EARLIER IN THE week, Liam Brady, in an appearance on Second Captains Live, made the controversial decision to remove Roy Keane from ‘The Good Wall’ and replace him with John Giles.
The decision stirred up plenty of debate, not least in The42.ie office.
Consequently, we’ve decided to pick our all-time Ireland XIs in a bid to definitively separate the good Irish footballers from the great ones.
So here are the teams that our writers ultimately came up with…
Steve O’Rourke
EMPICS Entertainment
EMPICS Entertainment
Playing a traditional 4-4-2, this XI supports attacking creativity on a foundation of defensive invulnerability. The likes of Mick McCarthy and Ronnie Whelan could probably feel hard done by but I’d fancy this side to beat anyone, especially with the little ‘un/big ‘un combination up front.
Shay Given Denis Irwin Paul McGrath Richard Dunne Steve Staunton Ray Houghton Roy Keane Johnny Giles Liam Brady Robbie Keane Niall Quinn
Eoin O’Callaghan
PA Archive / Press Association Images
PA Archive / Press Association Images / Press Association Images
In theory, I don’t like naming a Best XI and including players I haven’t seen play.
But, for the purposes of this assignment and the general dearth of brilliant players Ireland have had during my lifetime, some just had to be included. Everyone is aware of the immense contributions made by Giles and Brady but other figures like Noel Cantwell and Johnny Carey were immense characters. They may not have the cap-count that other less-decorated players have but quality over quantity everytime. There’s a stylish central defensive pairing while the midfield speaks for itself.
The attack is a different beast. I wanted to allow Keane & Giles the space to dictate a game so have gone with a 4-2-3-1 with Houghton and Sheedy providing some width and Brady given the freedom to combine with a young, fresh and willing Robbie Keane.
Advertisement
Shay Given
Noel Cantwell Johnny Carey Paul McGrath Denis Irwin
Roy Keane John Giles
Ray Houghton Kevin Sheedy Liam Brady
Robbie Keane
Paul Fennessy
EMPICS Entertainment
EMPICS Entertainment
Shay Given gets in just ahead of Pat Bonner in goals. Defence was particularly tricky to choose, with Steve Staunton, Dave O’Leary and Richard Dunne among those unlucky to miss out.
Three out of four midfielders are straightforward enough picks, with Giles, Brady and Keane almost impossible to leave out, while Ronnie Whelan gets the fourth spot, ahead of other once-great players including Damien Duff and Ray Houghton.
Robbie Keane deserves to be up front for his phenomenal goalscoring record alone, while Frank Stapleton joins him, despite stiff competition from the likes of Niall Quinn, John Aldridge and Tony Cascarino.
Shay Given
Finnan McGrath Lawrenson Irwin
Giles Ronnie Whelan Roy Keane Brady
Robbie Keane Stapleton
Sean Farrell
EMPICS Sport
EMPICS Sport
My team is gonna play ball. That’s why I’ve sacrificed some of the blood and thunder you might get with the Honey Monster in favour of the out-and-out comfort on the ball you get with Irwin, O’Shea and Staunton.
The midfield trip is pretty much inter-changeable and would pin defences into their own box mercilessly until they crack. While the 4-5-1 formation lacks a target man up top, Damien Duff is sure to win a ton of free kicks which Dinny and Stan can fight over/come to a sensible decision based on the best angle for their strong foot.
Shay Given
Denis Irwin (Capt.) Paul McGrath John O’Shea Steve Staunton
Roy Keane Liam Brady
Ray Houghton John Giles Damien Duff
Robbie Keane
Will Slattery
PA Archive / Press Association Images
PA Archive / Press Association Images / Press Association Images
Robbie Keane tells us constantly he can’t play on his own so I’ve gone for the classic big man/little man combo that should ensure we score many goals just like Ireland did against Germany in 2002. Omitting Roy Keane is a big call, but I like the balance that Whelan and Giles provide, and Roy wouldn’t be worth the hassle.
Given Irwin McGrath Dunne Staunton Brady Giles Ronnie Whelan Duff Robbie Keane Quinn
Do you agree with our writers' all-time Ireland XIs?
EARLIER IN THE week, Liam Brady, in an appearance on Second Captains Live, made the controversial decision to remove Roy Keane from ‘The Good Wall’ and replace him with John Giles.
The decision stirred up plenty of debate, not least in The42.ie office.
Consequently, we’ve decided to pick our all-time Ireland XIs in a bid to definitively separate the good Irish footballers from the great ones.
So here are the teams that our writers ultimately came up with…
Steve O’Rourke
Playing a traditional 4-4-2, this XI supports attacking creativity on a foundation of defensive invulnerability. The likes of Mick McCarthy and Ronnie Whelan could probably feel hard done by but I’d fancy this side to beat anyone, especially with the little ‘un/big ‘un combination up front.
Shay Given
Denis Irwin Paul McGrath Richard Dunne Steve Staunton
Ray Houghton Roy Keane Johnny Giles Liam Brady
Robbie Keane Niall Quinn
Eoin O’Callaghan
In theory, I don’t like naming a Best XI and including players I haven’t seen play.
But, for the purposes of this assignment and the general dearth of brilliant players Ireland have had during my lifetime, some just had to be included. Everyone is aware of the immense contributions made by Giles and Brady but other figures like Noel Cantwell and Johnny Carey were immense characters. They may not have the cap-count that other less-decorated players have but quality over quantity everytime. There’s a stylish central defensive pairing while the midfield speaks for itself.
The attack is a different beast. I wanted to allow Keane & Giles the space to dictate a game so have gone with a 4-2-3-1 with Houghton and Sheedy providing some width and Brady given the freedom to combine with a young, fresh and willing Robbie Keane.
Shay Given
Noel Cantwell
Johnny Carey
Paul McGrath
Denis Irwin
Roy Keane
John Giles
Ray Houghton
Kevin Sheedy
Liam Brady
Robbie Keane
Paul Fennessy
Shay Given gets in just ahead of Pat Bonner in goals. Defence was particularly tricky to choose, with Steve Staunton, Dave O’Leary and Richard Dunne among those unlucky to miss out.
Three out of four midfielders are straightforward enough picks, with Giles, Brady and Keane almost impossible to leave out, while Ronnie Whelan gets the fourth spot, ahead of other once-great players including Damien Duff and Ray Houghton.
Robbie Keane deserves to be up front for his phenomenal goalscoring record alone, while Frank Stapleton joins him, despite stiff competition from the likes of Niall Quinn, John Aldridge and Tony Cascarino.
Shay Given
Finnan McGrath Lawrenson Irwin
Giles Ronnie Whelan Roy Keane Brady
Robbie Keane Stapleton
Sean Farrell
My team is gonna play ball. That’s why I’ve sacrificed some of the blood and thunder you might get with the Honey Monster in favour of the out-and-out comfort on the ball you get with Irwin, O’Shea and Staunton.
The midfield trip is pretty much inter-changeable and would pin defences into their own box mercilessly until they crack. While the 4-5-1 formation lacks a target man up top, Damien Duff is sure to win a ton of free kicks which Dinny and Stan can fight over/come to a sensible decision based on the best angle for their strong foot.
Shay Given
Denis Irwin (Capt.) Paul McGrath John O’Shea Steve Staunton
Roy Keane Liam Brady
Ray Houghton John Giles Damien Duff
Robbie Keane
Will Slattery
Robbie Keane tells us constantly he can’t play on his own so I’ve gone for the classic big man/little man combo that should ensure we score many goals just like Ireland did against Germany in 2002. Omitting Roy Keane is a big call, but I like the balance that Whelan and Giles provide, and Roy wouldn’t be worth the hassle.
Given
Irwin McGrath Dunne Staunton
Brady Giles Ronnie Whelan Duff
Robbie Keane Quinn
LOI Division 1 wrap: Leaders Athlone come undone against Wexford Youths>
10-man Bohemians defeat Drogheda in game mired by controversy>
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
All Time Do you agree Have your say Liam Brady Roy Keane Ireland Republic Writers XIs