IT WAS THE hottest of takes on Sunday evening. For the Carolina Panthers to lose at home to the Minnesota Vikings โ bereft of their starting quarterback and franchise running back โ it must have had something to do with the protests going on outside Bank of America Stadium.
The city of Charlotte had been on high alert for nearly a week as protesters gathered downtown to mark the shooting dead of 43-year-old Keith Lamont Scott by a Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer.
Those tensions escalated further on Wednesday of last week when another man โ Justin Carr โ died after sustaining gunshot wounds as the protests turned violent.
In the wake of the second death, North Carolina Governor, Pat McCrory, declared a state of emergency and there was even talk of moving the game from Charlotte.
However, it went ahead on Sunday and the only protest involved 100 people kneeling outside the stadium as the national anthem played.
Inside the stadium, and to surprise of some as he wore a Martin Luther King quote on his t-shirt in the warm-up, Carolina Quarterback Cam Newton did not take a knee during the Stars and Stripes.
Indeed, the only protest against the anthem came from Panthers safety Marcus Ball raising his fist.
At the press conference after the game, an encounter in which they were resoundingly beaten by a rival for the NFC title, Ron Rivera was asked repeatedly if the events in Charlotte during the week had affected the teamโs build-up to the fixture.
โI donโt think thatโs fair,โ he said.
โWhen we are here, we practise and we do the things we are supposed to do. We got out and answered the questions. What happened here was very tragic and what we were hoping to do was come out and put that aside for a while. We just didnโt play very well.โ
The loss leaves Carolina with as many defeats as they had all of last season but they can take some heart from the fact that both came at the hands of probable playoff teams. But there are bigger things than sport at play here.
Athletes protesting is nothing new. Indeed, black athletes in particular often find themselves having to take a stand on social justice issues.
But the reason that the likes of Muhammad Ali and Jackie Robinson are held in such high esteem and Colin Kaepernick is regarded as the most hated athlete in America is because we like our protests to be in the past.
Itโs much easier to criticise our predecessors than take a look at ourselves and how we โ the human race โ have fostered a society where the simple act of taking a knee during a song provokes such hatred and anger when the extra-judicial killing of unarmed black Americans he is protesting is often greeted with a shrug of the shoulders.
Last week, former Super Bowl winning head coach โ not to mention Hall of Fame tight end โ Mike Ditka told a radio station in Dallas that Kaepernick should โget the hell outโ of America.
Mike Ditka is an idiot.
How else could you explain the following statement:
I have no respect for Colin Kaepernick โ he probably has no respect for me, thatโs his choice. My choice is, I like this country, I respect our flag, and I donโt see all the atrocities going on in this country that people say are going on.โ
The undercurrent of Ditkaโs argument, one he may not even realise heโs making himself, is that Kaepernick and people like him, whose ancestors were slaves, who were uprooted from their own country and upon whose blood and sweat the United States of America was built, should leave.
Itโs exactly that attitude, this othering of black Americans by people who know nothing of their struggles, that has led us to this situation.
Last week also produced another, far more interesting take on the Kaepernick protest from Richard Sherman, Seattle Seahawks defensive back and no friend of the San Francisco 49ers quarterback.
Earlier this month, Sherman supported Kaepernick but suggested he maybe could have chosen a different form of protest.
In August he said:
โThis country is the same country that had โwhitesโ and โcolouredโ signs on the bathroom.
โWeโre still in that country, weโre still in that nation. And that needs to be acknowledged and that needs to be changed. There are people with that mentality that still exists, and that needs to change. There are people who still treat people of colour with subjectivity.
โThey treat them a certain way. They categorise them. They put them in a certain category. There are certain statistics that are put out there to make sure police profile certain people in certain neighborhoods, and that needs to change.
โSo there is some depth and some truth to what heโs doing.
I think he could have picked a better platform and a better way to do it, but every day they say athletes are so robotic and do everything by the book. And then when somebody takes a stand like that, he gets his head chopped off.โ
Last week, after more deaths, his tone was angrier:
โI think the last couple of days a couple more guys have gotten shot and killed in the middle of the street.
โMore videos have come out of guys getting killed, and I think people are still missing the point. Itโs not right for people to get killed in the street.
I think you have players that are trying to take a stand and trying to be aware of social issues and try to make a stand and increase peopleโs awareness and put a spotlight on it and theyโre being ignored.
โWhether theyโre taking a knee or whether theyโre locking arms, theyโre trying to bring people together and unite them for a cause.โ
How history will judge Kaepernick remains to be seen but Ali was widely vilified when he chose not to fight in the Vietnam war and his death earlier this year produced millions of words in tribute to the boxer.
Of course, youโre probably thinking to yourself that thereโs a massive difference between being the best boxer to ever live and a back-up quarterback with one of the worst teams in the NFL.
But it shouldnโt matter. Colin Kaepernick has right on his side and, as long as unarmed black Americans continue to be killed on the streets, more and more players will take a stand by taking a knee.
Jaysus Murray. You must have been typing since the weekend! Looks like a great article. Fair play.
Murray I dunno how your not doing TV punditry or backroom analysis with a provincial or AIL set up. Your level of attention to detail is phenomenal and makes for fantastic reading. Keep it up.
@Dara รโMhaoilmhiaigh:
This is the best analysis I have seen anywhere, he should be in TV Punditry or better again a professional coaching setup, the attention to detail is excellent on all phases of play shown. I particularly liked the analysis of the first try driving maul and the attention on detail of how Sexton directs play in a way that cannot come true on real time viewing.
@ktsiwot: He was working with TV3 for the world cup, was he not?
@Shanahan: He was.
Jaysus thats some article. You could print that and have a 200 page book
Wait until the home leg is over before we tell them how we did itโฆit would take 2wks to read that tho :)
Good man murrary.
This isnโt an article on how Ireland beat New Zealand, Itโs a thesis. Looking forward to reading it but will probably take to until the rematch to get through it all.
Great analysis. Keep em coming!
Thatโs the kind of in depth analysis that is missing โ new players, kids, dads etc need more than a refs decision to understand why things happen on the field. Rugby is a far more intricate game than most people realise. Great article, keep it up!
Yawnโฆโฆโฆโฆ.
@Nick Drake: Go to bed.
Murray analyses all of Irelandโs games with the same level of detail, regardless of the opposition or result
Outstanding as ever Murray.
I hope thereโs none of the allblacks coaching team reading this.
It was a glorified exhibition match. Get over it. Cringeworthy level of analysis for a game of egg chasing.
You should consider changing your egg supplier. Iโm fairly sure a rugby ball got its oval shape from a pigโs bladder
I wonder could a smiling style of article be written about referees decisions? If you were to take an average weekend and pick out a bunch of decisions from them that people may have found dodgy and break down why it is or isnโt so. Maybe you cud do two or three of both good and bad. Itโd be good reading for those seriously interested in all facets of rugby and could educate a lot of people. The ref can make or break a game at times, I think good analysis in the media could do some good as well.
Dessie alternative read โ we scored more points than them.
Christmas analysis book next year please Murray.
Simply put, the power of 8โฆ
Great stuff, Murray, grma!!!
Love these articles. Dunno how the other hasnโt been snapped up as some teams video analyst. Level of detail here is really superb.
well done . i wish ireland would feel confident they can beat these all blacks they really had no respect for ireland that day.,with the team theyfielded only to bring in big guns at late stage all world except new zewland love to see ireland win again as ab think they have a god giving right to win all games . their times is up like the french rest incl ireland have seen where they are weak . congrats ireland do it again without fear . you have skilled soldiers to beat them again,, but mebe not sat as they will be in a revenge mode i fear . but ireland will have to treat them just like any other world team. ireland are strong and are colnfident now
I love these breakdowns. Superb work Murray!
Great work Murray