: Because they probably wouldn’t have scored a try and advantage would be over
@Thomas O’ Donnell: Johnny likes drop goals it seems…
@Thomas O’ Donnell: because even with the advantage, given, it can be lost just as easily. Jonathan wanted to end the game on his terms and just go for it. If he felt that he wouldn’t be able to make that goal, he would have gone for a safer decision. also the game was in injury time
James Ryan looks the part and Keith Earls owns that 14 jersey. Earls seems to be getting faster with age.
As per usual Kearney runs the ball goes to ground and turns it over.
@Declan Byrne: But you’ll say nothing about the fact that he’s having a great game and the ball was robbed from us that lead to Kearney having to cover. Nah, that’s not the “popular” thing to say is it.
@Declan Byrne: Kearney’s having a stormer.
@Declan Byrne: I agree, he does run the ball back and “hold on” hence giving a penalty away alot of the time. Yeh playing well other than that
@Jonny Cantwell: What has Kearney done well enlighten me thanks. Playing well against a poor France team ?
@Declan Byrne: Covering his position brilliantly and stopped a certain French try, he’s showing great pace when he gets the ball and is running some great lines. He’s also linking well with the back line in general creating moves. So yeah, some would say he’s having a great game indeed. You’re welcome.
@Declan Byrne: if it was a poor France team we would be winning by a lot more than 6 points
@Sam Harms: Well Ireland not been allowed to playing well . Very tactical Joe wants to get out of Paris with a win at all costs not like last year screwing up on day one .
@Jonny Cantwell: Don’t forget the knock forward in his great game to day.
@Declan Byrne: Yeah you’re right there mate, a knock on…shameful stuff from him.
@Jonny Cantwell: I am been hard on Kearney because I expect more from him.
@Jonny Cantwell: Kearney was a liability as teddys try showed. He was turned over twice. Good in the air but that’s not enough at this level. Especially when there is so much competition for full back.
@Anthony Davoren: liability? Very solid in defence (and I’m not his biggest fan) not the only one to miss a tackle in that phase. Shocking we fell asleep so easily especially against France in France, there is a reason the stats are the way they are all¯\_(ツ)_/¯
for you naysayers of Kearney, he is excellent, having started his rugby career at a very young age, he does have his bad moments but he is an asset to the team. Also he’s a Cooley Boy so I am biased towards him..
Where is the gender equality in tv3 panel for the game?
@The Debater: will you ever rev up and fućk off
BBC just introduced Bill O’Connell as a panel expert.
Looks a lot like Paul O’Connell to me!
Although I’m a big fan of Nigel …. my god some shocking calls tonight
KIA, knee injury assessment
Come on Ireland !
Trying to watch the end of the Scotland on the three player and they keep showing a GUINNESS ad on repeat.
Anyone else having problems
Being back RTE
@matt doyle: In fairness the RTE player is not any better.
Good luck too the boy’s in Green, go out and win with Pride and Ireland.
That’s why sexton got picked while he was away. Pure class
Whether you think Best is a brave captain to go support his teammates in a time of need or whether you think he’s a r@pist-supporting gowl – he still shouldn’t have gone to the trial and made the focus of the six nations about his personal actions off the field.
It shows his head is focused on something other than leading his county. And that alone is unforgivable.
@Abbie Cranky: County????? Clown.
@Abbie Cranky: Iain Henderson shouldn’t have gone either. yet people seem to forget that he was there too…
Either way this trial goes, Paddy Jackson’s promising career for Ireland is over. personally i feel that he was completely and utterly moronically stupid, and hope he gets jail time for his actions.
Love ya Johnny
Ah keith wood hinted at it during the week, Nigel Owens has the plot lost ..
James Ryan is playing really well considering his experience. Looks like he’s gonna be a top class player.
Sexton you god
fair dues Sexton.
@Minom Pnnomm: genius kick to earls as were going nowehere. if it hadn’t come off he would be murdered. small margins. Ireland poor today in poor conditions. not 1 line-break for Ireland?
Nigel Owens is having a shocker some terrible decisions
@Kenneth O Brien: not he is not, Ireland are making mistake after mistake.
@Kenneth O Brien: apparently taking player out in air without ball is ok in his book. The fact it went to tmo showed others didnt agree but ultimately what he says goes. Officiated correctly its an Ireland penalty at least and should be no where near the French try. Also the French #5 was a penalty machine and he took no further sanction
Sweet jesus!!
Feel sorry for jvf, missed last year’s six nations due to injury
Ehh… Ireland have the players and the form; whats going on? Playing attritional rugby against France not working– France are terrible AND in a really bad spot atm. Questions needs to be asked of Schmidt tactics
As much as im happy to be ahead… It is a boring enough match… But then again if Ireland come through can’t complain. Result counts. Come on Ireland
@Maurice Mulcahy: A win is important but the truth of the matter is that this is an awful game.
They build proper men in Ireland. Spuds will beat baguettes any day :-)
Ireland win! Celebratory spitroasts all round!
@DaisyChainsaw: go back to your play dough.
Nigel oxens is having a shocker!
Kicking to much ball away and the kicking has been poor so far.
The bad side is that the French are well up for this game, the good side is that we’re managing everything brilliantly; defence, kicking, glimpses of magic in attack. So far so good.
#ismycaptain
Come on Ireland!!
We have really had little nothing past the French 22. All the possession in the world is useless if we look this toothless going forward. Same old story
Yes Sexton!!
Rob Kearney having the game of his life, super stuff
@Tony Yeboah TP: that changed
JOHNNY SPOTY
In no way a Kearney hater but jaysus will you run at space instead of contact all the time.. also Henshaw is having a mare his passing is terrible he’s not even drawing the man to release the winger outside he shouldn’t be near the 13 jersey…12 all day long.
We need to get away from this one out runner crap when we get to the opposing teams 22 it’s ffffing killing our attacking game the ball is so slow.
Henderson having a brilliant game
Christ almighty…. That was exciting but being honest very lucky to win that had one realistic chance to get a try got nowhere… France had three chances got one… Brian Moore was said on BBC based on second half Ireland have stolen this… sport is unfair… But that’s the way it goes…
Tbh I bloody Delighted its only third time in my lifetime I’ve seen them win in Paris… But lads ye need to.improve
@Maurice Mulcahy: no we havent. Look at the penalty count etc. Individual brilliance on both sides. No surprise a former English hooker is worried about Paddy’s Day
Healy first try 45/1.
Kearney useless. Teddy.
@Minom Pnnomm: always good for a crucial missed tackle.
I’m not well after that. Seriously though, Sexton more than made up for his earlier miss. What a score, what a man and to the whole team who kept going. Fantastic :)
Sexton you’re a god
Talking all week about how much they are going to win by in a place they hardly ever win???????
Ireland are brutal
No sign of the Irish anthem today?
@Enda Reynolds: they don’t play the anthem at away matches, they use Ireland’s Call.
Its a win but God was it awful. Its Martin O’Neill soccer on a rugby field
unefffing believable!!!!!
Onya CJ
Just goes to show what you can achieve with a real leader in charge. Sexton drove that last game drive – in Owens ear questioning his terrible late decision making too.
Rory Best is not, and never has been, a true leader. Everything changed when Sexton took the lead
@Karlavaro: i never rated best as captain and the handbags during the first half kinda cemented that feeling for me. The captain should be the last person getting involved in that kind of stuff
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! Gwan ya good thing!
Brilliant by Murray
Whether you think Best is a brave captain to go support his teammates in a time of need or whether you think he’s a rapist-supporting shite – he still shouldn’t have gone to the trial and made the focus of the six nations about his personal actions off the field.
It shows his head is focused on something other than leading his county. And that alone is unforgivable.
@Abbie Cranky: Cranky Troll. Good bye
@Bluepoolroad: excellent contribution. Rush me to the burns unit.
@Bluepoolroad: well spoken Blue.
@Abbie Cranky: “burns unit”, Love it. Thanks.
C’mon Sexton you need to get those
@William Finnegan: just about made up for it! 6 nations would have been dead. thankfully the frog missed that easy enough kick also.
Jesus Christ what a finish !
No sign of a totally dominating Ireland so far. France dull but reasonably competent.
Feel sorry for jvf, missed last year’s six nations die to injury
Leinster are having a bad day against the French boys.
@Maid Marian: That’s odd because last time I checked Stander, Aki, stockdale, Earls, Murray, Henderson,POM, Best, and Ryan all play with other provinces.
Kearney unfortunately is no threat going forward constantly turned over. We’re far too reliant on kick chase. Switched off in defence for try very unprofessional they had taken quick throws earlier and players were far too slow trying to stop thar. Schmidt needs to show more adventure in his selections and tactics. That was a hard game to watch with such talented players. Got out of jail this time
Super kick but out of jail there.
What’s the point of tv3 not having HD coverage after spending all that money on six nations coverage what a bunch of idiots. Sport is one place you really notice it.
@ed w: TV3RD RATE
McFadden to the rescue! lol!
Bit nervous about this game. I have cribbed and I have cribbed that Joe Schmidt has not picked on form but bar Rob Kearney at fullback this is the first time Joe has actually picked on form. So I am nervous to see if form will provide a really good performance. Here’s hoping
@Brian Jones: Kearney is in fine form over the last few months
That Teddy bear is class, Ireland could do with someone like him.
The French are coming in from the side more times than a burglar.
terrible non-call by NO, but this loss will be totally Ireland’s fault. For such an experienced team, atrocious play in the 2nd half. More dignity if they stayed in the locker room.
@jindublin: all is forgiven!!!! BUT I hope they don’t keep playing like this for the next 4 matches or I will need blood pressure meds!
@jindublin: bad conditions but ireland playing by numbers which the French negated by line speed. Schmidt needs to vary things a bit.
brute force but brute force is whats needed
@Brian Jones: that’s the general idea of the game alright. Ireland lucky against a poor poor French outfit.
Painful to watch (on the BBC by the way) but thank god for small mercies, not a sight or sound of that odious George Hook.
@Joseph Dempsey: Then dont watch. Crucial 20’ ahead.
Sexton won’t sleep after that missed kicked
@Fred McHugh: Well he’ll sleep like a baby now!
@Fred McHugh: you sure
@William Finnegan: hell yeah he will
CTE Sexton does it again ! Colon you boys in green
The ad is just repeating for me too… it better be fixed before the game
Cricfree or stream to watch
Good start
Come on France
NEW… from ROB KEARNEY enterprises
Now you too can own a pair of Johnny Sexton stones now on special offer for only €13.15 order now before time runs out!
Ceiling in the pub well and truly destroyed!!!
What’s the story with furlongs bind?? Very odd the way his bind is behind Best not around his waist
30 second ad break. Cue people losing their shit !!
Hopefully the lads were watching the Welsh game. Arrogance will f**k us over here against the French. We are not suited to the favourite tag.